Anonymous
12/27/2025 13:22
Subject: Massive home addition causes confusion in Fairfax County neighborhood
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The homeowner changed his approved plans from a garage to a window/door at the 1st floor front of the home. The homeowner applied for this as an Amendment to his original permit but the county has not approved it yet. However, the homeowner has already constructed the addition in this front area in a way he’s seeking in the amendment. There are now steps built going from the old garage space (now door/window) to the driveway. Obviously not going to be a garage.
Those steps come further out into the front yard than the original plans. The original approved permit showed the plans at a 21 ft front setback, so county approved as meeting the front setback requirements.
Now with the garage redesign and added steps, is the homeowner still within the County’s 20 ft minimum for the front setback?
So is tge homeowner just deliberately building whatever he wants in complete violation of zoning laws and in contradiction to his permits, with a plan to just get approval after the fact?
So can everyone else doing renovations in Fairfax County use the same method?
Momentarily setting aside the side setback, everything else that has been brought up seems to be correctible. There seems to be just enough room for a second parking spot. And if there are stairs going into the new addition that create a new setback problem, those could be removed.
The side sideback isn't correctible. It is a mistake that never should have happened, but it did. It would be a grossly disproportionate response to require a teardown over 6 inches, both in this case and in general. If there's really a concern about encouraging such mistakes, a better deterrent would be a fine, not a teardown when there is no meaningful impact. I don't think that's a realistic concern, though.
County rezoning has mandated tear downs for much less.
Yeah, a pp cited sheds. Except sheds can be (relatively) easily moved. Got any examples involving houses or businesses?
There's probably a reason it doesn't happen with large builds. There is a very real possibility that the county will say tear it down, and a responsible builder will take measures to avoid a five or six figure mistake.
So no examples?
No. The cost of making a mistake is too high, so no one rolls the dice.
Except it does happen. A post-construction example in Arlington:
V-11945-23-UP-1: A use permit request by Kohlmark Builders, Inc. on behalf of Stuart and Norma Jean Young, the owners, to permit a rear setback of 24.6 feet to the building wall (sunroom) instead of 25 feet to the building wall (sunroom) as required, and to permit a left side setback of 4.6 feet to the screened A/C units instead of 5 feet to the A/C units as required; re: after the fact approval of sunroom wall and A/C units to an existing one-family detached dwelling in the R-5 zoning district, on the premises known as 1007 18th Street South (Arlington Ridge).
https://www.arlingtonva.us/files/sharedassets/public/v/1/commissions/documents/bza/minutes-2024/may-15-2024-bza-minutes-final.pdf
Anonymous
12/27/2025 13:16
Subject: Massive home addition causes confusion in Fairfax County neighborhood
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:It looks like Courtney has her backyard shed in the setback. In two, actually. Maybe she thought they should cancel each other out. Will one of you tell her?
So we’re back to the verging-on-creepy posts about the neighbor again, I see.
She went on TV and had a helicopter fly over her house.
And?
Does asking questions about something happening in one’s neighborhood give others the right to make creepy comments about the person?
You gotta wonder if comments like this would be made if a man had asked these questions.
How is it creepy? Should have I instead gone on Facebook and posted the address? Then went to the media to have them take pictures of her house? Because that's somehow less creepy?
Yeah, it does make you wonder how this would have gone down if Mike was a woman and Courtney was a man.
Every setback is sacred,
Every setback is great!
If you’re six inches over,
You’ve committed a grave mistake!
I suggest you open a complaint with the zoning authority in Fairfax County. It's online. The shed might even be unpermitted.
This happened with a neighbor on my street. Another neighbor reported them. The county sent out notices to our whole block that there would be a hearing where we could state our concerns about the shed. The neighbor who reported it said they were against it, but all the other neighbors who came to the hearing were fine with it. The board gave them a variance for the shed.
Apparently this is fairly common and as long as most of the neighbors are okay with it, the allow it.
