Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I love it. I had a double decker piece(s) for breakfast. Whipped cream between the layers and on top.

I like your style.

Thank you!! My beloved sister-in-law taught me this morning-after-Thanksgiving delight on one of the first holidays I spent with her. It’s genius.

Anonymous wrote:Our homemade pumpkin pie was kinda sunken and dense this year. What did we do wrong?

Not enough eggs or evaporated milk?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I love it. I had a double decker piece(s) for breakfast. Whipped cream between the layers and on top.

I like your style.

+1. I think the clouds just parted and angels sang!

Anonymous wrote:I tried the Costco pumpkin pie this year and actually liked it.

It’s the Libby’s recipe. We all love it morning, noon and night!

Anonymous wrote:I hate it. The first time I tried it, I mistakenly thought it was sweet potato. It was so Not sweet potato.

I had the opposite experience. I grew up loving pumpkin, but hate sweet potato. The first time I had sweet potato pie was at a bake sale and I mistakenly thought it was pumpkin. It was so NOT pumpkin.

I think it’s that they seem like they should be similar, and they’re not. If you have a preexisting preference for one, that establishes an expectation for that pleasureable experience, and a contrasting taste comes as a rude shock.

I hate it. The first time I tried it, I mistakenly thought it was sweet potato. It was so Not sweet potato.

Anonymous wrote:I love it. I had a double decker piece(s) for breakfast. Whipped cream between the layers and on top.

I like your style.

I prefer sweet potato.

Our homemade pumpkin pie was kinda sunken and dense this year. What did we do wrong?

I love it. I had a double decker piece(s) for breakfast. Whipped cream between the layers and on top.

Anonymous wrote:We love it, too, OP!

It is my (adult) daughter’s favorite Thanksgiving food!

Anonymous wrote:Gross. Didn't even have one at Thanksgiving this year. Nobody missed it. It's such a mediocre dessert, not worth the calories.

You haven’t had MY pumpkin pie. It’s delicious!

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Gross. Didn't even have one at Thanksgiving this year. Nobody missed it. It's such a mediocre dessert, not worth the calories.

No that is mashed potatoes.

I'm with you pp and always feel alone. I only make the potatoes for everyone else!

Anonymous wrote:Love it. It is really good if you eat it with pecan pie.

In the same mouthful? Hmmmm, trying this tomorrow.

I love it but only in small quantities with plenty of whipped cream. I hope you have pie for breakfast to tomorrow, OP!