Anonymous
Post 11/23/2020 10:32     Subject: Where did McLean go wrong?
McLean won U19 ECNL national championship in 2018 and lost in National finals in 2019. They were #1 seed last year before Covid canceled nationals.
Anonymous
Post 11/23/2020 10:32     Subject: Where did McLean go wrong?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:There is validity to the argument that the new landscape hurts McLean's ability to dominate. Girs have multiple options to play on strong teams w/good coaches. But let's be serious for a moment:

1. MU is a dead man walking.
2. 0Arlington does not have a track record of producing elite DI players.
3. BRYC has produced a select number of DI players but they will suffer from the same dynamics impacting McLean.
4. Loudoun will always lose out to either FCV or McLean.
5. VDA has potential and does not face the same level of competition for players as Loudoun, FCV, McLean and Arlington.


Point #5 here is interesting as the VDA 06G spanked Loudoun twice (plus a third time if you count scrimmage) by combined score of 8-1 and VDA beat McLean twice by combined score of 5-1. Can't make generalizations at all across all age groups. VDA doesn't play FCV or Arlington (DA). So, trash your list and start over if able. I know, I know... 03, 04, 05... blah blah. But, you can't make a statement like #5 and then get destroyed on the point.

Let's not forget that two years ago VDA 06G went to Nationals Championship game in San Diego only to lose to PDA Blue. How often does NOVA clubs go to National Championship games? #trashlist


NP - but PP likely meant #5 to show that VDA doesn’t have to worry about losing players to close geographic competition. Kids can swap between BRYC/Arlington/McLean pretty easily, since they are geographically close. Loudoun lost players to FCV. Who is the closest real competing club for VDA? It would be a long drive.
Anonymous
Post 11/23/2020 09:17     Subject: Where did McLean go wrong?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:There is validity to the argument that the new landscape hurts McLean's ability to dominate. Girs have multiple options to play on strong teams w/good coaches. But let's be serious for a moment:

1. MU is a dead man walking.
2. 0Arlington does not have a track record of producing elite DI players.
3. BRYC has produced a select number of DI players but they will suffer from the same dynamics impacting McLean.
4. Loudoun will always lose out to either FCV or McLean.
5. VDA has potential and does not face the same level of competition for players as Loudoun, FCV, McLean and Arlington.


Point #5 here is interesting as the VDA 06G spanked Loudoun twice (plus a third time if you count scrimmage) by combined score of 8-1 and VDA beat McLean twice by combined score of 5-1. Can't make generalizations at all across all age groups. VDA doesn't play FCV or Arlington (DA). So, trash your list and start over if able. I know, I know... 03, 04, 05... blah blah. But, you can't make a statement like #5 and then get destroyed on the point.

Let's not forget that two years ago VDA 06G went to Nationals Championship game in San Diego only to lose to PDA Blue. How often does NOVA clubs go to National Championship games? #trashlist


McLean won a U18 national championship in 2018 and went deep into the playoffs in 2019 I believe.
Anonymous
Post 11/23/2020 08:34     Subject: Where did McLean go wrong?
Anonymous wrote:There is validity to the argument that the new landscape hurts McLean's ability to dominate. Girs have multiple options to play on strong teams w/good coaches. But let's be serious for a moment:

1. MU is a dead man walking.
2. 0Arlington does not have a track record of producing elite DI players.
3. BRYC has produced a select number of DI players but they will suffer from the same dynamics impacting McLean.
4. Loudoun will always lose out to either FCV or McLean.
5. VDA has potential and does not face the same level of competition for players as Loudoun, FCV, McLean and Arlington.


Point #5 here is interesting as the VDA 06G spanked Loudoun twice (plus a third time if you count scrimmage) by combined score of 8-1 and VDA beat McLean twice by combined score of 5-1. Can't make generalizations at all across all age groups. VDA doesn't play FCV or Arlington (DA). So, trash your list and start over if able. I know, I know... 03, 04, 05... blah blah. But, you can't make a statement like #5 and then get destroyed on the point.

Let's not forget that two years ago VDA 06G went to Nationals Championship game in San Diego only to lose to PDA Blue. How often does NOVA clubs go to National Championship games? #trashlist
Anonymous
Post 11/23/2020 08:15     Subject: Where did McLean go wrong?
There is validity to the argument that the new landscape hurts McLean's ability to dominate. Girs have multiple options to play on strong teams w/good coaches. But let's be serious for a moment:

1. MU is a dead man walking.
2. 0Arlington does not have a track record of producing elite DI players.
3. BRYC has produced a select number of DI players but they will suffer from the same dynamics impacting McLean.
4. Loudoun will always lose out to either FCV or McLean.
5. VDA has potential and does not face the same level of competition for players as Loudoun, FCV, McLean and Arlington.
Anonymous
Post 11/22/2020 22:29     Subject: Where did McLean go wrong?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Spoken like an Arlington or FCV parent. I wonder why those NC clubs chose to return to ECNL over GAL


Probably so they could spank crappy Va ECNL teams to have plenty of video for college coaches.


Is that why y'all prefer the higher goal differential of GA?
Anonymous
Post 11/22/2020 21:24     Subject: Where did McLean go wrong?
Anonymous wrote:Spoken like an Arlington or FCV parent. I wonder why those NC clubs chose to return to ECNL over GAL


Probably so they could spank crappy Va ECNL teams to have plenty of video for college coaches.
Anonymous
Post 11/22/2020 19:36     Subject: Where did McLean go wrong?
Spoken like an Arlington or FCV parent. I wonder why those NC clubs chose to return to ECNL over GAL
Anonymous
Post 11/22/2020 18:33     Subject: Where did McLean go wrong?
Anonymous wrote:Mid-Atl ECNL is the strongest girls league that a team in VA could be in. Certainly stronger than mid-Atl GAL

Very debatable.

Mediocre teams except for the NC teams that moved over from the DA
Anonymous
Post 11/22/2020 12:30     Subject: Where did McLean go wrong?
^right...McLean ahead of VDA
Anonymous
Post 11/22/2020 11:29     Subject: Where did McLean go wrong?
Anonymous wrote:McLean girl teams are above VDA in the ECNL standings in 4 of 6 age groups


1 age group from being split 3/3. In the 17s Mclean is one match ahead of VDA but have played 1 extra match.
Anonymous
Post 11/22/2020 07:58     Subject: Where did McLean go wrong?
Mid-Atl ECNL is the strongest girls league that a team in VA could be in. Certainly stronger than mid-Atl GAL
Anonymous
Post 11/22/2020 07:23     Subject: Where did McLean go wrong?
Anonymous wrote:McLean girl teams are above VDA in the ECNL standings in 4 of 6 age groups


In Mid Atlantic Ecnl, that’s like being first place in the losers bracket.
Anonymous
Post 11/22/2020 07:18     Subject: Where did McLean go wrong?
McLean girl teams are above VDA in the ECNL standings in 4 of 6 age groups
Anonymous
Post 11/21/2020 23:40     Subject: Where did McLean go wrong?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:How did 06 McLean team perform? Were they totally dominated by VDA?


VDA had 10 shots on goal to McLean's three. First few mins McLean came out fast and tried to play a VDA style game, but then VDA scored in 5 minutes. I'd say ball control was 60-40 to VDA with McLean's back line playing kick ball to get it away from the box. VDA was much better this game than their last meeting and the score line shows it.


VDA played above themselves because ether knew that they were trying out to make next year’s McLean team.




No one from VDA wants to join McLean. McLean going downhill.