Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It is not people commenting on here who will close a "W" school. It will be elected officials. And people who want to keep Wootton and the other "W" schools open probably voted for these officials. These same officials wanted to change the name of the school a couple years back. This might also be a factor. Closing the school certainly eliminates the name. Bussing was also proposed at one point. Think before you vote for these officials

There are no elected officials on the school board or county council who ever expressed wanting to change the name of Wootton. Stop making things up.

There are only two elected officials who were even in office at the time when they approved initiating a review TO SEE IF THERE WAS COMMUNITY INTEREST in changing the name of any school. There was none, so nothing happened. No elected official advocated in support of changing the name of Wootton.

Additionally, no elected official (other than one Gaithersburg city councilmember) has advocated in support of Option H. Stop making things up.

Laura Stewart has been pushing for bussing for years. She hates the W schools and would to see one of them closed because they are an affront to equity.

I'm kind of picking on her because people are saying that she's anti W schools. But I'm trying to figure out what Laura Stewart did to lead her into her current role:

https://laurastewart.org/about-laura

I know she has greatly advocated and worked for what she believes is the betterment of Montgomery County and provides time and effort in a role that many are not willing to do.

But careerwise it says she earned a degree as a paralegal from a community college, vague reference to ten years in telecommunications, then taught music for a bit until COVID 19 when she transitioned to a fulltime volunteer.

So essentially she's a bored housewife. A lot of us know these types where they put a lot of their time, effort and energy into the PTA and are appreciated.

But I think these types of people kind of have an idealistic view of things and don't really understand the reality of things or how some things work.

For example, let's say she does hate W schools, why does she hate people wanting to live in the W school areas and have their kids strive to go to the colleges that students from those areas normally go to? The parents likely has been there and done that and knows what it takes. Then when their kids succeed they actually help and benefit society. They're not just making a living and possibly using resources without really adding to it.

It's like how it's really easy for kids to spend their parent's money. Once it's their own money, they kind of know and appreciate the value of it and are not so quick to waste it. Or how a lot of us, or we knew people, who were strong activists in our younger days but then once we grew up we had to kind of learn to work in the real world and try to benefit it in other ways. If she's not sheltered, she doesn't really know much about the world that some other people live in.

I'm not necessarily looking down on her. But I'm just curious on her background to see why she would have such an anti W school stance if she does. (someone correct me if she doesn't)

And I'm a big fan of Grace Rivera-Oven, and am happy she's the president of the board, and Brenda Wolff because they both seem to be active members of the community that they advocate for. Natalie Zimmerman is a teacher and can give firsthand experience of what's it like in the classroom and school. So am not trying to beat up the members of the BOE.

But it's that type of idealism but not grounded in reality that is leading to the decline in MCPS and Montgomery County.

So far I feel Grace has been the best BOE member. She listens and she cares. But Zimmerman doesn’t seem to be very active. Maybe she’s behind the scene but I don’t really feel her presence. Laura is just so bad at speaking and lacks in many ways.

Grace lies and tells you what you want to hear and then votes differently. Laura has lots of PTA and MCCPTA experience so slamming her makes no sense when she's very qualified. Public speaking doesn't make someone qualified and she'd done far more for students than most people here.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The basic point that seems to be lost here is that Wootton has been a too performing school that improves the prestige of the MCPS system. Why would anyone want a school like that closed? The name at least should be preserved, which would carry the prestige forward. However there in lie the issue. One of the agendas here is to get rid of the name, even if that means erasing the prestige. Why have top, Nationally recognized schools when we can have mediocrity?

Not a single person on the BOE or County Council ever once advocated for changing the name of Wootton. Not one. And saying that it is an agenda today, is unfounded speculation.

And I think you wildly exaggerate the "prestige" of the name. Any prestige comes from the fact that it is a school, and any good school would generate the same "prestige."

They’re not going to show their cards at once. Why are you being so naive?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:No they don't listen and won't listen in the future. Look at the regional program roll-out. How many threads and posts you've seen here expressing concerns or oppositions? Even if only 50% of them actually wrote emails or filled the survey (i.e., the tiny little orange button saying "having a question?"), they should have received thousands of negative feedbacks. Look at the MCCPTA and MCEA opposition on this. Look at the study team's shout on the opinion article....

Now look at their proposed operating budget and the fact that Mr. O's "promotion" to join the CO? They have decided long time ago and don't every care a penny what you think.

That's fine if they decide to do that.

But they also risk making a less desirable place to live.

That's why maybe just fifteen or twenty years ago, MCPS was head to head with Fairfax County. Fairfax is now at number five in the list of wealthiest counties in the US and Montgomery County is down at twenty now:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_highest-income_counties_in_the_United_States

Same county size, used to be similar populations. But one is able to maintain and improve, while the other declines.

