Anonymous
Post 02/11/2023 10:25     Subject: Re:Why are people more sympathetic to Lindsay Clancy than Andrea Yates? (Child death mentioned)

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Not sure why comments calling out Lindsay sympathizers for being racist are being deleted, except these same people are triggered for being rightfully called out. We all know what this case is about and it’s unacceptable in this day and age.


That’s a shame because I do appreciate the perspective that her race is a part of the sympathy. I don’t think race alone accounts for it - we all know that most mass shooters are white and don’t garner this sympathy - but I think it’s an important discussion. I’d like to say I’d extend the same sympathy if she was Black but then again, if she was Black I’d probably never hear about this case.


If interested, maybe do some research on cases and start a separate thread?
Anonymous
Post 02/11/2023 10:22     Subject: Re:Why are people more sympathetic to Lindsay Clancy than Andrea Yates? (Child death mentioned)

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Not sure why comments calling out Lindsay sympathizers for being racist are being deleted, except these same people are triggered for being rightfully called out. We all know what this case is about and it’s unacceptable in this day and age.


That’s a shame because I do appreciate the perspective that her race is a part of the sympathy. I don’t think race alone accounts for it - we all know that most mass shooters are white and don’t garner this sympathy - but I think it’s an important discussion. I’d like to say I’d extend the same sympathy if she was Black but then again, if she was Black I’d probably never hear about this case.


I think it’s a combination of demographic factors. If Clancy was living in a trailer on food stamps, this may just get passing mention in the news like the (sadly way too many) other cases of parents killing their kids. If she were black, this may still make the news if we’re talking about an attractive, UMC, well educated mom who posted cute photos on Instagram.

There’s definitely demographic biases going on though because people who have all the privileges she has don’t normally kill their kids.
Anonymous
Post 02/11/2023 10:19     Subject: Re:Why are people more sympathetic to Lindsay Clancy than Andrea Yates? (Child death mentioned)

Anonymous wrote:I notice a definite pattern, especially amongst millennial umc couples of having three kids in succession, 2 years apart at most. Many of these couples have zero experience with kids and are extremely self centered individuals. I can imagine adjusting to parenthood would be challenging for them. They do seem to be competing with each other. Thank you for glamorizing parenthood, social media.


Well it’s not that common given the overall birth rate. But I can see why it makes sense if you want to your kids to have built in playmates, as roaming around neighborhoods is much less common now. I say that as a mom of 3 but with a huge age spread.

I have some older friends though and the social media thing and parenting thing that they are seeing with grandkids is weird. I am more of a Gen Xer and things have really shifted. And not in a good way.

But putting that aside, crimes like this are very rare and that’s why it’s getting so much attention.

Anonymous
Post 02/11/2023 09:56     Subject: Re:Why are people more sympathetic to Lindsay Clancy than Andrea Yates? (Child death mentioned)

Anonymous wrote:Not sure why comments calling out Lindsay sympathizers for being racist are being deleted, except these same people are triggered for being rightfully called out. We all know what this case is about and it’s unacceptable in this day and age.


That’s a shame because I do appreciate the perspective that her race is a part of the sympathy. I don’t think race alone accounts for it - we all know that most mass shooters are white and don’t garner this sympathy - but I think it’s an important discussion. I’d like to say I’d extend the same sympathy if she was Black but then again, if she was Black I’d probably never hear about this case.
Anonymous
Post 02/11/2023 09:51     Subject: Why are people more sympathetic to Lindsay Clancy than Andrea Yates? (Child death mentioned)

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I am not a Clancy “Stan”, but I do feel sympathy toward her.

Its not because I secretly also want to kill my kids.

It might be due to unconscious bias, as I am also white and a professional. And if so, that’s something I need to acknowledge and actively work against in the future.

But what I think what it is, is that for us sympathizers, we love our kids so much and cannot in a million years imagine killing them, so we assume that Clancy - perhaps because she looks like us? Has a similar lifestyle to us? - must have had something so crazy wrong with her brain for a brief moment because surely she wouldn’t do this on purpose.

