Anonymous wrote:But you take CAPE at the end of the school year and the kids come from a mix of elementary schools including the ones listed so only 1.5% 5th grade 5s (2 kids) is at least not impressive.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Why so much BASIS hate? BASIS is working very well for much of its student population. Yes, that population is not reflective of many DC public or public charter schools. But so what? I wish the effort put into breaking down BASIS flaws was aimed at what other public schools need to do to serve the vast majority of their student populations just as well.

Ok. But why doesn't BASIS have kids take the CAPE for the class they're actually taking? Seems like since BASIS is working very well and is all around awesome, they would be able to show good results for 6th grade Algebra I, right? Why not do it?

6th graders don't take Algebra 1.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Why so much BASIS hate? BASIS is working very well for much of its student population. Yes, that population is not reflective of many DC public or public charter schools. But so what? I wish the effort put into breaking down BASIS flaws was aimed at what other public schools need to do to serve the vast majority of their student populations just as well.

Ok. But why doesn't BASIS have kids take the CAPE for the class they're actually taking? Seems like since BASIS is working very well and is all around awesome, they would be able to show good results for 6th grade Algebra I, right? Why not do it?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Why so much BASIS hate? BASIS is working very well for much of its student population. Yes, that population is not reflective of many DC public or public charter schools. But so what? I wish the effort put into breaking down BASIS flaws was aimed at what other public schools need to do to serve the vast majority of their student populations just as well.

Ok. But why doesn't BASIS have kids take the CAPE for the class they're actually taking? Seems like since BASIS is working very well and is all around awesome, they would be able to show good results for 6th grade Algebra I, right? Why not do it?

BASIS parent here. Compared to our DCPS elementary, BASIS doesn't seem to really care much about CAPE. They never really talk about it and They knock the tests out in a few days. each test has 30 questions -- at our DCPS, they would give the kids 10 questions per day, Tl/We/Th, so the ELA Math and Science take three weeks. At BASIS, they do one test per day in full, all 30 questions, so they are done in 3 days.

BASIS kids take a lot of other tests, and the within BASIS standardized tests are the ones that are important and that students and teachers are judged by.

We love the school. It would be a terrible fit for many kids, but if it works, it's an incredible opportunity to learn a ton.

Okay, but still most schools give the kids the test for the class the kid takes. And BASIS and its boosters dearly love to have good stats and talk about how very excellent BASIS is. So wouldn't an impressive Algebra I score be valuable for BASIS?

Or are they not giving the Algebra I CAPE test because they think giving the kids an easier test will look better?

No. Why would it be? As a parent, I don't care what the Algebra 1 CAPE score is. I care about which colleges admit BASIS DC students.

Why would you care more about colleges than Algebra I? Most kids who take Algebra I at BASIS leave years before they apply to college.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Hardy 6th grade also has more 5s than Basis - both subjects (twice as many for ELA).

Who are you arguing with? If your kid doesn't or didn't attend BASIS then why do you care so much? If your kid attended and left then why do you seem to care more about BASIS than wherever your kid goes now? This derangement is just weird.

I'm not the PP, but I care because I want people to understand BASIS is mid. I'm showing my age, but I remember how many people got hyped up about seemingly desirable charters 8-10 years ago and how disappointed they ended up being. BASIS is what it is and it's important to see clearly exactly what the data show so we can all make decisions for our individual children.

Wait. You think BASIS is "mid" because of CAPE scores? In 5th and 6th grade? That's "the data"? Ok...

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Hardy 6th grade also has more 5s than Basis - both subjects (twice as many for ELA).

Who are you arguing with? If your kid doesn't or didn't attend BASIS then why do you care so much? If your kid attended and left then why do you seem to care more about BASIS than wherever your kid goes now? This derangement is just weird.

I'm not the PP, but I care because I want people to understand BASIS is mid. I'm showing my age, but I remember how many people got hyped up about seemingly desirable charters 8-10 years ago and how disappointed they ended up being. BASIS is what it is and it's important to see clearly exactly what the data show so we can all make decisions for our individual children.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Hardy 6th grade also has more 5s than Basis - both subjects (twice as many for ELA).

