Anonymous
Post 09/13/2024 12:04     Subject: Scouts at MLSNext games
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Actually the Philadelphia Union player had at 5 offers DCU , Redbulls, Real Salt Lake , Philadelphia Union as well as Atlanta United, as well as 3 invites to 2010's USA Talent ID, he's actually a technical player .. Parents are forever grateful to the SYC organization and Coach Tupy.


According to MLS rules, it’s “illegal” to recruit players from outside the designated area. The club know the rules and how to go about this. Instead of stirring the pot, just be happy that the kid is where he wants to be. Stop posting information about this process if you’re not informed, because it can definitely cause serious trouble for both the player and the club.


In practice, does that mean that a scout from another academy cannot reach out to a player outside of their area if that player hasn’t already made first contact?


By illegal do you mean frowned upon? Happens all the time
Anonymous
Post 09/13/2024 10:39     Subject: Scouts at MLSNext games
Anonymous wrote:Oh SYC fanboy. Get a life. Reality is SYC did not develop him. He came to them from a different club.



Anonymous wrote:Actually the Philadelphia Union player had at 5 offers DCU , Redbulls, Real Salt Lake , Philadelphia Union as well as Atlanta United, as well as 3 invites to 2010's USA Talent ID, he's actually a technical player .. Parents are forever grateful to the SYC organization and Coach Tupy.


Every club that a player goes through has a part of in each player's development. Maybe the player was a strong player before syc but syc possibly helped him get to the next level. To say SYC didn't develop is just dumb. I have no idea who this player is but the comment is dumb.
Anonymous
Post 09/13/2024 10:29     Subject: Scouts at MLSNext games
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Actually the Philadelphia Union player had at 5 offers DCU , Redbulls, Real Salt Lake , Philadelphia Union as well as Atlanta United, as well as 3 invites to 2010's USA Talent ID, he's actually a technical player .. Parents are forever grateful to the SYC organization and Coach Tupy.


According to MLS rules, it’s “illegal” to recruit players from outside the designated area. The club know the rules and how to go about this. Instead of stirring the pot, just be happy that the kid is where he wants to be. Stop posting information about this process if you’re not informed, because it can definitely cause serious trouble for both the player and the club.


I totally agree that folks should stop posting detailed information about individual players, especially when ill-informed. But this sure sounds like his mom.
Anonymous
Post 09/13/2024 10:27     Subject: Scouts at MLSNext games
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Actually the Philadelphia Union player had at 5 offers DCU , Redbulls, Real Salt Lake , Philadelphia Union as well as Atlanta United, as well as 3 invites to 2010's USA Talent ID, he's actually a technical player .. Parents are forever grateful to the SYC organization and Coach Tupy.


According to MLS rules, it’s “illegal” to recruit players from outside the designated area. The club know the rules and how to go about this. Instead of stirring the pot, just be happy that the kid is where he wants to be. Stop posting information about this process if you’re not informed, because it can definitely cause serious trouble for both the player and the club.


In practice, does that mean that a scout from another academy cannot reach out to a player outside of their area if that player hasn’t already made first contact?


No. Our club, which is outside of a designated area, has had players join 4 different MLS academies in the past 2 years.
Anonymous
Post 09/13/2024 10:09     Subject: Scouts at MLSNext games
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Actually the Philadelphia Union player had at 5 offers DCU , Redbulls, Real Salt Lake , Philadelphia Union as well as Atlanta United, as well as 3 invites to 2010's USA Talent ID, he's actually a technical player .. Parents are forever grateful to the SYC organization and Coach Tupy.


According to MLS rules, it’s “illegal” to recruit players from outside the designated area. The club know the rules and how to go about this. Instead of stirring the pot, just be happy that the kid is where he wants to be. Stop posting information about this process if you’re not informed, because it can definitely cause serious trouble for both the player and the club.


In practice, does that mean that a scout from another academy cannot reach out to a player outside of their area if that player hasn’t already made first contact?
Anonymous
Post 09/12/2024 21:53     Subject: Scouts at MLSNext games
Oh SYC fanboy. Get a life. Reality is SYC did not develop him. He came to them from a different club.



Anonymous wrote:Actually the Philadelphia Union player had at 5 offers DCU , Redbulls, Real Salt Lake , Philadelphia Union as well as Atlanta United, as well as 3 invites to 2010's USA Talent ID, he's actually a technical player .. Parents are forever grateful to the SYC organization and Coach Tupy.
Anonymous
Post 09/12/2024 21:50     Subject: Scouts at MLSNext games

No it was a question. How do you get stalking from that. You idiot.

Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:If you are invited to practice with DCU, do they give you a jersey?


Are you stalking the kids online?
Anonymous
Post 09/12/2024 20:26     Subject: Scouts at MLSNext games
SYC is not a high level club give them a break!!
Anonymous
Post 09/12/2024 20:21     Subject: Scouts at MLSNext games
Anonymous wrote:Actually the Philadelphia Union player had at 5 offers DCU , Redbulls, Real Salt Lake , Philadelphia Union as well as Atlanta United, as well as 3 invites to 2010's USA Talent ID, he's actually a technical player .. Parents are forever grateful to the SYC organization and Coach Tupy.


According to MLS rules, it’s “illegal” to recruit players from outside the designated area. The club know the rules and how to go about this. Instead of stirring the pot, just be happy that the kid is where he wants to be. Stop posting information about this process if you’re not informed, because it can definitely cause serious trouble for both the player and the club.
Anonymous
Post 09/12/2024 20:11     Subject: Scouts at MLSNext games
Actually the Philadelphia Union player had at 5 offers DCU , Redbulls, Real Salt Lake , Philadelphia Union as well as Atlanta United, as well as 3 invites to 2010's USA Talent ID, he's actually a technical player .. Parents are forever grateful to the SYC organization and Coach Tupy.
Anonymous
Post 09/12/2024 20:09     Subject: Scouts at MLSNext games
Anonymous wrote:If you are invited to practice with DCU, do they give you a jersey?


Are you stalking the kids online?
Anonymous
Post 09/12/2024 20:04     Subject: Scouts at MLSNext games
If you are invited to practice with DCU, do they give you a jersey?
Anonymous
Post 09/12/2024 18:51     Subject: Scouts at MLSNext games
There is only one. He has always been playing up a year.

Anonymous wrote:Two 2011s from SYC played with DCU U14s last year and have been playing with U15s this year.
Anonymous
Post 09/12/2024 16:28     Subject: Scouts at MLSNext games
Two 2011s from SYC played with DCU U14s last year and have been playing with U15s this year.
Anonymous
Post 09/12/2024 16:27     Subject: Scouts at MLSNext games
Anonymous wrote:If you ask the TD at SYC he will smirk and tell you DCU is not a good club and they would rather hold the player back than send them there.

Irony with that is DCU didn't pick up any 2011 players from SYC. There were some great players on that 2011 squad but that destroyed when 1. HG took over. 2. When JR took over. 3. When


Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Honestly speaking, I would pick any other club even an ECNL club over SYC.

This season, DCU picked up the following for their 2011 group. I am sure there were more but these are the ones I know.
5 from VDA to DCU
2 from Arlington to DCU
1 from Alexandria to DCU
0 from SYC



Two 2011s from SYC played with DCU U14s last year and have been playing with U15s this year.

This is what baffles me about SYC. They said they have good players and develop them, supports their players but not able to place any players for 2011 and little to no one in the other age groups with DCU. They have good players and the conclusion that makes any sense is SYC is not advocating for their players and potentially blocking them from being picked up.