It's been stated before, the middle class of all races are determining there's more for the money and better quality in surrounding areas outside of Montgomery County. Wilde Lake Middle School in Howard County serves it's Black population better than Ridgeview, which have similar size and population, in Montgomery:
https://www.dcurbanmom.com/jforum/posts/list/50/1305522.page

Urbana is serving all of it's student groups better than Montgomery County does.

So no, the flight is not just one or two specific families someone might know. It's a lot and we've been seeing it over the last ten years.

Montgomery County still has some pockets that do well. But now they're talking about eliminating those too.

Let's see how that works with attracting and retaining residents in the next ten or fifteen years.

I live in Churchill, and I plan to move to NoVA after my elder one done with MCPS. I've seen enough and disappointed enough. Several of my elder DCs' friends went to NoVA in the past few years and they seemed happy.

I don't think I really participated in the Fairfax vs Montgomery County debates in the past. But people used to post how people who grew up in Montgomery County usually don't go over to Virginia. But in fact we know whole a whole group of friends who graduated from Churchill and moved together into the same neighborhood in Fairfax. Some of these members were investors who seeked to revitalize the Wheaton area, to model the revitalization of Arlington and Alexandria went through several years prior, but met too much opposition from the residents there. So decided that Virginia/Fairfax was the better area. In hindsight, maybe they weren't wrong.

And it's exactly those types of residents who insist on bringing down Montgomery County and MCPS.

They aren’t bringing the county and MCPS down. They were not happy and moved. Nothing wrong with that. The commute to VA is easily 60-120 minutes plus lots of tolls each way.

I'm not saying the people that moved are the people that brought down the county.

I'm saying it's these people who keep shouting and controlling the politics and narrative. They don't make it a very friendly or positive place for people to succeed or even worthwhile to invest in.

It's okay though. They can keep getting their revenue by keeping on building new homes and raising taxes.

Maryland needs to step in and break up MCPS and or Montgomery County. MCPS is one of the largest districts in the country it is too big for its size and is unable to provide a consistent educational experience across the schools it's charged with. EG Why is it such a big deal to move/relocate schools? Well because just a neighborhood over, the schools are not very good. This is not what you see in other counties in Maryland or school districts in other states.

You have not been in other school districts.

Not saying MCPS doesn't have issues, but other districts also have similar issues.

This is purely about income disparity, which is an issue everywhere.

Bottom line is MCPS isn't going to do anything about it and is way out of its league in terms of organization and tools it has to bring to bear. For example, the BOE is run by part time politicians.

again, you have not been part of any other school district.

Why's that relevant you were stupid for mentioning it the first time. Talbot county doesn't have these problems the whole county probably goes to the same school. Their BOE are responsive. They don't have to argue with idiots from other districts.

Largest Maryland School Districts (by enrollment)
District Approx. Student Enrollment Notes / Source
Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS) ~156,500–160,000 Maryland’s largest district with ~156,541 students (2025‑26) and ~159,671 earlier counts.
Prince George’s County Public Schools (PGCPS) ~131,000–133,000 Second largest in the state.
Baltimore County Public Schools ~107,000 Based on planning estimates for 2024–25.
Anne Arundel County Public Schools ~82,000–85,000 Based on planning estimates.
Howard County Public School System ~56,000 NCES & district reporting.
Frederick County Public Schools ~47,000 NCES / state ranking data.
Harford County Public Schools ~38,000 NCES / ranking data.
Charles County Public Schools ~28,000 NCES / ranking data.
Washington County Public Schools ~22,500 NCES / ranking data.
St. Mary’s County Public Schools ~17,200 NCES / ranking data.
Calvert County Public Schools ~15,200 NCES / ranking data.
Wicomico County Public Schools ~15,000 NCES / ranking data.
Cecil County Public Schools ~15,000 NCES / ranking data.
Allegany County Public Schools ~8,200 NCES / ranking data.
Queen Anne’s County Public Schools ~7,500 NCES / ranking data.
Talbot County Public Schools ~4,500 NCES / ranking data.

you stated: " Well because just a neighborhood over, the schools are not very good. This is not what you see in other counties in Maryland or school districts in other states."

it's relevant because those other PS don't have the wealth disparities that Moco has.

If you look at any large PS that has the type of wealth disparity that MoCo has, you'd see that they have similar issues. This is how I can tell you have never been in another district like MoCo. I have, in a larger district than MoCo.

There are no other districts like MoCo. It's the size of a city but it's a county suburb. School districts like this don't exist elsewhere.