Who are you arguing with? If your kid doesn't or didn't attend BASIS then why do you care so much? If your kid attended and left then why do you seem to care more about BASIS than wherever your kid goes now? This derangement is just weird.

Anonymous wrote:Hardy 6th grade also has more 5s than Basis - both subjects (twice as many for ELA).

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Why so much BASIS hate? BASIS is working very well for much of its student population. Yes, that population is not reflective of many DC public or public charter schools. But so what? I wish the effort put into breaking down BASIS flaws was aimed at what other public schools need to do to serve the vast majority of their student populations just as well.

Ok. But why doesn't BASIS have kids take the CAPE for the class they're actually taking? Seems like since BASIS is working very well and is all around awesome, they would be able to show good results for 6th grade Algebra I, right? Why not do it?

BASIS parent here. Compared to our DCPS elementary, BASIS doesn't seem to really care much about CAPE. They never really talk about it and They knock the tests out in a few days. each test has 30 questions -- at our DCPS, they would give the kids 10 questions per day, Tl/We/Th, so the ELA Math and Science take three weeks. At BASIS, they do one test per day in full, all 30 questions, so they are done in 3 days.

BASIS kids take a lot of other tests, and the within BASIS standardized tests are the ones that are important and that students and teachers are judged by.

We love the school. It would be a terrible fit for many kids, but if it works, it's an incredible opportunity to learn a ton.

Okay, but still most schools give the kids the test for the class the kid takes. And BASIS and its boosters dearly love to have good stats and talk about how very excellent BASIS is. So wouldn't an impressive Algebra I score be valuable for BASIS?

Or are they not giving the Algebra I CAPE test because they think giving the kids an easier test will look better?

No. Why would it be? As a parent, I don't care what the Algebra 1 CAPE score is. I care about which colleges admit BASIS DC students.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:its not hate really. but a lot of middle schools offer 7th grade algebra. next to nobody (<5%) in 5th grade ELA got a 5 which is weird. you are going to say its a math school and thats due to weak elementary schools but idk.

This. It's odd! What's going on there? Lots of schools had better scores for their 5th grade class.

For example SWS, Bancroft, Brent, LT, Maury, Marie Reed, Moten, Payne, Bruce-Monroe... Many!

Anonymous wrote:Am I misreading this or are Bancroft's scores a lot lower than I would expect? We have been thinking of moving into Mt. Pleasant because we have heard such great things about Bancroft. wondering if there is something going on there.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Why so much BASIS hate? BASIS is working very well for much of its student population. Yes, that population is not reflective of many DC public or public charter schools. But so what? I wish the effort put into breaking down BASIS flaws was aimed at what other public schools need to do to serve the vast majority of their student populations just as well.

Ok. But why doesn't BASIS have kids take the CAPE for the class they're actually taking? Seems like since BASIS is working very well and is all around awesome, they would be able to show good results for 6th grade Algebra I, right? Why not do it?

BASIS parent here. Compared to our DCPS elementary, BASIS doesn't seem to really care much about CAPE. They never really talk about it and They knock the tests out in a few days. each test has 30 questions -- at our DCPS, they would give the kids 10 questions per day, Tl/We/Th, so the ELA Math and Science take three weeks. At BASIS, they do one test per day in full, all 30 questions, so they are done in 3 days.

BASIS kids take a lot of other tests, and the within BASIS standardized tests are the ones that are important and that students and teachers are judged by.

We love the school. It would be a terrible fit for many kids, but if it works, it's an incredible opportunity to learn a ton.

Okay, but still most schools give the kids the test for the class the kid takes. And BASIS and its boosters dearly love to have good stats and talk about how very excellent BASIS is. So wouldn't an impressive Algebra I score be valuable for BASIS?

Or are they not giving the Algebra I CAPE test because they think giving the kids an easier test will look better?

No. Why would it be? As a parent, I don't care what the Algebra 1 CAPE score is. I care about which colleges admit BASIS DC students.