Anonymous
Post 11/16/2014 22:16     Subject: Re:FCPS About to Propose Major Boundary Changes?
Can anyone please post the link to the proposed changes? I looked at the FCPS website and could not find the information.
Anonymous
Post 11/16/2014 22:06     Subject: Re:FCPS About to Propose Major Boundary Changes?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:16:31 here: I looked at this again and the documents suggest that the movement of kids who might be moved from Kilmer AAP to a new Thoreau AAP center would be "AAP students residing within the Thoreau MS attendance area" currently at Kilmer AAP (main summary document at p. 15).

I don't know how that could possibly involve 250 students (see Attachment C - Map 10 at p. 11). Most Thoreau kids go the the Jackson AAP center, not Kilmer. The only exception seems to be the Kilmer AAP kids at Freedom Hill and Stenwood who have Thoreau as their base school, and I don't think anywhere close to 250 kids fall in that category, since Kilmer is the base school for most Freedom Hill and Stenwood kids. That's what made me think this option must involve moving other Kilmer AAP kids to Thoreau. Guess the actual details would emerge later if that option got some real traction.


There are also AAP kids at Wolftrap Elementary who will go to Kilmer, as their AAP Center, then back to Madison. It'd be great if they made Thoreau the AAP Center for all Town of Vienna kids for space/capacity reasons, given the overcrowding at Kilmer with the AAP students.


How can we get the traction to align the Town of Vienna? Would contacting the town work? petition? The current zoning doesn't make sense and splits kids too much.


Honestly, I think you're wasting your time. Enrollment in the Madison pyramid is relatively stable and FCPS will have bigger issues to address than making sure every kid in the Town of Vienna, which does not own any schools like the City of Fairfax, can go to both Thoreau and Madison.

If you really wanted to do this, it might involve lobbying Pat Hynes to support the following:

- move every kid in the Town of Vienna now at either Wolftrap or Westbriar over to Vienna ES (and move part of Vienna ES over to Cunningham Park ES if necessary);

- move the part of Vienna ES outside the Town of Vienna to Freedom Hill ES and the part of the Town of Vienna at Freedom Hill over to Vienna ES;

- expand the boundaries for Thoreau, so that every Town kid goes to Thoreau (can be pitched as relieving overcrowding at Kilmer); and

- support the introduction of AAP at Thoreau

Net result: straight feeder of Vienna ES to Kilmer/Madison and Freedom Hill ES to Kilmer/Marshall, and straight feeder of every Town kid to Thoreau/Madison. There would still be split feeders at other schools like Cunningham Park and Marshall Road, but that is the case today.


Doesn't Cunningham Park all goes to Thoreau and then splits to Madison and Marshall? I thought some of Stenwood went to Thoreau too, but might be mistaken. I'm not sure why those families want to stay with Thoreau as their middle school and then move to Marshall. Thoreau is closer and sometimes even in their backyard, but Thoreau and Kilmer are two other schools about 1 mile apart from each other. I'd rather go to middle school with kids going to my high school.


Yes, half of Stenwood students go to Thoreau and the other half go to Klimer. But they all meet back up at Marshall. Go figure...
Anonymous
Post 11/12/2014 21:30     Subject: FCPS About to Propose Major Boundary Changes?
Stringfellow is one of the roads that divides the zones for the base school. So the houses across and beyond stringfellow road that includes autumn glory way, poplar tree etc., are zoned for poplar tree regularly and GBW for aap.
Anonymous
Post 11/11/2014 23:29     Subject: Re:FCPS About to Propose Major Boundary Changes?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Video of today's work session (almost 3 hours in length) is now posted.

http://youtu.be/JNS39yDmzCE


What is condensed version?


Only thing close to a done deal is Poplar Tree and Greenbriar West.



Can someone please explain what is decided about Poplar Tree and GBW?


Nothing is decided yet. The only thing close -- and it is NOT decided yet -- is a new AAP Center at Poplar Tree, which would relieve some of the overcrowding at Greenbriar West.

IF this happens (and no one knows yet as it is not decided), the new AAP Center at Poplar Tree would be in place for 2015-2016 school year (September 2015).