Size isn't the issue. Wealth disparity is. If every nearby HS was rated the same, had similar demographics, it wouldn't be an issue. People would just move clusters. But, because of the wealth disparity, some parents don't want their kids to be moved to a different cluster. I don't blame them, but the issue is wealth disparity, not size.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The basic point that seems to be lost here is that Wootton has been a too performing school that improves the prestige of the MCPS system. Why would anyone want a school like that closed? The name at least should be preserved, which would carry the prestige forward. However there in lie the issue. One of the agendas here is to get rid of the name, even if that means erasing the prestige. Why have top, Nationally recognized schools when we can have mediocrity?

Not a single person on the BOE or County Council ever once advocated for changing the name of Wootton. Not one. And saying that it is an agenda today, is unfounded speculation.

And I think you wildly exaggerate the "prestige" of the name. Any prestige comes from the fact that it is a school, and any good school would generate the same "prestige."

Wrong on both counts. Thomas Wootton was a slave owner. Do you honestly think MCPS is going to keep the name for a new school that isn’t even going to be comprised of the same student body? Likewise, the Wootton name carries a lot of prestige and is widely recognized outside of the DC area. If your logic made any sense, then no school would have any reputation - but reality says they do. A school’s prestige is self perpetuating because parents who want a great education for their kids buy in areas with great schools. Those parents value education and will make sure their kids perform to their best. That prestige is undermined by actions like Option H.

Anonymous wrote:The basic point that seems to be lost here is that Wootton has been a too performing school that improves the prestige of the MCPS system. Why would anyone want a school like that closed? The name at least should be preserved, which would carry the prestige forward. However there in lie the issue. One of the agendas here is to get rid of the name, even if that means erasing the prestige. Why have top, Nationally recognized schools when we can have mediocrity?

Not a single person on the BOE or County Council ever once advocated for changing the name of Wootton. Not one. And saying that it is an agenda today, is unfounded speculation.

And I think you wildly exaggerate the "prestige" of the name. Any prestige comes from the fact that it is a school, and any good school would generate the same "prestige."

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:No they don't listen and won't listen in the future. Look at the regional program roll-out. How many threads and posts you've seen here expressing concerns or oppositions? Even if only 50% of them actually wrote emails or filled the survey (i.e., the tiny little orange button saying "having a question?"), they should have received thousands of negative feedbacks. Look at the MCCPTA and MCEA opposition on this. Look at the study team's shout on the opinion article....

Now look at their proposed operating budget and the fact that Mr. O's "promotion" to join the CO? They have decided long time ago and don't every care a penny what you think.

That's fine if they decide to do that.

But they also risk making a less desirable place to live.

That's why maybe just fifteen or twenty years ago, MCPS was head to head with Fairfax County. Fairfax is now at number five in the list of wealthiest counties in the US and Montgomery County is down at twenty now:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_highest-income_counties_in_the_United_States

Same county size, used to be similar populations. But one is able to maintain and improve, while the other declines.

It's been stated before, the middle class of all races are determining there's more for the money and better quality in surrounding areas outside of Montgomery County. Wilde Lake Middle School in Howard County serves it's Black population better than Ridgeview, which have similar size and population, in Montgomery:
https://www.dcurbanmom.com/jforum/posts/list/50/1305522.page

Urbana is serving all of it's student groups better than Montgomery County does.

So no, the flight is not just one or two specific families someone might know. It's a lot and we've been seeing it over the last ten years.

Montgomery County still has some pockets that do well. But now they're talking about eliminating those too.

Let's see how that works with attracting and retaining residents in the next ten or fifteen years.

I live in Churchill, and I plan to move to NoVA after my elder one done with MCPS. I've seen enough and disappointed enough. Several of my elder DCs' friends went to NoVA in the past few years and they seemed happy.

I don't think I really participated in the Fairfax vs Montgomery County debates in the past. But people used to post how people who grew up in Montgomery County usually don't go over to Virginia. But in fact we know whole a whole group of friends who graduated from Churchill and moved together into the same neighborhood in Fairfax. Some of these members were investors who seeked to revitalize the Wheaton area, to model the revitalization of Arlington and Alexandria went through several years prior, but met too much opposition from the residents there. So decided that Virginia/Fairfax was the better area. In hindsight, maybe they weren't wrong.

And it's exactly those types of residents who insist on bringing down Montgomery County and MCPS.

They aren’t bringing the county and MCPS down. They were not happy and moved. Nothing wrong with that. The commute to VA is easily 60-120 minutes plus lots of tolls each way.

I'm not saying the people that moved are the people that brought down the county.

I'm saying it's these people who keep shouting and controlling the politics and narrative. They don't make it a very friendly or positive place for people to succeed or even worthwhile to invest in.