Anonymous
12/27/2025 13:15
Subject: Massive home addition causes confusion in Fairfax County neighborhood
Anonymous wrote:Greenbrier is a dumb; not sure what the big deal is? The neighbor can certainly move. None of those houses are worth very much though. Chantilly is not the most desirable highschool in FCPS.
The neighbor's house is $800k. She'll be fine.
Anonymous
12/27/2025 12:48
Subject: Massive home addition causes confusion in Fairfax County neighborhood
Greenbrier is a dumb; not sure what the big deal is? The neighbor can certainly move. None of those houses are worth very much though. Chantilly is not the most desirable highschool in FCPS.
Anonymous
12/27/2025 11:19
Subject: Massive home addition causes confusion in Fairfax County neighborhood
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The homeowner changed his approved plans from a garage to a window/door at the 1st floor front of the home. The homeowner applied for this as an Amendment to his original permit but the county has not approved it yet. However, the homeowner has already constructed the addition in this front area in a way he’s seeking in the amendment. There are now steps built going from the old garage space (now door/window) to the driveway. Obviously not going to be a garage.
Those steps come further out into the front yard than the original plans. The original approved permit showed the plans at a 21 ft front setback, so county approved as meeting the front setback requirements.
Now with the garage redesign and added steps, is the homeowner still within the County’s 20 ft minimum for the front setback?
So is tge homeowner just deliberately building whatever he wants in complete violation of zoning laws and in contradiction to his permits, with a plan to just get approval after the fact?
So can everyone else doing renovations in Fairfax County use the same method?
Momentarily setting aside the side setback, everything else that has been brought up seems to be correctible. There seems to be just enough room for a second parking spot. And if there are stairs going into the new addition that create a new setback problem, those could be removed.
The side sideback isn't correctible. It is a mistake that never should have happened, but it did. It would be a grossly disproportionate response to require a teardown over 6 inches, both in this case and in general. If there's really a concern about encouraging such mistakes, a better deterrent would be a fine, not a teardown when there is no meaningful impact. I don't think that's a realistic concern, though.
County rezoning has mandated tear downs for much less.
Yeah, a pp cited sheds. Except sheds can be (relatively) easily moved. Got any examples involving houses or businesses?
There's probably a reason it doesn't happen with large builds. There is a very real possibility that the county will say tear it down, and a responsible builder will take measures to avoid a five or six figure mistake.
So no examples?
No. The cost of making a mistake is too high, so no one rolls the dice.
Anonymous
12/27/2025 11:18
Subject: Massive home addition causes confusion in Fairfax County neighborhood
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:It looks like Courtney has her backyard shed in the setback. In two, actually. Maybe she thought they should cancel each other out. Will one of you tell her?
So we’re back to the verging-on-creepy posts about the neighbor again, I see.
She went on TV and had a helicopter fly over her house.
And?
Does asking questions about something happening in one’s neighborhood give others the right to make creepy comments about the person?
You gotta wonder if comments like this would be made if a man had asked these questions.
How is it creepy? Should have I instead gone on Facebook and posted the address? Then went to the media to have them take pictures of her house? Because that's somehow less creepy?
Yeah, it does make you wonder how this would have gone down if Mike was a woman and Courtney was a man.
Every setback is sacred,
Every setback is great!
If you’re six inches over,
You’ve committed a grave mistake!
I suggest you open a complaint with the zoning authority in Fairfax County. It's online. The shed might even be unpermitted.
You mean, the county may have granted a setback reduction? The horror!
The county is not granting those for sheds. That's why people don't get permits.
Anonymous
12/27/2025 11:07
Subject: Massive home addition causes confusion in Fairfax County neighborhood
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:It looks like Courtney has her backyard shed in the setback. In two, actually. Maybe she thought they should cancel each other out. Will one of you tell her?
So we’re back to the verging-on-creepy posts about the neighbor again, I see.
