Anonymous
12/11/2023 09:43
Subject: Why are Americans so defensive about America?
Did you ever consider that they criticize their own country all the time (I do:our out of control gun policies, politics, etc). But it is sometimes hard to hear people who chose to live here (vs are from here) go on and on about the deficiencies.
Seems sort of rude, and prompts the question (since they have a choice) about why they stay.
Seems sort of rude, and prompts the question (since they have a choice) about why they stay.
Anonymous
12/10/2023 19:10
Subject: Why are Americans so defensive about America?
Anonymous wrote:Most of the world is messed up even to this day because of European colonialism, remember that.
Funny how it's only European colonialism that is "evil" - funny how the violent and barbaric history of so many other massive waves of colonialism never get the same mention - such as violent Muslim conquest of vast swaths of land, Imperial Russian conquest and expansion into Asia, the Soviet cold war and Russia's continued attempts to destabilize Africa and create proxy states, Japanese and Chinese imperialism and colonialism in Asia and the Pacific, China's involvement in North Korea, Vietnam and other parts of Asia which destabilized nations and started wars, and continued attempts to get hooks throughout the world, Iran and its many proxies, like Houthis, Hezbollah and so on... And typically the people pointing the finger at "western/European/American" colonialism are solidly in the camp of Russia or China or some other party which is every bit as bad or worse.
Anonymous
12/10/2023 19:00
Subject: Why are Americans so defensive about America?
Anonymous wrote:Most of the world is messed up even to this day because of European colonialism, remember that.
Is it? Is Indonesia messed up today due to its colonial past? I’d say they’re doing a pretty good job despite it. What about Malaysia, Japan, China, India, Thailand? Are they pretty messed up?
Maybe you could clarify exactly what you mean by most of the world being messed up by colonialism.
Anonymous
12/10/2023 17:17
Subject: Why are Americans so defensive about America?
Some of you need to read the piece in the NYT why colonialism isn’t what’s going on in Israel-Palestine. Colonialism doesn’t really map to the history there. People who think it’s colonialism have a TikTok deep level understanding of history.
Anonymous
12/10/2023 17:15
Subject: Why are Americans so defensive about America?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Most of the world is messed up even to this day because of European colonialism, remember that.
The problem is you don’t know what the world would look like without European colonialism. It could be messed up in some other way. It’s not like there weren’t other empires (eg Mongols, Ottomans, various African empires, Arab conquests in India).
Thank God we had our white European saviors handing out small pox blankets to indians, chopping off hands of 5 year olds in Congo, ruling over all those people in India and burning down the gates of Beijing!
Anonymous
12/10/2023 16:58
Subject: Why are Americans so defensive about America?
Anonymous wrote:Most of the world is messed up even to this day because of European colonialism, remember that.
The problem is you don’t know what the world would look like without European colonialism. It could be messed up in some other way. It’s not like there weren’t other empires (eg Mongols, Ottomans, various African empires, Arab conquests in India).
Anonymous
12/10/2023 16:03
Subject: Why are Americans so defensive about America?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Most of the world is messed up even to this day because of European colonialism, remember that.
-Great Leap Forward famine
-African wars of the 90s (including Rwandan Genocide and Second Congo War)
-Emperor worship in Japan
-Black September (Jordan vs PLA)
-Red Guard killings and cannibalism
-Gang violence in El Salvador
-AIDS epidemic in Russia
- great leap: communism, a European invention, thanks
- African wars: wow, destabilized countries and warring factions because of European plundering of the continent. France lit people on fire in the streets of Algiers while Belgians murdered over a million and cut off the hands of thousands of children in Congo.
- emporer worship in Japan and imperial Japan: go read up on the history of the greater East Asia co prosperity sphere, which was in response to white westerners from Europe making a mess all over Asia, like the British bending over and reaming the Chinese for decades. Literally invented to insulate themselves from western imperialism and communist thought invented by the west.
- black September: literally of very little consequence to the world at large. No where near as damaging as the legacy of imperialism that has caused so many border disputes to this day.
- red guard killings: see above. Communism is a western invention from Europe.
- gang violence in El Salvador: El Salvador has been a mess ever since Spanish colonialism and since chaos broke out after Napoleon occupied Spain and the Spanish lost control over all of their colonies. Once again, the poison of communism that was invented by Europeans caused more civil wars in the later part of the 20th.
-AIDs in Russia: not sure what your point is here given that this is an internal health problem that affects little people outside the borders of Russia.
Now do India/Pakistan disputes, Israel/Palestine, Venezuela/Guyana, all of WW1 and WW2, and the list goes on and on. The world is thoroughly messed up because of Europeans and their colonialism.