It's okay though. They can keep getting their revenue by keeping on building new homes and raising taxes.

Maryland needs to step in and break up MCPS and or Montgomery County. MCPS is one of the largest districts in the country it is too big for its size and is unable to provide a consistent educational experience across the schools it's charged with. EG Why is it such a big deal to move/relocate schools? Well because just a neighborhood over, the schools are not very good. This is not what you see in other counties in Maryland or school districts in other states.

You have not been in other school districts.

Not saying MCPS doesn't have issues, but other districts also have similar issues.

This is purely about income disparity, which is an issue everywhere.

Bottom line is MCPS isn't going to do anything about it and is way out of its league in terms of organization and tools it has to bring to bear. For example, the BOE is run by part time politicians.

again, you have not been part of any other school district.

Why's that relevant you were stupid for mentioning it the first time. Talbot county doesn't have these problems the whole county probably goes to the same school. Their BOE are responsive. They don't have to argue with idiots from other districts.

Largest Maryland School Districts (by enrollment)
District Approx. Student Enrollment Notes / Source
Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS) ~156,500–160,000 Maryland’s largest district with ~156,541 students (2025‑26) and ~159,671 earlier counts.
Prince George’s County Public Schools (PGCPS) ~131,000–133,000 Second largest in the state.
Baltimore County Public Schools ~107,000 Based on planning estimates for 2024–25.
Anne Arundel County Public Schools ~82,000–85,000 Based on planning estimates.
Howard County Public School System ~56,000 NCES & district reporting.
Frederick County Public Schools ~47,000 NCES / state ranking data.
Harford County Public Schools ~38,000 NCES / ranking data.
Charles County Public Schools ~28,000 NCES / ranking data.
Washington County Public Schools ~22,500 NCES / ranking data.
St. Mary’s County Public Schools ~17,200 NCES / ranking data.
Calvert County Public Schools ~15,200 NCES / ranking data.
Wicomico County Public Schools ~15,000 NCES / ranking data.
Cecil County Public Schools ~15,000 NCES / ranking data.
Allegany County Public Schools ~8,200 NCES / ranking data.
Queen Anne’s County Public Schools ~7,500 NCES / ranking data.
Talbot County Public Schools ~4,500 NCES / ranking data.

you stated: " Well because just a neighborhood over, the schools are not very good. This is not what you see in other counties in Maryland or school districts in other states."

it's relevant because those other PS don't have the wealth disparities that Moco has.

If you look at any large PS that has the type of wealth disparity that MoCo has, you'd see that they have similar issues. This is how I can tell you have never been in another district like MoCo. I have, in a larger district than MoCo.

There are no other districts like MoCo. It's the size of a city but it's a county suburb. School districts like this don't exist elsewhere.

Anonymous wrote:The basic point that seems to be lost here is that Wootton has been a too performing school that improves the prestige of the MCPS system. Why would anyone want a school like that closed? The name at least should be preserved, which would carry the prestige forward. However there in lie the issue. One of the agendas here is to get rid of the name, even if that means erasing the prestige. Why have top, Nationally recognized schools when we can have mediocrity?

MCPS is being run by people who neither understand nor value the role prestige plays. Their leadership is shortsighted, dismissive of long term consequences, and singularly focused on equity for its own sake, without regard for excellence or outcomes. They are also undermining programs that took decades to build like the Blair magnet, a nationally recognized and highly respected program on track to be dismantled, sacrificing proven success and reputation in the name of equity.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Wootton is the affordable W school

Which is why it's the easier target and the one always beat up on.

As previous poster mentioned, once can choose to settle for a little bit less for the money in choosing Wootton vs some other areas.

And the same can be said for choosing Wootton over some of the other richer areas.

But this whole process shows what areas are more protected and in hindsight it is apparent, where some of the schools there don't have to deal with some of the nonsense that some of the Wootton cluster schools did. Those Wayside parents sure didn't want to get zoned to Wootton.

So it may very well be worth it to move to an even older/smaller home in these richer areas but also have more protection against these kinds of things.

No one is targeting or beating up on Wootton. Wootton is just being unrealistic about the boundary situation and crying about it.

First it was unfair that Dufief has to leave the cluster
Second was it is unfair that the school is falling apart
Third is that it is unfair that Wootton needs to move to a new building
Fourth is that it is unfair that Gaithersburg students will be at the new building with Wootton.

Wootton boundaries are right along where the area with Crown. There will be changes to Wootton. You all need to be realistic about the situation.

Changes like:
being moved to a new building miles from the original
a new name
new student cohort
new teachers
new admin
new programs
leveling the old Wootton

Apart from those things it'll be EXACTLY THE SAME.