I am guessing there would be some sort of grandfathering for current 5th graders at Greenbriar West with Poplar Tree as their base school. But no one knows yet.



Does anyone know why they don't think about making Colin Powell a center instead as Poplar Tree and keep Poplar Tree AAP kids in GBW since it is closer to GBW and busing is easier than Colin Powell?


They identified that as a potential option as well, but Powell already has a big enrollment (almost 960 kids this year) whereas Poplar Tree is under 600.


I do not understand zoning since houses on Bebe court, Veronica lane , Marshall crown lane are zoned in GBW where as houses near poplar tree , autumn glory way and walney road are zoned to poplar tree. Any idea why?
Anonymous
Post 11/11/2014 20:58     Subject: FCPS About to Propose Major Boundary Changes?
The heat maps presentation slides (used by Kevin Sneed in the work session) are now posted on BoardDocs.

http://www.boarddocs.com/vsba/fairfax/Board.nsf/files/9QRN5S5466CB/$file/NEW%20HEAT%20MAPS%20Presentation%20Manual.pdf


Anonymous
Post 11/11/2014 16:46     Subject: Re:FCPS About to Propose Major Boundary Changes?
Anonymous wrote:[quote]So if the projections are correct


Don't have much experience with FCPS, do you?


Ignore the projections, then. Just look at the current enrollments in the Madison and Marshall pyramids, and figure out whether that type of realignment that was being discussed (all Town of Vienna kids to Thoreau/Madison, all of Thoreau to Madison, all of Kilmer to Marshall, and AAP at Thoreau) would have a negative impact on any of the schools involved.

It clearly would be a good thing to balance the enrollments at Kilmer and Thoreau, and it doesn't seem like it would have a negative impact on either Madison or Marshall. Each would both gain and lose a few neighborhoods.

But, again, it's all hypothetical, in response to the posters who asked how this could happen or complained about the current feeder patterns. If FCPS is dealing with bigger issues, it won't get around to something like this any time soon.
Anonymous
Post 11/11/2014 16:33     Subject: Re:FCPS About to Propose Major Boundary Changes?
[quote]So if the projections are correct


Don't have much experience with FCPS, do you?
Anonymous
Post 11/11/2014 15:41     Subject: Re:FCPS About to Propose Major Boundary Changes?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Video of today's work session (almost 3 hours in length) is now posted.

http://youtu.be/JNS39yDmzCE


What is condensed version?


Only thing close to a done deal is Poplar Tree and Greenbriar West.



Can someone please explain what is decided about Poplar Tree and GBW?


Nothing is decided yet. The only thing close -- and it is NOT decided yet -- is a new AAP Center at Poplar Tree, which would relieve some of the overcrowding at Greenbriar West.

IF this happens (and no one knows yet as it is not decided), the new AAP Center at Poplar Tree would be in place for 2015-2016 school year (September 2015).

I am guessing there would be some sort of grandfathering for current 5th graders at Greenbriar West with Poplar Tree as their base school. But no one knows yet.



Does anyone know why they don't think about making Colin Powell a center instead as Poplar Tree and keep Poplar Tree AAP kids in GBW since it is closer to GBW and busing is easier than Colin Powell?


They identified that as a potential option as well, but Powell already has a big enrollment (almost 960 kids this year) whereas Poplar Tree is under 600.
Anonymous
Post 11/11/2014 14:59     Subject: Re:FCPS About to Propose Major Boundary Changes?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Video of today's work session (almost 3 hours in length) is now posted.

http://youtu.be/JNS39yDmzCE


What is condensed version?


Only thing close to a done deal is Poplar Tree and Greenbriar West.



Can someone please explain what is decided about Poplar Tree and GBW?


Nothing is decided yet. The only thing close -- and it is NOT decided yet -- is a new AAP Center at Poplar Tree, which would relieve some of the overcrowding at Greenbriar West.

IF this happens (and no one knows yet as it is not decided), the new AAP Center at Poplar Tree would be in place for 2015-2016 school year (September 2015).