She went on TV and had a helicopter fly over her house.
I’m pretty sure that she didn’t hire the news crews or pay for the cost of operating the helicopter. Obviously this addition is so outrageous it made for an interesting news story. Interesting enough it was worthy of the news to spend the money to report on it.
Anonymous
12/27/2025 10:12
Subject: Massive home addition causes confusion in Fairfax County neighborhood
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:It looks like Courtney has her backyard shed in the setback. In two, actually. Maybe she thought they should cancel each other out. Will one of you tell her?
So we’re back to the verging-on-creepy posts about the neighbor again, I see.
She went on TV and had a helicopter fly over her house.
And?
Does asking questions about something happening in one’s neighborhood give others the right to make creepy comments about the person?
You gotta wonder if comments like this would be made if a man had asked these questions.
How is it creepy? Should have I instead gone on Facebook and posted the address? Then went to the media to have them take pictures of her house? Because that's somehow less creepy?
Yeah, it does make you wonder how this would have gone down if Mike was a woman and Courtney was a man.
Every setback is sacred,
Every setback is great!
If you’re six inches over,
You’ve committed a grave mistake!
I suggest you open a complaint with the zoning authority in Fairfax County. It's online. The shed might even be unpermitted.
You mean, the county may have granted a setback reduction? The horror!
Anonymous
12/27/2025 10:11
Subject: Massive home addition causes confusion in Fairfax County neighborhood
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The homeowner changed his approved plans from a garage to a window/door at the 1st floor front of the home. The homeowner applied for this as an Amendment to his original permit but the county has not approved it yet. However, the homeowner has already constructed the addition in this front area in a way he’s seeking in the amendment. There are now steps built going from the old garage space (now door/window) to the driveway. Obviously not going to be a garage.
Those steps come further out into the front yard than the original plans. The original approved permit showed the plans at a 21 ft front setback, so county approved as meeting the front setback requirements.
Now with the garage redesign and added steps, is the homeowner still within the County’s 20 ft minimum for the front setback?
So is tge homeowner just deliberately building whatever he wants in complete violation of zoning laws and in contradiction to his permits, with a plan to just get approval after the fact?
So can everyone else doing renovations in Fairfax County use the same method?
Momentarily setting aside the side setback, everything else that has been brought up seems to be correctible. There seems to be just enough room for a second parking spot. And if there are stairs going into the new addition that create a new setback problem, those could be removed.
The side sideback isn't correctible. It is a mistake that never should have happened, but it did. It would be a grossly disproportionate response to require a teardown over 6 inches, both in this case and in general. If there's really a concern about encouraging such mistakes, a better deterrent would be a fine, not a teardown when there is no meaningful impact. I don't think that's a realistic concern, though.
County rezoning has mandated tear downs for much less.
Yeah, a pp cited sheds. Except sheds can be (relatively) easily moved. Got any examples involving houses or businesses?
There's probably a reason it doesn't happen with large builds. There is a very real possibility that the county will say tear it down, and a responsible builder will take measures to avoid a five or six figure mistake.
So no examples?
Anonymous
12/27/2025 10:07
Subject: Massive home addition causes confusion in Fairfax County neighborhood
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:It looks like Courtney has her backyard shed in the setback. In two, actually. Maybe she thought they should cancel each other out. Will one of you tell her?
So we’re back to the verging-on-creepy posts about the neighbor again, I see.
She went on TV and had a helicopter fly over her house.
And?
Does asking questions about something happening in one’s neighborhood give others the right to make creepy comments about the person?
You gotta wonder if comments like this would be made if a man had asked these questions.
How is it creepy? Should have I instead gone on Facebook and posted the address? Then went to the media to have them take pictures of her house? Because that's somehow less creepy?
Yeah, it does make you wonder how this would have gone down if Mike was a woman and Courtney was a man.
Every setback is sacred,
Every setback is great!
