Anonymous
Post 11/25/2020 19:15     Subject: HBO The Undoing
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Remember how Jonathan admitted to the lawyer he’d had another, previous affair? That detail must be in there for a reason. Maybe we’ll meet the first other woman.


Wonder if it was Sylvia.


Hmmmm!!
Anonymous
Post 11/25/2020 18:17     Subject: HBO The Undoing
Anonymous wrote:Remember how Jonathan admitted to the lawyer he’d had another, previous affair? That detail must be in there for a reason. Maybe we’ll meet the first other woman.


Wonder if it was Sylvia.
Anonymous
Post 11/25/2020 17:21     Subject: HBO The Undoing
Anonymous wrote:Is it possible it’s someone we don’t even know about? Like, another artist/neighbor on the building? Robbery gone bad?


I will definitely be annoyed if that’s the cases. The most recent season of True Detective did that and the last episode was like a deflating balloon after building tons of suspense.
Anonymous
Post 11/25/2020 16:07     Subject: HBO The Undoing
Remember how Jonathan admitted to the lawyer he’d had another, previous affair? That detail must be in there for a reason. Maybe we’ll meet the first other woman.
Anonymous
Post 11/24/2020 20:45     Subject: HBO The Undoing
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Is it possible it’s someone we don’t even know about? Like, another artist/neighbor on the building? Robbery gone bad?


Or a hit job by grandpa bc he knew Jonathan was having an affair


Yes! Not by him, directly, of course. One hires people for such things.
Anonymous
Post 11/24/2020 20:12     Subject: HBO The Undoing
Anonymous wrote:Is it possible it’s someone we don’t even know about? Like, another artist/neighbor on the building? Robbery gone bad?


Or a hit job by grandpa bc he knew Jonathan was having an affair
Anonymous
Post 11/24/2020 20:11     Subject: HBO The Undoing
Is it possible it’s someone we don’t even know about? Like, another artist/neighbor on the building? Robbery gone bad?
Anonymous
Post 11/24/2020 18:56     Subject: HBO The Undoing
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I think the blond friend also had an affair with Jonathan, was jealous of the other woman (including her spectacular breasts), did it and wanted to frame Jonathan.

The hammer in the violin case is a red herring. Henry found it, thought it was the murder weapon and hid it.


This is an interesting theory.

I love that this show still has 4-5 plausible murderers in the last episode! Excellent “whodunnit” series.



This is my theory, too (the blonde lawyer friend did it). This means that if that's the case I'm going to be pissed that I so easily figured it out
Anonymous
Post 11/24/2020 15:30     Subject: Re:HBO The Undoing
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I love reading all of the theories here. This series has been one of my favorites of the year in terms of story, characters, settings, styling etc. - so entertaining overall And the attorney - boy does she steal the show. Can't wait for the finale.


I’ve found the attorney to be completely unrealistic fan service.


The attorney friend looks like Corey Feldman.

The AA attorney is my fav.
Anonymous
Post 11/24/2020 15:20     Subject: HBO The Undoing
So maybe Jonathan did it and concealed the weapon to make it look like the kid did it and the mother will take the wrap.

Or maybe that's too far fetched.

maybe the mother did it.

Maybe its like an expensive version of CSI
Anonymous
Post 11/24/2020 14:51     Subject: HBO The Undoing
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Sutherland's eyebrows would have prevented him from seeing clearly enough to hit her in the head so many times. He is innocent.


Thank you for the laugh! I admit to thinking "why doesn't whoever cuts his hair trim those for him?"


Men get a pass on these things, unfairly.
Anonymous
Post 11/24/2020 14:45     Subject: HBO The Undoing
Anonymous wrote:Sutherland's eyebrows would have prevented him from seeing clearly enough to hit her in the head so many times. He is innocent.


Thank you for the laugh! I admit to thinking "why doesn't whoever cuts his hair trim those for him?"
Anonymous
Post 11/24/2020 14:44     Subject: Re:HBO The Undoing
I think Hugh Grant and Donald Sutherland's characters were actually having an affair, and Elena found out and began blackmailing both of them.
To shut her up, Sutherland got her into the fancy school.
The affair with Grant and the illegitimate kid are red herrings.
Anonymous
Post 11/24/2020 14:40     Subject: HBO The Undoing
That was a very clean looking hammer.
Anonymous
Post 11/24/2020 13:34     Subject: HBO The Undoing
Anonymous wrote:I think the blond friend also had an affair with Jonathan, was jealous of the other woman (including her spectacular breasts), did it and wanted to frame Jonathan.

The hammer in the violin case is a red herring. Henry found it, thought it was the murder weapon and hid it.


This is an interesting theory.

I love that this show still has 4-5 plausible murderers in the last episode! Excellent “whodunnit” series.