Just my two cents. I appreciate everyone’s differing perspectives. Three innocent lives lost, let’s hope some new knowledge / understanding about mental health and social media and unconscious bias comes out of this mess.


Do you think she should be held accountable for her actions?


I feel like I don’t have a deep enough understanding of what was going on here to say whether she should go to prison for life, a psych ward or be released with strict restrictions (like they did with Hinkley). I feel like I’m “missing” something here, because it just does not compute why a woman with so much privilege, intellect (ie she was a nurse / gainfully employed) and options could do this to innocent children.
Anonymous
Post 02/11/2023 09:29     Subject: Re:Why are people more sympathetic to Lindsay Clancy than Andrea Yates? (Child death mentioned)

Not sure why comments calling out Lindsay sympathizers for being racist are being deleted, except these same people are triggered for being rightfully called out. We all know what this case is about and it’s unacceptable in this day and age.
Anonymous
Post 02/11/2023 09:22     Subject: Re:Why are people more sympathetic to Lindsay Clancy than Andrea Yates? (Child death mentioned)

Anonymous wrote:I notice a definite pattern, especially amongst millennial umc couples of having three kids in succession, 2 years apart at most. Many of these couples have zero experience with kids and are extremely self centered individuals. I can imagine adjusting to parenthood would be challenging for them. They do seem to be competing with each other. Thank you for glamorizing parenthood, social media.


Yep. There is a young family on this street that meets this description. The children are positively feral. Pretty much every teen on the street has babysat for them and no one wants to anymore. Yet on social media they are the “perfect family.” In reality parents do no parenting and spend most of their free time drinking with their friends, while all the kids run around completely unsupervised. But they have a nice house and a suburban and they are cute so all must be well, right?
Anonymous
Post 02/11/2023 09:16     Subject: Re:Why are people more sympathetic to Lindsay Clancy than Andrea Yates? (Child death mentioned)

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I keep going back to the call her husband made to the doctors a week prior. He said she was acting like a zombie. Her meds were adjusted and bam— one week later, the unthinkable. Obviously her situation was precarious and very difficult to treat. There is a fine line to titrating psych meds and some cases are intractable.

Also, there is no scenario where she will get off scot free as some posters are saying. If not guilty due to insanity— she will be in a locked ward for a very long time to come. These are not cushy rehab facilities at all.

In MD we have the Clifton Perkins Hospital for the criminally insane— she would likely end up somewhere like that. A pretty grim way to spend your life, especially as a paraplegic.


I wonder about the timing of “one week before”, I know it has been reported that he said that. But I think there has been so much that has come out since then, when did he actually say that?

Her mom also visited the weekend prior (incident happened on Tuesday) and texted her saying she was doing “much better”.


As far as I know, the call to the doctor hasn’t been disputed by law enforcement or the prosecutor’s office. The way I interpreted her mom’s statement is this: she’s doing much better as not in a psych hospital, not in intensive outpatient treatment and able to care for the kids. There have definitely been days I’ve felt like a zombie caring for my kids!

We’re any of the kids in preschool or daycare during the day?
Anonymous
Post 02/11/2023 09:13     Subject: Re:Why are people more sympathetic to Lindsay Clancy than Andrea Yates? (Child death mentioned)

I notice a definite pattern, especially amongst millennial umc couples of having three kids in succession, 2 years apart at most. Many of these couples have zero experience with kids and are extremely self centered individuals. I can imagine adjusting to parenthood would be challenging for them. They do seem to be competing with each other. Thank you for glamorizing parenthood, social media.
Anonymous
Post 02/11/2023 09:03     Subject: Why are people more sympathetic to Lindsay Clancy than Andrea Yates? (Child death mentioned)

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I am not a Clancy “Stan”, but I do feel sympathy toward her.

Its not because I secretly also want to kill my kids.

It might be due to unconscious bias, as I am also white and a professional. And if so, that’s something I need to acknowledge and actively work against in the future.