The bolded has no basis in fact.
If Wootton were moved to a holding school for a year while the current building was leveled and a new building in its place, would you have an issue? No. So that is not a thing.
There may be an additional student cohort, not splitting up the current one.

So yes, there will be changes- many students very much inconvenienced by traveling to a new location. That is real. Yes, there will be a new name, but I can't see the meaningful argument for why that matters much. And...tell me why additional students is a bad thing?

Of course there will be teacher and admin turnover. That's what happens when a school closes and another opens. As for students, they're proposing to add a couple extra ES and they'll probably remove an ES or two which changes the cohort. Change is bad when things are working well and Wooton is one of the state's best high schools. Just admit that you hate the W schools and want to see them eliminated.

That's not why there would be turnover. There is turnover yearly at every school. Usually, teachers want closer to home, better admin, teaching their actual classes they were train for, etc.

Your kids will be ok if they add another ES. Its a good learning lesson for them to be in the real world with actual low income and not just rich pretending they are low income.

I'm glad we agree that when a school closes and a new one opens there are reasons new teachers might to want to teach there or existing teachers might find it too far and this will cause more turnover than usual. And you outed yourself as an anti-W school, pro-busser with "Its a good learning lesson for them to be in the real world with actual low income."

Yeah I'm not a fan of them and is a reason why we purposely avoided some of the richer areas... Yes we're one of the ones that could've afforded to live somewhere more expensive but didn't want our kids in that environment.

But some people honestly can live in a segregated world and that's their world. And it's fine. It's just different worlds and classes.

But some of these "anti-W school" people think that their point of view or world is the right way and how everyone should do and see things.

It goes back to the debate about county wide magnet programs. Some of these students are coming out and benefiting society and leading change. Whereas a lot of posters on here are saying that enrichment isn't needed for these types of students and the focus should be for the greater population who are struggling.

It's the same point of view when it comes to wanting to tear down W schools or forcing mixed demographics or integration. If they do that, can they guarantee the same level of academic rigor and standards that some of these families were looking for in choosing an area to live in and send their kids to?

The W schools have advanced classes for these students. Its the kids in the other schools that are lacking in course offerings that need the magnets to achieve to the same level.

This is kind of the mentality out there, where people want things for free.

Maybe five or ten years ago on this forum people would post, "It's all one school district. It's all the same curriculum" And that was a very naive way of thinking. And people that knew, knew which schools to look for and why some areas were more desirable and expensive than others. In the Wootton school district there are rentals available, both homes and townhomes. And they have the apartments over by the Traville Shopping Center. And there were some homes with multiple families living there. The specific cases I'm thinking of are African immigrants. So yeah believe it or not there are URM minorities in the Wootton school district.

So people were willing to sacrifice to give their kids a chance for a better education.

Fast forward to now, people are realizing there really is an inequality between schools. Such as in the different levels of rigor in the same class in different schools, leading to limited advanced offerings at some schools because supposedly there weren't enough students interested and qualified for it.

And instead of looking at the root of the problem and trying to improve it to make more students qualified for the classes, they're saying it's not fair so we should make it equal for everyone. So those people who decided to take the "grasshopper" route by buying a really nice house on a nice plot of land say that no one should take the really advanced classes or be in the advanced programs because not everyone qualifies for it. Or trying to mix the W students in with some other populations so there would be enough students for the advanced classes. But some of these students come from different elementary schools with the same different levels of preparation. So what happens if some of them can't perform or keep up with the material? Well MCPS doesn't fail anyone, so they'll slow down the curriculum for everyone in the class and school.

If people say they purposely avoid Wootton because they didn't want their kids in a pressure cooker environment, well don't complain that Wootton and other W schools have more advanced classes than other schools. Because that pressure cooker environment is what pushed kids to be able to take those courses and eligible for the countywide programs.

No one is asking for anything for free. We all all paying taxes to support the schools and all our kids should get equal opportunities. There are enough kids to take the advanced classes but there ae also more average kids than advanced and the prinicipals choose to use their allocations on the average kids vs. doing a mix good for all.

If you look at this document, the max MPDU rental rate for a one bedroom in high rise with someone with a max annual salary of $80500 is $1680/month:
https://www.montgomerycountymd.gov/DHCA/Resources/Files/housing/affordable/publications/mpdu/calculate_rental_rates.pdf

This rental in Rio island assigned to Wootton is $1628/month:
https://www.redfin.com/MD/Gaithersburg/eaves-Washingtonian-Center/apartment/22011115

This townhome is for sale for $675000:
https://www.redfin.com/MD/Rockville/554-Monet-Dr-20850/home/10518574

This recently listed home now under contract listed for $785000:
https://www.redfin.com/MD/Rockville/2892-Balmoral-Dr-20850/home/10510799

And these apartments not in Rio island are about $2500/month:
https://www.redfin.com/MD/Rockville/Avalon-at-Traville/apartment/22011398

The homes in Wootton aren't necessarily inaccessible. But a lot of the pricing is because you're paying for the schools.