Not sure why are you include communism on that list. Buddhism is an Asian ‘invention’ but nobody is forced to adopt it. It’s a little insulting to deny agency of people like the Chinese who chose to adopt communism. There are also plenty of people who might argue communism was a positive in certain countries. Isn’t it a very US perspective to say it was bad?
Alien vs The Predstor, time to fight it out! Which one of you is going to win the AmricanBad game? The critical race theorist or the communist?
I can only hope that many of the posters here are not Americans.
Anonymous
12/10/2023 16:01
Subject: Why are Americans so defensive about America?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Most of the world is messed up even to this day because of European colonialism, remember that.
-Great Leap Forward famine
-African wars of the 90s (including Rwandan Genocide and Second Congo War)
-Emperor worship in Japan
-Black September (Jordan vs PLA)
-Red Guard killings and cannibalism
-Gang violence in El Salvador
-AIDS epidemic in Russia
- great leap: communism, a European invention, thanks
- African wars: wow, destabilized countries and warring factions because of European plundering of the continent. France lit people on fire in the streets of Algiers while Belgians murdered over a million and cut off the hands of thousands of children in Congo.
- emporer worship in Japan and imperial Japan: go read up on the history of the greater East Asia co prosperity sphere, which was in response to white westerners from Europe making a mess all over Asia, like the British bending over and reaming the Chinese for decades. Literally invented to insulate themselves from western imperialism and communist thought invented by the west.
- black September: literally of very little consequence to the world at large. No where near as damaging as the legacy of imperialism that has caused so many border disputes to this day.
- red guard killings: see above. Communism is a western invention from Europe.
- gang violence in El Salvador: El Salvador has been a mess ever since Spanish colonialism and since chaos broke out after Napoleon occupied Spain and the Spanish lost control over all of their colonies. Once again, the poison of communism that was invented by Europeans caused more civil wars in the later part of the 20th.
-AIDs in Russia: not sure what your point is here given that this is an internal health problem that affects little people outside the borders of Russia.
Now do India/Pakistan disputes, Israel/Palestine, Venezuela/Guyana, all of WW1 and WW2, and the list goes on and on. The world is thoroughly messed up because of Europeans and their colonialism.
Not sure why are you include communism on that list. Buddhism is an Asian ‘invention’ but nobody is forced to adopt it. It’s a little insulting to deny agency of people like the Chinese who chose to adopt communism. There are also plenty of people who might argue communism was a positive in certain countries. Isn’t it a very US perspective to say it was bad?
Alien vs The Predstor, time to fight it out! Which one of you is going to win the AmricanBad game? The critical race theorist or the communist?
Anonymous
12/10/2023 15:59
Subject: Why are Americans so defensive about America?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Most of the world is messed up even to this day because of European colonialism, remember that.
-Great Leap Forward famine
-African wars of the 90s (including Rwandan Genocide and Second Congo War)
-Emperor worship in Japan
-Black September (Jordan vs PLA)
-Red Guard killings and cannibalism
-Gang violence in El Salvador
-AIDS epidemic in Russia
- great leap: communism, a European invention, thanks
- African wars: wow, destabilized countries and warring factions because of European plundering of the continent. France lit people on fire in the streets of Algiers while Belgians murdered over a million and cut off the hands of thousands of children in Congo.
- emporer worship in Japan and imperial Japan: go read up on the history of the greater East Asia co prosperity sphere, which was in response to white westerners from Europe making a mess all over Asia, like the British bending over and reaming the Chinese for decades. Literally invented to insulate themselves from western imperialism and communist thought invented by the west.
- black September: literally of very little consequence to the world at large. No where near as damaging as the legacy of imperialism that has caused so many border disputes to this day.
- red guard killings: see above. Communism is a western invention from Europe.
- gang violence in El Salvador: El Salvador has been a mess ever since Spanish colonialism and since chaos broke out after Napoleon occupied Spain and the Spanish lost control over all of their colonies. Once again, the poison of communism that was invented by Europeans caused more civil wars in the later part of the 20th.
-AIDs in Russia: not sure what your point is here given that this is an internal health problem that affects little people outside the borders of Russia.
Now do India/Pakistan disputes, Israel/Palestine, Venezuela/Guyana, all of WW1 and WW2, and the list goes on and on. The world is thoroughly messed up because of Europeans and their colonialism.
You treat white people like they are Satan, corrupting blameless people.
Anonymous
12/10/2023 15:17
Subject: Why are Americans so defensive about America?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Most of the world is messed up even to this day because of European colonialism, remember that.