But what I think what it is, is that for us sympathizers, we love our kids so much and cannot in a million years imagine killing them, so we assume that Clancy - perhaps because she looks like us? Has a similar lifestyle to us? - must have had something so crazy wrong with her brain for a brief moment because surely she wouldn’t do this on purpose.

Just my two cents. I appreciate everyone’s differing perspectives. Three innocent lives lost, let’s hope some new knowledge / understanding about mental health and social media and unconscious bias comes out of this mess.


This is my perspective too. Any mother who has been through pregnancy, childbirth, nursing, sleep deprivation, hormonal and chemical fluctuations, and watching the monitor all night to make sure your baby is breathing - all while raising other toddlers- knows how it can alter your mental state. I can’t imagine the pain and scariness of having an actual PPD or PPP diagnosis on top of it. Maybe it’s unconscious bias, but we know how little support is available for parents having difficulty going through this phase of life. Like PP said, doing what she did is unimaginable for the vast majority of parents- most of us have to believe that someone with no prior record would have to have been driven insane.


I think we need to reject conventional practices of having babies less than 2 years apart and having more than 2 of them like it’s easy. Yes people do it, and most people survive it without something terrible happening.

BUT. In this day and age, having 3+ kids less than 2 years apart is just asking for misery. Why? Just why? I had two kids 3 years apart. Both were good sleepers and neurotypical and it was still really hard! DH and I didn’t have any trouble deciding to stop at 2 even though before we had any kids we discussed three. As non parents you have no clue.

Again, not saying people can’t have more than two kids. But can we please get rid of this idea that it’s so easy that everyone should do it and in quick succession too, which is how it feels right now.

This. It’s another sign of the times. We don’t need a herd of children to work on the farm anymore, also we have ways to prevent pregnancy. Sadly, it appears as though many women now simply have babies for social media fodder, for attention. These women don’t seem to acknowledge that their children are actually autonomous people with diverse personalities and behaviors.
Anonymous
Post 02/11/2023 08:33     Subject: Why are people more sympathetic to Lindsay Clancy than Andrea Yates? (Child death mentioned)

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I am not a Clancy “Stan”, but I do feel sympathy toward her.

Its not because I secretly also want to kill my kids.

It might be due to unconscious bias, as I am also white and a professional. And if so, that’s something I need to acknowledge and actively work against in the future.

But what I think what it is, is that for us sympathizers, we love our kids so much and cannot in a million years imagine killing them, so we assume that Clancy - perhaps because she looks like us? Has a similar lifestyle to us? - must have had something so crazy wrong with her brain for a brief moment because surely she wouldn’t do this on purpose.

Just my two cents. I appreciate everyone’s differing perspectives. Three innocent lives lost, let’s hope some new knowledge / understanding about mental health and social media and unconscious bias comes out of this mess.


This is my perspective too. Any mother who has been through pregnancy, childbirth, nursing, sleep deprivation, hormonal and chemical fluctuations, and watching the monitor all night to make sure your baby is breathing - all while raising other toddlers- knows how it can alter your mental state. I can’t imagine the pain and scariness of having an actual PPD or PPP diagnosis on top of it. Maybe it’s unconscious bias, but we know how little support is available for parents having difficulty going through this phase of life. Like PP said, doing what she did is unimaginable for the vast majority of parents- most of us have to believe that someone with no prior record would have to have been driven insane.


I think we need to reject conventional practices of having babies less than 2 years apart and having more than 2 of them like it’s easy. Yes people do it, and most people survive it without something terrible happening.

BUT. In this day and age, having 3+ kids less than 2 years apart is just asking for misery. Why? Just why? I had two kids 3 years apart. Both were good sleepers and neurotypical and it was still really hard! DH and I didn’t have any trouble deciding to stop at 2 even though before we had any kids we discussed three. As non parents you have no clue.

Again, not saying people can’t have more than two kids. But can we please get rid of this idea that it’s so easy that everyone should do it and in quick succession too, which is how it feels right now.
Anonymous
Post 02/11/2023 08:18     Subject: Why are people more sympathetic to Lindsay Clancy than Andrea Yates? (Child death mentioned)

Anonymous wrote:I am not a Clancy “Stan”, but I do feel sympathy toward her.