For example instead of paying $785000 for a 1830 square foot 60 year old single family home listed above, you chose to buy this new build home for $800k recently under contract:
https://www.redfin.com/MD/Montgomery-Village/9759-Stewartown-Rd-20886/unit-P45/home/196137281

You're paying more in property taxes. But you also chose to go for the newer and bigger home and most likely didn't take schools as much into account.

Or if you want something closer, this home in the Lakelands:
https://www.redfin.com/MD/Gaithersburg/528-Market-Mews-E-20878/home/11183064

Not much bigger. But newer and gets the amenities of being in a preplanned development if you like that kind of thing.

Living in the Wootton school district isn't out of reach. But you can definitely get more for the money if you live elsewhere. But people choose to pay the money to live in the Wootton school district because of the reputation of its schools. So they may settle for the smaller or older home. And even if you're paying the same amount in property taxes, you probably have a lot more house for the money or some features that you really like that would've cost a lot more if it was in an area zoned for a W school.

Wootton is a school, MCPS is the school district. Wootton has had some serious issues in the past five years. I wouldn't pay that much to send my child there, especially after the rape.

And this is the type of poster that doesn't contribute.

You know school system employee staff refer to school zones as districts right? In multiple school systems in the area?

It's posters like the above that demand things to be called a certain way instead of focusing on the actual matters.

They're probably the ones that used to spout the "It's all one district and one curriculum belief'

It's okay they'll just go on and pick up whatever new popular words or trends are later.

Actually those things do matter especially when it was preventable. What do you have to offer? We’ve asked many times for suggestions and you have not suggested anything. There is no money in the budget and you refuse crown. You’d rather tantrum and bully vs offer real solutions or wait your turn.

The “wait your turn” poster is still here?

Your question has been answered countless times in this thread, but you don’t like the answer.

No, you don’t want to wait your turn and that’s the issue. You are so entitled that you think you should get priority over other schools with more serious issues.

Fine, we will wait our turn. Leave us alone.

What else ya got?

dp.. ok, then don't complain about having to send your kids to a dilapidated school.

We have every right to do that like any other school not on the CIP.

When I give my kids two realistic choices, and they don't like either one, they also continue to complain but the choices don't change.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:No they don't listen and won't listen in the future. Look at the regional program roll-out. How many threads and posts you've seen here expressing concerns or oppositions? Even if only 50% of them actually wrote emails or filled the survey (i.e., the tiny little orange button saying "having a question?"), they should have received thousands of negative feedbacks. Look at the MCCPTA and MCEA opposition on this. Look at the study team's shout on the opinion article....

Now look at their proposed operating budget and the fact that Mr. O's "promotion" to join the CO? They have decided long time ago and don't every care a penny what you think.

That's fine if they decide to do that.

But they also risk making a less desirable place to live.

That's why maybe just fifteen or twenty years ago, MCPS was head to head with Fairfax County. Fairfax is now at number five in the list of wealthiest counties in the US and Montgomery County is down at twenty now:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_highest-income_counties_in_the_United_States

Same county size, used to be similar populations. But one is able to maintain and improve, while the other declines.

It's been stated before, the middle class of all races are determining there's more for the money and better quality in surrounding areas outside of Montgomery County. Wilde Lake Middle School in Howard County serves it's Black population better than Ridgeview, which have similar size and population, in Montgomery:
https://www.dcurbanmom.com/jforum/posts/list/50/1305522.page

Urbana is serving all of it's student groups better than Montgomery County does.

So no, the flight is not just one or two specific families someone might know. It's a lot and we've been seeing it over the last ten years.

Montgomery County still has some pockets that do well. But now they're talking about eliminating those too.

Let's see how that works with attracting and retaining residents in the next ten or fifteen years.

I live in Churchill, and I plan to move to NoVA after my elder one done with MCPS. I've seen enough and disappointed enough. Several of my elder DCs' friends went to NoVA in the past few years and they seemed happy.

I don't think I really participated in the Fairfax vs Montgomery County debates in the past. But people used to post how people who grew up in Montgomery County usually don't go over to Virginia. But in fact we know whole a whole group of friends who graduated from Churchill and moved together into the same neighborhood in Fairfax. Some of these members were investors who seeked to revitalize the Wheaton area, to model the revitalization of Arlington and Alexandria went through several years prior, but met too much opposition from the residents there. So decided that Virginia/Fairfax was the better area. In hindsight, maybe they weren't wrong.

