Anonymous wrote:OP you have ruined my day. I’ve used this for decades and didn’t know it was discontinued! Wondering if I can hunt down some leftover bottles at CVS before it disappears forever.

NP. I have been trying to find it at local stores to no avail. Let me know if anyone finds it anywhere. I agree that I have used this for many years and there is nothing that compares. It looks like you can still get it on Amazon but I don’t trust their beauty stuff.

Weirdly, Aldi has their own brand of this. I wonder if they will keep making it.

Anonymous wrote:How about Neutrogena Ultra Gentle Daily Foaming Facial Cleanser for Sensitive Skin?

I am also looking for a replacement for the above mentioned product and the ultra gentle Neutrogena product does not remove makeup so was a disappointment to me.

I second the Clinique recommendation. It's creamy, foamy, and one wash will remove makeup throughly, including eyeliner and mascara.

You can use it alone, or for those who find it drying you can follow up with a regular face wash to address whatever issues.

I really like First Aid Beauty Pure cleanser

Go to Amazon

I have been so sad about this! This cleanser is the only one that my three daughters and I used. I realized it was going away when I couldn't find it and its dupe at Walmart. I bought about 6 at amazon right away. I am still looking for a good replacement. Let me know what you find!

Vanicream foaming cleanser is my HG

Anonymous wrote:Cerave foaming cleanser for normal to oily skin is different from the creamier ones, which don’t seem to get my face clean.

The only one I like is the cream to foam one for normal to dry skin (and it is different from their other normal or dry skin cleansers)

https://www.cerave.com/skincare/cleansers/hydrating-cream-to-foam-cleanser

Cerave foaming cleanser for normal to oily skin is different from the creamier ones, which don’t seem to get my face clean.

This is all very helpful everyone. I’ve been on the hunt for this forming cleanser as well with no luck. I’ll try some of the suggestions as well.

Thank you. 💕

OP....did you find another product that you like and is comparable to Neutrogena Fresh Foaming Cleanser? Like you, I have been using this cleanser for years and am very disappointed that it has been discontinued. I am on my last bottle and need to find a comparable replacement.

I used this forever for the same reasons. You can use the Neutrogena Hydrating Cleanser (ok to rub on eyes) and some neutrogena makeup remover wipes for the leftover eyemakeup.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Have you tried the Clinique Foaming Facial Cream? I like it, but have to use it sparingly as it dries me out. I just like the way it feels on my face.

I have not - is it good for removing eye makeup?

It removes everything I have on, but I'm not a major eye makeup wearer, usually just some blah shades of shadow.

https://www.clinique.com/product/1673/31385/skincare/cleansers-makeup-removers/all-about-cleantm-foaming-facial-soap?size=150_ml

Order a bunch until they’re sold out.

Cerave foaming cleanser.