Its not because I secretly also want to kill my kids.

It might be due to unconscious bias, as I am also white and a professional. And if so, that’s something I need to acknowledge and actively work against in the future.

But what I think what it is, is that for us sympathizers, we love our kids so much and cannot in a million years imagine killing them, so we assume that Clancy - perhaps because she looks like us? Has a similar lifestyle to us? - must have had something so crazy wrong with her brain for a brief moment because surely she wouldn’t do this on purpose.

Just my two cents. I appreciate everyone’s differing perspectives. Three innocent lives lost, let’s hope some new knowledge / understanding about mental health and social media and unconscious bias comes out of this mess.


This is my perspective too. Any mother who has been through pregnancy, childbirth, nursing, sleep deprivation, hormonal and chemical fluctuations, and watching the monitor all night to make sure your baby is breathing - all while raising other toddlers- knows how it can alter your mental state. I can’t imagine the pain and scariness of having an actual PPD or PPP diagnosis on top of it. Maybe it’s unconscious bias, but we know how little support is available for parents having difficulty going through this phase of life. Like PP said, doing what she did is unimaginable for the vast majority of parents- most of us have to believe that someone with no prior record would have to have been driven insane.
Anonymous
Post 02/11/2023 07:52     Subject: Why are people more sympathetic to Lindsay Clancy than Andrea Yates? (Child death mentioned)

Anonymous wrote:I am not a Clancy “Stan”, but I do feel sympathy toward her.

Its not because I secretly also want to kill my kids.

It might be due to unconscious bias, as I am also white and a professional. And if so, that’s something I need to acknowledge and actively work against in the future.

But what I think what it is, is that for us sympathizers, we love our kids so much and cannot in a million years imagine killing them, so we assume that Clancy - perhaps because she looks like us? Has a similar lifestyle to us? - must have had something so crazy wrong with her brain for a brief moment because surely she wouldn’t do this on purpose.

Just my two cents. I appreciate everyone’s differing perspectives. Three innocent lives lost, let’s hope some new knowledge / understanding about mental health and social media and unconscious bias comes out of this mess.


Do you think she should be held accountable for her actions?
Anonymous
Post 02/11/2023 07:51     Subject: Re:Why are people more sympathetic to Lindsay Clancy than Andrea Yates? (Child death mentioned)

Anonymous wrote:I keep going back to the call her husband made to the doctors a week prior. He said she was acting like a zombie. Her meds were adjusted and bam— one week later, the unthinkable. Obviously her situation was precarious and very difficult to treat. There is a fine line to titrating psych meds and some cases are intractable.

Also, there is no scenario where she will get off scot free as some posters are saying. If not guilty due to insanity— she will be in a locked ward for a very long time to come. These are not cushy rehab facilities at all.

In MD we have the Clifton Perkins Hospital for the criminally insane— she would likely end up somewhere like that. A pretty grim way to spend your life, especially as a paraplegic.


I wonder about the timing of “one week before”, I know it has been reported that he said that. But I think there has been so much that has come out since then, when did he actually say that?

Her mom also visited the weekend prior (incident happened on Tuesday) and texted her saying she was doing “much better”.
Anonymous
Post 02/11/2023 07:39     Subject: Why are people more sympathetic to Lindsay Clancy than Andrea Yates? (Child death mentioned)

I am not a Clancy “Stan”, but I do feel sympathy toward her.

Its not because I secretly also want to kill my kids.

It might be due to unconscious bias, as I am also white and a professional. And if so, that’s something I need to acknowledge and actively work against in the future.

But what I think what it is, is that for us sympathizers, we love our kids so much and cannot in a million years imagine killing them, so we assume that Clancy - perhaps because she looks like us? Has a similar lifestyle to us? - must have had something so crazy wrong with her brain for a brief moment because surely she wouldn’t do this on purpose.

Just my two cents. I appreciate everyone’s differing perspectives. Three innocent lives lost, let’s hope some new knowledge / understanding about mental health and social media and unconscious bias comes out of this mess.