-Great Leap Forward famine
-African wars of the 90s (including Rwandan Genocide and Second Congo War)
-Emperor worship in Japan
-Black September (Jordan vs PLA)
-Red Guard killings and cannibalism
-Gang violence in El Salvador
-AIDS epidemic in Russia
- great leap: communism, a European invention, thanks
- African wars: wow, destabilized countries and warring factions because of European plundering of the continent. France lit people on fire in the streets of Algiers while Belgians murdered over a million and cut off the hands of thousands of children in Congo.
- emporer worship in Japan and imperial Japan: go read up on the history of the greater East Asia co prosperity sphere, which was in response to white westerners from Europe making a mess all over Asia, like the British bending over and reaming the Chinese for decades. Literally invented to insulate themselves from western imperialism and communist thought invented by the west.
- black September: literally of very little consequence to the world at large. No where near as damaging as the legacy of imperialism that has caused so many border disputes to this day.
- red guard killings: see above. Communism is a western invention from Europe.
- gang violence in El Salvador: El Salvador has been a mess ever since Spanish colonialism and since chaos broke out after Napoleon occupied Spain and the Spanish lost control over all of their colonies. Once again, the poison of communism that was invented by Europeans caused more civil wars in the later part of the 20th.
-AIDs in Russia: not sure what your point is here given that this is an internal health problem that affects little people outside the borders of Russia.
Now do India/Pakistan disputes, Israel/Palestine, Venezuela/Guyana, all of WW1 and WW2, and the list goes on and on. The world is thoroughly messed up because of Europeans and their colonialism.
Not sure why are you include communism on that list. Buddhism is an Asian ‘invention’ but nobody is forced to adopt it. It’s a little insulting to deny agency of people like the Chinese who chose to adopt communism. There are also plenty of people who might argue communism was a positive in certain countries. Isn’t it a very US perspective to say it was bad?
Anonymous
12/10/2023 12:58
Subject: Why are Americans so defensive about America?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Most of the world is messed up even to this day because of European colonialism, remember that.
-Great Leap Forward famine
-African wars of the 90s (including Rwandan Genocide and Second Congo War)
-Emperor worship in Japan
-Black September (Jordan vs PLA)
-Red Guard killings and cannibalism
-Gang violence in El Salvador
-AIDS epidemic in Russia
- great leap: communism, a European invention, thanks
- African wars: wow, destabilized countries and warring factions because of European plundering of the continent. France lit people on fire in the streets of Algiers while Belgians murdered over a million and cut off the hands of thousands of children in Congo.
- emporer worship in Japan and imperial Japan: go read up on the history of the greater East Asia co prosperity sphere, which was in response to white westerners from Europe making a mess all over Asia, like the British bending over and reaming the Chinese for decades. Literally invented to insulate themselves from western imperialism and communist thought invented by the west.
- black September: literally of very little consequence to the world at large. No where near as damaging as the legacy of imperialism that has caused so many border disputes to this day.
- red guard killings: see above. Communism is a western invention from Europe.
- gang violence in El Salvador: El Salvador has been a mess ever since Spanish colonialism and since chaos broke out after Napoleon occupied Spain and the Spanish lost control over all of their colonies. Once again, the poison of communism that was invented by Europeans caused more civil wars in the later part of the 20th.
-AIDs in Russia: not sure what your point is here given that this is an internal health problem that affects little people outside the borders of Russia.
Now do India/Pakistan disputes, Israel/Palestine, Venezuela/Guyana, all of WW1 and WW2, and the list goes on and on. The world is thoroughly messed up because of Europeans and their colonialism.
Anonymous
12/10/2023 12:38
Subject: Why are Americans so defensive about America?
Anonymous wrote:Most of the world is messed up even to this day because of European colonialism, remember that.
-Great Leap Forward famine
-African wars of the 90s (including Rwandan Genocide and Second Congo War)
-Emperor worship in Japan
-Black September (Jordan vs PLA)
-Red Guard killings and cannibalism
-Gang violence in El Salvador
-AIDS epidemic in Russia
Anonymous
12/10/2023 12:19
Subject: Why are Americans so defensive about America?
I just came from Europe and had multiple conversations with locals about how defensive French/German/Brits are when discussing their own country. I don’t buy that this is solely an American thing, I think its an individual thing.
Anonymous
12/10/2023 12:16
Subject: Why are Americans so defensive about America?
Because I truly would never want to live anywhere else or be a citizen anywhere else, and I recognize that so many feel the same (that’s why they keep coming!).
Anonymous
12/10/2023 11:40
Subject: Why are Americans so defensive about America?
Most of the world is messed up even to this day because of European colonialism, remember that.