I am guessing there would be some sort of grandfathering for current 5th graders at Greenbriar West with Poplar Tree as their base school. But no one knows yet.



Does anyone know why they don't think about making Colin Powell a center instead as Poplar Tree and keep Poplar Tree AAP kids in GBW since it is closer to GBW and busing is easier than Colin Powell?
Anonymous
Post 11/11/2014 14:13     Subject: Re:FCPS About to Propose Major Boundary Changes?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:16:31 here: I looked at this again and the documents suggest that the movement of kids who might be moved from Kilmer AAP to a new Thoreau AAP center would be "AAP students residing within the Thoreau MS attendance area" currently at Kilmer AAP (main summary document at p. 15).

I don't know how that could possibly involve 250 students (see Attachment C - Map 10 at p. 11). Most Thoreau kids go the the Jackson AAP center, not Kilmer. The only exception seems to be the Kilmer AAP kids at Freedom Hill and Stenwood who have Thoreau as their base school, and I don't think anywhere close to 250 kids fall in that category, since Kilmer is the base school for most Freedom Hill and Stenwood kids. That's what made me think this option must involve moving other Kilmer AAP kids to Thoreau. Guess the actual details would emerge later if that option got some real traction.


There are also AAP kids at Wolftrap Elementary who will go to Kilmer, as their AAP Center, then back to Madison. It'd be great if they made Thoreau the AAP Center for all Town of Vienna kids for space/capacity reasons, given the overcrowding at Kilmer with the AAP students.


How can we get the traction to align the Town of Vienna? Would contacting the town work? petition? The current zoning doesn't make sense and splits kids too much.


Honestly, I think you're wasting your time. Enrollment in the Madison pyramid is relatively stable and FCPS will have bigger issues to address than making sure every kid in the Town of Vienna, which does not own any schools like the City of Fairfax, can go to both Thoreau and Madison.

If you really wanted to do this, it might involve lobbying Pat Hynes to support the following:

- move every kid in the Town of Vienna now at either Wolftrap or Westbriar over to Vienna ES (and move part of Vienna ES over to Cunningham Park ES if necessary);

- move the part of Vienna ES outside the Town of Vienna to Freedom Hill ES and the part of the Town of Vienna at Freedom Hill over to Vienna ES;

- expand the boundaries for Thoreau, so that every Town kid goes to Thoreau (can be pitched as relieving overcrowding at Kilmer); and

- support the introduction of AAP at Thoreau

Net result: straight feeder of Vienna ES to Kilmer/Madison and Freedom Hill ES to Kilmer/Marshall, and straight feeder of every Town kid to Thoreau/Madison. There would still be split feeders at other schools like Cunningham Park and Marshall Road, but that is the case today.


There is no way I would support having only AAP kids attending Madison go to Thoreau instead of Kilmer. The percentage of Madison kids at Kilmer has already dropped lower than is acceptable to me. The boundaries should either align with the high school or be significant split such as 70/30 or 50/50.


So if the projections are correct and the Marshall pyramid is going to grow much faster now than the Madison pyramid (a big reversal from prior years), move the parts of Town of Vienna now at Kilmer to Thoreau, send all of Thoreau to Madison, send all of Kilmer to Marshall, and let Thoreau have its own AAP center.

But you'd still want to look at the elementary school assignments, because otherwise you'd be eliminating split feeders at the middle/high school levels while creating some odd ones at the elementary school level.
Anonymous
Post 11/11/2014 13:07     Subject: Re:FCPS About to Propose Major Boundary Changes?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:16:31 here: I looked at this again and the documents suggest that the movement of kids who might be moved from Kilmer AAP to a new Thoreau AAP center would be "AAP students residing within the Thoreau MS attendance area" currently at Kilmer AAP (main summary document at p. 15).

I don't know how that could possibly involve 250 students (see Attachment C - Map 10 at p. 11). Most Thoreau kids go the the Jackson AAP center, not Kilmer. The only exception seems to be the Kilmer AAP kids at Freedom Hill and Stenwood who have Thoreau as their base school, and I don't think anywhere close to 250 kids fall in that category, since Kilmer is the base school for most Freedom Hill and Stenwood kids. That's what made me think this option must involve moving other Kilmer AAP kids to Thoreau. Guess the actual details would emerge later if that option got some real traction.