And it's exactly those types of residents who insist on bringing down Montgomery County and MCPS.

They aren’t bringing the county and MCPS down. They were not happy and moved. Nothing wrong with that. The commute to VA is easily 60-120 minutes plus lots of tolls each way.

I'm not saying the people that moved are the people that brought down the county.

I'm saying it's these people who keep shouting and controlling the politics and narrative. They don't make it a very friendly or positive place for people to succeed or even worthwhile to invest in.

It's okay though. They can keep getting their revenue by keeping on building new homes and raising taxes.

Maryland needs to step in and break up MCPS and or Montgomery County. MCPS is one of the largest districts in the country it is too big for its size and is unable to provide a consistent educational experience across the schools it's charged with. EG Why is it such a big deal to move/relocate schools? Well because just a neighborhood over, the schools are not very good. This is not what you see in other counties in Maryland or school districts in other states.

You have not been in other school districts.

Not saying MCPS doesn't have issues, but other districts also have similar issues.

This is purely about income disparity, which is an issue everywhere.

Bottom line is MCPS isn't going to do anything about it and is way out of its league in terms of organization and tools it has to bring to bear. For example, the BOE is run by part time politicians.

again, you have not been part of any other school district.

Why's that relevant you were stupid for mentioning it the first time. Talbot county doesn't have these problems the whole county probably goes to the same school. Their BOE are responsive. They don't have to argue with idiots from other districts.

Largest Maryland School Districts (by enrollment)
District Approx. Student Enrollment Notes / Source
Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS) ~156,500–160,000 Maryland’s largest district with ~156,541 students (2025‑26) and ~159,671 earlier counts.
Prince George’s County Public Schools (PGCPS) ~131,000–133,000 Second largest in the state.
Baltimore County Public Schools ~107,000 Based on planning estimates for 2024–25.
Anne Arundel County Public Schools ~82,000–85,000 Based on planning estimates.
Howard County Public School System ~56,000 NCES & district reporting.
Frederick County Public Schools ~47,000 NCES / state ranking data.
Harford County Public Schools ~38,000 NCES / ranking data.
Charles County Public Schools ~28,000 NCES / ranking data.
Washington County Public Schools ~22,500 NCES / ranking data.
St. Mary’s County Public Schools ~17,200 NCES / ranking data.
Calvert County Public Schools ~15,200 NCES / ranking data.
Wicomico County Public Schools ~15,000 NCES / ranking data.
Cecil County Public Schools ~15,000 NCES / ranking data.
Allegany County Public Schools ~8,200 NCES / ranking data.
Queen Anne’s County Public Schools ~7,500 NCES / ranking data.
Talbot County Public Schools ~4,500 NCES / ranking data.

you stated: " Well because just a neighborhood over, the schools are not very good. This is not what you see in other counties in Maryland or school districts in other states."

it's relevant because those other PS don't have the wealth disparities that Moco has.

If you look at any large PS that has the type of wealth disparity that MoCo has, you'd see that they have similar issues. This is how I can tell you have never been in another district like MoCo. I have, in a larger district than MoCo.

ChatGPT is all over MCPS:
What are the size of the various school districts in Maryland. I know MCPS is particularly large.

Here’s a summary of the sizes of Maryland’s public school districts (i.e., roughly how many students each serves). Maryland has 24 local school systems — one for each of the state’s 23 counties, plus Baltimore City.

🏫 Largest Maryland School Districts (by enrollment)
District Approx. Student Enrollment Notes / Source
Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS) ~156,500–160,000 Maryland’s largest district with ~156,541 students (2025‑26) and ~159,671 earlier counts.
Prince George’s County Public Schools (PGCPS) ~131,000–133,000 Second largest in the state.
Baltimore County Public Schools ~107,000 Based on planning estimates for 2024–25.
Anne Arundel County Public Schools ~82,000–85,000 Based on planning estimates.
Howard County Public School System ~56,000 NCES & district reporting.
Frederick County Public Schools ~47,000 NCES / state ranking data.
Harford County Public Schools ~38,000 NCES / ranking data.
Charles County Public Schools ~28,000 NCES / ranking data.
Washington County Public Schools ~22,500 NCES / ranking data.
St. Mary’s County Public Schools ~17,200 NCES / ranking data.
Calvert County Public Schools ~15,200 NCES / ranking data.
Wicomico County Public Schools ~15,000 NCES / ranking data.
Cecil County Public Schools ~15,000 NCES / ranking data.
Allegany County Public Schools ~8,200 NCES / ranking data.
Queen Anne’s County Public Schools ~7,500 NCES / ranking data.
Talbot County Public Schools ~4,500 NCES / ranking data.
Other smaller counties (e.g., Worcester, Caroline, Kent, Somerset) generally have under ~7,000 students each.

