Montreal Bagels from St. Viateur, sweeter than NYC bagels.
But if you prefer NYC, Russ and Daughters
We've done Lou Malnati's Chicago pizza and it's been great
We send our ex new yorkers bagels and lox and whitefish from Russ and Daughters. There's also a cheesecake made by nuns that's great and soup and kreplach from pastrami queen.
I used it for the first time this Christmas, ordered pastries from some small Maine bakery for a bunch of different family members with a Maine connection. Last-minute order at the holidays, shipping all over the country - everything arrived quickly and got a hugely positive response. From what I could see via Facetime videos, the packages were larger than I would have guessed from the photos (usually it's the opposite.)