Anonymous wrote:Big Sis has a recent post that's a bit angry and defensive about "fair critiques" that woman memoirists are always publishing new memoirs with ever new life lessons and instructions they are compelled to impart. She evidentially got a question from a journalist who pointed out that Fierce, Free, and Full of Shit came out 3 months before her marriage imploded. Awkward. Yeah, the whole cottage industry of influencer woman is dependent on a steady stream of earth-shattering revelations and learnings. This is super hard to keep up when you are sort of basic and average in thought and insight. Jen isn't a deep thinker and what she does put out there is highly leveraged and borrowed from others. She's not an academic who can lean into research like Brene Brown can.
A publisher of non-fictions once told me that most people have one good book in them. No one unless they lead an amazing, on-going life is capable of a good second (or tenth) book. Big Sis' one good book was For The Love. 7 was a gimmick. The others like the Moxie one and Fierce were terrible.
I didn't read Awake but I doubt it's very good.
The one good book thing - yeah, I thought that. No one's life is interesting enough to keep churning them out, unless you have a super interesting career that changes a lot - like a international photo journalist, relief aid, or something. Jen adopted her kids (which was an interesting experience to read about, her thoughts on international adoption,) started a church, and tried to buck some of the convention - and then just - did nothing really. Got divorced, but that is not a book, really, as it happens to many, many people and has been thoroughly discussed before. She has the burden of portraying her life as constantly interesting and insightful, and it is neither. She is an influencer with content basically about being an influencer.
She has a lot going for her - nice kids, nice house, good family, circle of friends. I wish, for her sake, she could just embrace/enjoy that without having to perform or sell. Could she get a regular job, and just chill, enjoy what she has? Of course, she would not be able to take a month for Me Camp then.
She has a lot of blessings in her life, but being interesting is not one of them.