There are also AAP kids at Wolftrap Elementary who will go to Kilmer, as their AAP Center, then back to Madison. It'd be great if they made Thoreau the AAP Center for all Town of Vienna kids for space/capacity reasons, given the overcrowding at Kilmer with the AAP students.


How can we get the traction to align the Town of Vienna? Would contacting the town work? petition? The current zoning doesn't make sense and splits kids too much.


Honestly, I think you're wasting your time. Enrollment in the Madison pyramid is relatively stable and FCPS will have bigger issues to address than making sure every kid in the Town of Vienna, which does not own any schools like the City of Fairfax, can go to both Thoreau and Madison.

If you really wanted to do this, it might involve lobbying Pat Hynes to support the following:

- move every kid in the Town of Vienna now at either Wolftrap or Westbriar over to Vienna ES (and move part of Vienna ES over to Cunningham Park ES if necessary);

- move the part of Vienna ES outside the Town of Vienna to Freedom Hill ES and the part of the Town of Vienna at Freedom Hill over to Vienna ES;

- expand the boundaries for Thoreau, so that every Town kid goes to Thoreau (can be pitched as relieving overcrowding at Kilmer); and

- support the introduction of AAP at Thoreau

Net result: straight feeder of Vienna ES to Kilmer/Madison and Freedom Hill ES to Kilmer/Marshall, and straight feeder of every Town kid to Thoreau/Madison. There would still be split feeders at other schools like Cunningham Park and Marshall Road, but that is the case today.


There is no way I would support having only AAP kids attending Madison go to Thoreau instead of Kilmer. The percentage of Madison kids at Kilmer has already dropped lower than is acceptable to me. The boundaries should either align with the high school or be significant split such as 70/30 or 50/50.
Anonymous
Post 11/11/2014 13:06     Subject: Re:FCPS About to Propose Major Boundary Changes?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:16:31 here: I looked at this again and the documents suggest that the movement of kids who might be moved from Kilmer AAP to a new Thoreau AAP center would be "AAP students residing within the Thoreau MS attendance area" currently at Kilmer AAP (main summary document at p. 15).

I don't know how that could possibly involve 250 students (see Attachment C - Map 10 at p. 11). Most Thoreau kids go the the Jackson AAP center, not Kilmer. The only exception seems to be the Kilmer AAP kids at Freedom Hill and Stenwood who have Thoreau as their base school, and I don't think anywhere close to 250 kids fall in that category, since Kilmer is the base school for most Freedom Hill and Stenwood kids. That's what made me think this option must involve moving other Kilmer AAP kids to Thoreau. Guess the actual details would emerge later if that option got some real traction.


There are also AAP kids at Wolftrap Elementary who will go to Kilmer, as their AAP Center, then back to Madison. It'd be great if they made Thoreau the AAP Center for all Town of Vienna kids for space/capacity reasons, given the overcrowding at Kilmer with the AAP students.


How can we get the traction to align the Town of Vienna? Would contacting the town work? petition? The current zoning doesn't make sense and splits kids too much.


Honestly, I think you're wasting your time. Enrollment in the Madison pyramid is relatively stable and FCPS will have bigger issues to address than making sure every kid in the Town of Vienna, which does not own any schools like the City of Fairfax, can go to both Thoreau and Madison.

If you really wanted to do this, it might involve lobbying Pat Hynes to support the following:

- move every kid in the Town of Vienna now at either Wolftrap or Westbriar over to Vienna ES (and move part of Vienna ES over to Cunningham Park ES if necessary);

- move the part of Vienna ES outside the Town of Vienna to Freedom Hill ES and the part of the Town of Vienna at Freedom Hill over to Vienna ES;

- expand the boundaries for Thoreau, so that every Town kid goes to Thoreau (can be pitched as relieving overcrowding at Kilmer); and

- support the introduction of AAP at Thoreau

Net result: straight feeder of Vienna ES to Kilmer/Madison and Freedom Hill ES to Kilmer/Marshall, and straight feeder of every Town kid to Thoreau/Madison. There would still be split feeders at other schools like Cunningham Park and Marshall Road, but that is the case today.