If you’re six inches over,
You’ve committed a grave mistake!
I suggest you open a complaint with the zoning authority in Fairfax County. It's online. The shed might even be unpermitted.
Anonymous
12/27/2025 09:58
Subject: Massive home addition causes confusion in Fairfax County neighborhood
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The homeowner changed his approved plans from a garage to a window/door at the 1st floor front of the home. The homeowner applied for this as an Amendment to his original permit but the county has not approved it yet. However, the homeowner has already constructed the addition in this front area in a way he’s seeking in the amendment. There are now steps built going from the old garage space (now door/window) to the driveway. Obviously not going to be a garage.
Those steps come further out into the front yard than the original plans. The original approved permit showed the plans at a 21 ft front setback, so county approved as meeting the front setback requirements.
Now with the garage redesign and added steps, is the homeowner still within the County’s 20 ft minimum for the front setback?
So is tge homeowner just deliberately building whatever he wants in complete violation of zoning laws and in contradiction to his permits, with a plan to just get approval after the fact?
So can everyone else doing renovations in Fairfax County use the same method?
Momentarily setting aside the side setback, everything else that has been brought up seems to be correctible. There seems to be just enough room for a second parking spot. And if there are stairs going into the new addition that create a new setback problem, those could be removed.
The side sideback isn't correctible. It is a mistake that never should have happened, but it did. It would be a grossly disproportionate response to require a teardown over 6 inches, both in this case and in general. If there's really a concern about encouraging such mistakes, a better deterrent would be a fine, not a teardown when there is no meaningful impact. I don't think that's a realistic concern, though.
County rezoning has mandated tear downs for much less.
Yeah, a pp cited sheds. Except sheds can be (relatively) easily moved. Got any examples involving houses or businesses?
There's probably a reason it doesn't happen with large builds. There is a very real possibility that the county will say tear it down, and a responsible builder will take measures to avoid a five or six figure mistake.
Anonymous
12/27/2025 00:59
Subject: Massive home addition causes confusion in Fairfax County neighborhood
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The homeowner changed his approved plans from a garage to a window/door at the 1st floor front of the home. The homeowner applied for this as an Amendment to his original permit but the county has not approved it yet. However, the homeowner has already constructed the addition in this front area in a way he’s seeking in the amendment. There are now steps built going from the old garage space (now door/window) to the driveway. Obviously not going to be a garage.
Those steps come further out into the front yard than the original plans. The original approved permit showed the plans at a 21 ft front setback, so county approved as meeting the front setback requirements.
Now with the garage redesign and added steps, is the homeowner still within the County’s 20 ft minimum for the front setback?
So is tge homeowner just deliberately building whatever he wants in complete violation of zoning laws and in contradiction to his permits, with a plan to just get approval after the fact?
So can everyone else doing renovations in Fairfax County use the same method?
Momentarily setting aside the side setback, everything else that has been brought up seems to be correctible. There seems to be just enough room for a second parking spot. And if there are stairs going into the new addition that create a new setback problem, those could be removed.
The side sideback isn't correctible. It is a mistake that never should have happened, but it did. It would be a grossly disproportionate response to require a teardown over 6 inches, both in this case and in general. If there's really a concern about encouraging such mistakes, a better deterrent would be a fine, not a teardown when there is no meaningful impact. I don't think that's a realistic concern, though.
There seems to be just enough room for a second parking spot - disagree with your comment that there is enough room for a second parking spot. Tandem parking is parking two cars end to end, one in front of the other. The driveway as is with the addition does not support that.
Having a second parking spot side by side won’t work either because there is not enough space with the shortened driveway and one car width of an apron for a car to get onto a second parking spot, even without a car in the other parking spot. He really hasn’t left much space on the driveway with the addition.
The stairs were placed because the driveway elevation is different than the addition elevation. Not sure you can just remove the stairs, especially if you put in sliding doors vs windows.
