Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I'm from Pittsburgh. Alderdice high school is in squirrel hill and is the best city school a kid can go to. Her parents might live there because it's the "Jewish neighborhood"or they might live there to get her into a school that should have prepped her for college. There is NO WAY a school like Allderdice, who sends loads of kids to ivy's every year, didn't tell her that she needs lots of extra-curriculars, etc.

I don't like to pick on a 17 year old, but I agree that it was very poorly written. The shot at muslims and gays, even IF she was trying be farcical, was not written well enough to give any hint of tongue in cheek.

As a native Pgher, I can tell you that this type of class warfare, where people TRULY believe they won't get into college because they're not black or hispanic, who think quotas are the reason they're not President, is rampant. The class warfare is INSANE and it is built into the culture of that city; odd because even the working class folks come across as sourly conservative on immigration issues, etc. They truly do think the black people, native americans "foreigners" and especially the Asians / Indians are coming to take their ..

+1 Allderdice, '92

Anonymous wrote:...and nobody here understands the gift of satire...what were you doing in your english classes anyways???

Rock on girl, go to state universities that really want you! ! ! ! !

Anonymous wrote:Today she says the article was satire.

The fact that the satire was not obvious to, well anyone, is pretty much the final word on whether the schools made the right decision on her application.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I'm from Pittsburgh. Alderdice high school is in squirrel hill and is the best city school a kid can go to. Her parents might live there because it's the "Jewish neighborhood"or they might live there to get her into a school that should have prepped her for college. There is NO WAY a school like Allderdice, who sends loads of kids to ivy's every year, didn't tell her that she needs lots of extra-curriculars, etc.

I don't like to pick on a 17 year old, but I agree that it was very poorly written. The shot at muslims and gays, even IF she was trying be farcical, was not written well enough to give any hint of tongue in cheek.

As a native Pgher, I can tell you that this type of class warfare, where people TRULY believe they won't get into college because they're not black or hispanic, who think quotas are the reason they're not President, is rampant. The class warfare is INSANE and it is built into the culture of that city; odd because even the working class folks come across as sourly conservative on immigration issues, etc. They truly do think the black people, native americans "foreigners" and especially the Asians / Indians are coming to take their ..

+1 Allderdice, '92

Anonymous wrote:I feel for her and a lot of you are judging her from your adult perspective when she is a teenager.

Her post could have been me during the college process. I did the extra stuff (sports, student council president, yearbook editor, job, etc.), was top 10% of my high school but as a middle class white girl it meant nothing. And this was 20 years ago, I can't imagine today.

I agree she comes off as young but, well, she is.

Anonymous wrote:I'm from Pittsburgh. Alderdice high school is in squirrel hill and is the best city school a kid can go to. Her parents might live there because it's the "Jewish neighborhood"or they might live there to get her into a school that should have prepped her for college. There is NO WAY a school like Allderdice, who sends loads of kids to ivy's every year, didn't tell her that she needs lots of extra-curriculars, etc.

I don't like to pick on a 17 year old, but I agree that it was very poorly written. The shot at muslims and gays, even IF she was trying be farcical, was not written well enough to give any hint of tongue in cheek.

As a native Pgher, I can tell you that this type of class warfare, where people TRULY believe they won't get into college because they're not black or hispanic, who think quotas are the reason they're not President, is rampant. The class warfare is INSANE and it is built into the culture of that city; odd because even the working class folks come across as sourly conservative on immigration issues, etc. They truly do think the black people, native americans "foreigners" and especially the Asians / Indians are coming to take their ..

Anonymous wrote:PP, why is she going to unemployable? For speaking the truth? Just because no one wants to admit this on a public forum, and would prefer to come across as "fighting the good fight", does not mean it is not true.

I would be proud to employ her. Clearly her family knows something about success. On their own. Without handouts.

Anonymous wrote:PP, why is she going to unemployable? For speaking the truth? Just because no one wants to admit this on a public forum, and would prefer to come across as "fighting the good fight", does not mean it is not true.

I would be proud to employ her. Clearly her family knows something about success. On their own. Without handouts.

Anonymous wrote:I like the use of the word "cracker" but she wimped out (or her editor did) and put saltine in front of it.

My best friend lives in Pittsburg and is doing college visits. The college counselor gave them a list of every kid in Pitsburg (without names), their GPA, SAT score and the colleges acceptance. When a school accepted a child with a low grade the counselor (to my friends disappointment) would say, "black, Hispanic or athlete".

She was appalled. She said they still talk about diversity in terms of "Polish, italian, German and Irish".

You can't choose where your aging parents live.

Anonymous wrote:And, OMG, these people are attention whores. This is their house. Notice the publication: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970204323904577038301146022524.html