Meant "straight feeder of Vienna ES to Thoreau/Madison"....


Vienna ES and Freedom Hill have very strange boundaries. The boundary should probably just be changed to align with the high school boundary. I think the same amount of kids go to Vienna ES and then to Marshall as the amount of kids who attend Freedom Hill and then go onto Madison.
Anonymous
Post 11/11/2014 13:04     Subject: Re:FCPS About to Propose Major Boundary Changes?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:16:31 here: I looked at this again and the documents suggest that the movement of kids who might be moved from Kilmer AAP to a new Thoreau AAP center would be "AAP students residing within the Thoreau MS attendance area" currently at Kilmer AAP (main summary document at p. 15).

I don't know how that could possibly involve 250 students (see Attachment C - Map 10 at p. 11). Most Thoreau kids go the the Jackson AAP center, not Kilmer. The only exception seems to be the Kilmer AAP kids at Freedom Hill and Stenwood who have Thoreau as their base school, and I don't think anywhere close to 250 kids fall in that category, since Kilmer is the base school for most Freedom Hill and Stenwood kids. That's what made me think this option must involve moving other Kilmer AAP kids to Thoreau. Guess the actual details would emerge later if that option got some real traction.


There are also AAP kids at Wolftrap Elementary who will go to Kilmer, as their AAP Center, then back to Madison. It'd be great if they made Thoreau the AAP Center for all Town of Vienna kids for space/capacity reasons, given the overcrowding at Kilmer with the AAP students.


How can we get the traction to align the Town of Vienna? Would contacting the town work? petition? The current zoning doesn't make sense and splits kids too much.


Honestly, I think you're wasting your time. Enrollment in the Madison pyramid is relatively stable and FCPS will have bigger issues to address than making sure every kid in the Town of Vienna, which does not own any schools like the City of Fairfax, can go to both Thoreau and Madison.

If you really wanted to do this, it might involve lobbying Pat Hynes to support the following:

- move every kid in the Town of Vienna now at either Wolftrap or Westbriar over to Vienna ES (and move part of Vienna ES over to Cunningham Park ES if necessary);

- move the part of Vienna ES outside the Town of Vienna to Freedom Hill ES and the part of the Town of Vienna at Freedom Hill over to Vienna ES;

- expand the boundaries for Thoreau, so that every Town kid goes to Thoreau (can be pitched as relieving overcrowding at Kilmer); and

- support the introduction of AAP at Thoreau

Net result: straight feeder of Vienna ES to Kilmer/Madison and Freedom Hill ES to Kilmer/Marshall, and straight feeder of every Town kid to Thoreau/Madison. There would still be split feeders at other schools like Cunningham Park and Marshall Road, but that is the case today.


Doesn't Cunningham Park all goes to Thoreau and then splits to Madison and Marshall? I thought some of Stenwood went to Thoreau too, but might be mistaken. I'm not sure why those families want to stay with Thoreau as their middle school and then move to Marshall. Thoreau is closer and sometimes even in their backyard, but Thoreau and Kilmer are two other schools about 1 mile apart from each other. I'd rather go to middle school with kids going to my high school.
Anonymous
Post 11/11/2014 12:49     Subject: Re:FCPS About to Propose Major Boundary Changes?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:16:31 here: I looked at this again and the documents suggest that the movement of kids who might be moved from Kilmer AAP to a new Thoreau AAP center would be "AAP students residing within the Thoreau MS attendance area" currently at Kilmer AAP (main summary document at p. 15).

I don't know how that could possibly involve 250 students (see Attachment C - Map 10 at p. 11). Most Thoreau kids go the the Jackson AAP center, not Kilmer. The only exception seems to be the Kilmer AAP kids at Freedom Hill and Stenwood who have Thoreau as their base school, and I don't think anywhere close to 250 kids fall in that category, since Kilmer is the base school for most Freedom Hill and Stenwood kids. That's what made me think this option must involve moving other Kilmer AAP kids to Thoreau. Guess the actual details would emerge later if that option got some real traction.


