This is op and thank you for all the suggestions! I'll definitely go back to a running store but also have done great recs I can actually try at the store too if they carry them. One of the challenges with the running store I went to was limited stock so trying a different one makes sense. And to the pp who I asked what I was looking for - I know I don't run a lot but I do really enjoy it and am trying to focus on having good form/stride and making sure my shoes are comfortable. These ones I have feel heavy for me so that's why I was curious for a new option.

Anonymous wrote:I would go to a running store. I am about your size and wear asics gt2000 which helps with my shin splints, and i use profoot inserts to help with plantar fasciitis. I got fitted by Pacers in Old Town

+1 on ASICS running shoes. I tried many models and they are all great. Currently my favorite are Cumulus. They are around $120-130. I used to get shin splints with other shoes.

I too am a Hoka person and I just splurged on the new Bondi 8 model. It feels like it has a firmer mid-sole than the earlier Bondis. I love them!!

If you want cushion the answer is Hokas. Nothing squishier.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Agree with going to a running store. I like Brooks Ghost or Brooks Launch but you will want to get someone to look at your pronation, strike and gait before committing.

I have the Brooks Ghost. Very happy with them. I have a neutral step, so neither pronator or supinator

I'm a neutral runner, and these are my favorites, too. OP, I echo everyone else -- maybe try a different running store.