The point is that there's no requirement for parking spots to be independently accessible. Tandem parking obviously requires that and is allowed. There's nothing in the code that says that can't also be true for side by side parking.
I disagree there isn't space to straighten the car out. You'd need the parking pad extended to the sidewalk. Worst case, you might need to pull in crooked, back over the sidewalk again, and then pull forward straight.
You don't need stairs in front of sliding doors if the doors are sealed shut to prevent them from opening. This is common with new houses when they wait to build a deck.
Anonymous
12/26/2025 23:02
Subject: Massive home addition causes confusion in Fairfax County neighborhood
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:The homeowner changed his approved plans from a garage to a window/door at the 1st floor front of the home. The homeowner applied for this as an Amendment to his original permit but the county has not approved it yet. However, the homeowner has already constructed the addition in this front area in a way he’s seeking in the amendment. There are now steps built going from the old garage space (now door/window) to the driveway. Obviously not going to be a garage.
Those steps come further out into the front yard than the original plans. The original approved permit showed the plans at a 21 ft front setback, so county approved as meeting the front setback requirements.
Now with the garage redesign and added steps, is the homeowner still within the County’s 20 ft minimum for the front setback?
So is tge homeowner just deliberately building whatever he wants in complete violation of zoning laws and in contradiction to his permits, with a plan to just get approval after the fact?
So can everyone else doing renovations in Fairfax County use the same method?
Momentarily setting aside the side setback, everything else that has been brought up seems to be correctible. There seems to be just enough room for a second parking spot. And if there are stairs going into the new addition that create a new setback problem, those could be removed.
The side sideback isn't correctible. It is a mistake that never should have happened, but it did. It would be a grossly disproportionate response to require a teardown over 6 inches, both in this case and in general. If there's really a concern about encouraging such mistakes, a better deterrent would be a fine, not a teardown when there is no meaningful impact. I don't think that's a realistic concern, though.
There seems to be just enough room for a second parking spot - disagree with your comment that there is enough room for a second parking spot. Tandem parking is parking two cars end to end, one in front of the other. The driveway as is with the addition does not support that.
Having a second parking spot side by side won’t work either because there is not enough space with the shortened driveway and one car width of an apron for a car to get onto a second parking spot, even without a car in the other parking spot. He really hasn’t left much space on the driveway with the addition.
The stairs were placed because the driveway elevation is different than the addition elevation. Not sure you can just remove the stairs, especially if you put in sliding doors vs windows.
Anonymous
12/26/2025 18:46
Subject: Massive home addition causes confusion in Fairfax County neighborhood
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:It looks like Courtney has her backyard shed in the setback. In two, actually. Maybe she thought they should cancel each other out. Will one of you tell her?
So we’re back to the verging-on-creepy posts about the neighbor again, I see.
She went on TV and had a helicopter fly over her house.
And?
Does asking questions about something happening in one’s neighborhood give others the right to make creepy comments about the person?
You gotta wonder if comments like this would be made if a man had asked these questions.
How is it creepy? Should have I instead gone on Facebook and posted the address? Then went to the media to have them take pictures of her house? Because that's somehow less creepy?
Yeah, it does make you wonder how this would have gone down if Mike was a woman and Courtney was a man.
Every setback is sacred,
Every setback is great!
If you’re six inches over,
You’ve committed a grave mistake!
Anonymous
12/26/2025 18:30
Subject: Massive home addition causes confusion in Fairfax County neighborhood
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:It looks like Courtney has her backyard shed in the setback. In two, actually. Maybe she thought they should cancel each other out. Will one of you tell her?
So we’re back to the verging-on-creepy posts about the neighbor again, I see.
She went on TV and had a helicopter fly over her house.
And?
Does asking questions about something happening in one’s neighborhood give others the right to make creepy comments about the person?
You gotta wonder if comments like this would be made if a man had asked these questions.