There are also AAP kids at Wolftrap Elementary who will go to Kilmer, as their AAP Center, then back to Madison. It'd be great if they made Thoreau the AAP Center for all Town of Vienna kids for space/capacity reasons, given the overcrowding at Kilmer with the AAP students.


How can we get the traction to align the Town of Vienna? Would contacting the town work? petition? The current zoning doesn't make sense and splits kids too much.


Honestly, I think you're wasting your time. Enrollment in the Madison pyramid is relatively stable and FCPS will have bigger issues to address than making sure every kid in the Town of Vienna, which does not own any schools like the City of Fairfax, can go to both Thoreau and Madison.

If you really wanted to do this, it might involve lobbying Pat Hynes to support the following:

- move every kid in the Town of Vienna now at either Wolftrap or Westbriar over to Vienna ES (and move part of Vienna ES over to Cunningham Park ES if necessary);

- move the part of Vienna ES outside the Town of Vienna to Freedom Hill ES and the part of the Town of Vienna at Freedom Hill over to Vienna ES;

- expand the boundaries for Thoreau, so that every Town kid goes to Thoreau (can be pitched as relieving overcrowding at Kilmer); and

- support the introduction of AAP at Thoreau

Net result: straight feeder of Vienna ES to Kilmer/Madison and Freedom Hill ES to Kilmer/Marshall, and straight feeder of every Town kid to Thoreau/Madison. There would still be split feeders at other schools like Cunningham Park and Marshall Road, but that is the case today.


Meant "straight feeder of Vienna ES to Thoreau/Madison"....
Anonymous
Post 11/11/2014 12:48     Subject: Re:FCPS About to Propose Major Boundary Changes?
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:16:31 here: I looked at this again and the documents suggest that the movement of kids who might be moved from Kilmer AAP to a new Thoreau AAP center would be "AAP students residing within the Thoreau MS attendance area" currently at Kilmer AAP (main summary document at p. 15).

I don't know how that could possibly involve 250 students (see Attachment C - Map 10 at p. 11). Most Thoreau kids go the the Jackson AAP center, not Kilmer. The only exception seems to be the Kilmer AAP kids at Freedom Hill and Stenwood who have Thoreau as their base school, and I don't think anywhere close to 250 kids fall in that category, since Kilmer is the base school for most Freedom Hill and Stenwood kids. That's what made me think this option must involve moving other Kilmer AAP kids to Thoreau. Guess the actual details would emerge later if that option got some real traction.


There are also AAP kids at Wolftrap Elementary who will go to Kilmer, as their AAP Center, then back to Madison. It'd be great if they made Thoreau the AAP Center for all Town of Vienna kids for space/capacity reasons, given the overcrowding at Kilmer with the AAP students.


How can we get the traction to align the Town of Vienna? Would contacting the town work? petition? The current zoning doesn't make sense and splits kids too much.


Honestly, I think you're wasting your time. Enrollment in the Madison pyramid is relatively stable and FCPS will have bigger issues to address than making sure every kid in the Town of Vienna, which does not own any schools like the City of Fairfax, can go to both Thoreau and Madison.

If you really wanted to do this, it might involve lobbying Pat Hynes to support the following:

- move every kid in the Town of Vienna now at either Wolftrap or Westbriar over to Vienna ES (and move part of Vienna ES over to Cunningham Park ES if necessary);

- move the part of Vienna ES outside the Town of Vienna to Freedom Hill ES and the part of the Town of Vienna at Freedom Hill over to Vienna ES;

- expand the boundaries for Thoreau, so that every Town kid goes to Thoreau (can be pitched as relieving overcrowding at Kilmer); and

- support the introduction of AAP at Thoreau

Net result: straight feeder of Vienna ES to Kilmer/Madison and Freedom Hill ES to Kilmer/Marshall, and straight feeder of every Town kid to Thoreau/Madison. There would still be split feeders at other schools like Cunningham Park and Marshall Road, but that is the case today.