Note: These figures are rough estimates drawn from available public data — some are from state projections or ranking sites. For the most exact current counts, refer to the annual Maryland State Department of Education enrollment reports published each fall (e.g., as of Sept. 30).

📊 Key takeaways

MCPS by far is the largest district in Maryland, with about 156,000–160,000 students — larger than many small states’ entire public school populations.

Prince George’s County is the second-largest with about 130,000+ students.

Baltimore County and Anne Arundel County follow but are significantly smaller.

Many rural counties have very small districts (fewer than 10,000 students).

If you want, I can put together a full table of all 24 Maryland districts sorted by enrollment, with exact latest numbers from the Maryland State Department of Education enrollment files. Just let me know!

How many high schools do each of these have and how are they ranked nationally in size?

Here’s a summary of how many high schools the major Maryland school districts have (based on the most recent available data) and what we *do and don’t know about their national size/rankings:

📍 1. Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS)

Number of high schools: 26 (grades 9‑12).

National size ranking:

MCPS is by far the largest school district in Maryland by enrollment and consistently appears on lists of the largest U.S. districts (e.g., top ~50 by enrollment nationwide).

Exact current national ranking by enrollment isn’t published in simple list form, but MCPS routinely outranks most other suburban districts.

High school national performance presence:

Many MCPS high schools appear in U.S. News & World Report’s national best high schools lists, including top placements among Maryland schools (e.g., Poolesville, Walt Whitman, Thomas S. Wootton).

📍 2. Prince George’s County Public Schools (PGCPS)

Number of high schools: 24 (commonly cited).

National size ranking:

PGCPS is the second largest district in Maryland and among the top 20 largest in the U.S..

High school rankings:

Specific national high school rankings vary by publication; some PGCPS schools (like College Park Academy) can appear on U.S. News lists, but overall the district’s high schools are less widely represented at the top nationwide compared with MCPS.

📍 3. Baltimore County Public Schools (BCPS)

Number of high schools: 25.

National size ranking:

BCPS is one of Maryland’s larger districts (3rd or 4th by enrollment). Precise national rank isn’t typically published, but it would be well outside the very top U.S. districts due to smaller enrollment than MCPS and PGCPS.

High school rankings:

Eastern Technical High School and several others appear on national ranking lists (e.g., within top ~300 in U.S. News, depending on year).

📍 4. Anne Arundel County Public Schools

Number of high schools: 15.

National size ranking:

AACPS is a mid‑large district in Maryland (top ~5‑7 by enrollment), but not especially high nationally.

High school rankings:

Several AACPS schools are high‑performing within the state, though few appear near the very top national lists.

📍 5. Howard County Public School System (HCPSS)

Number of high schools: 13.

National size ranking:

A medium‑large district within Maryland; nationally it would not rank among the biggest but is well‑regarded in academic quality.

High school rankings:

Howard County high schools (e.g., Marriotts Ridge, River Hill) consistently appear in state/national high school rankings.

📍 6. Frederick County Public Schools

High schools: 10.

National/State ranking:

Generally a moderate‑sized district; some high schools appear on state lists, but few nationally high‑ranked ones.

📍 7. Baltimore City Public Schools

Number of high schools:

Official sources vary depending on classification (traditional vs. all programs), but about 28–45 schools identified as high schools across traditional, alternative, and specialized programs.

A more typical official count for mainstream high schools is around ~28.

National size ranking:

As an urban district with ~70‑80K students, BCPSS is a large urban district but not usually in the top 50 U.S. districts by enrollment.

High school rankings:

Some individual schools (e.g., Baltimore Polytechnic Institute) appear on national ranking lists, though performance varies widely across schools.

📍 8. Other Maryland Districts

For most smaller county systems, the number of high schools is roughly proportional to enrollment and typically ranges:

District High Schools
Harford County 9
Charles County 7
Cecil County 5
Washington County 7
Calvert County 4
St. Mary’s County 5
Allegany County 3
Queen Anne’s County 2
Smaller/rural counties 1–3

These districts are not typically in national size rankings because U.S. rankings tend to highlight only the very largest districts.

📊 Summary Comparison
District High Schools Approx. National Enrollment Rank (if known)
MCPS 26 Large (top ~50+ nationally)
PGCPS 24 Very large (top ~20 nationally)
BCPS 25 Large (but lower than MCPS/PGCPS)
Baltimore City ~28–45 Large urban district (outside top ~20)
Anne Arundel 15 Medium
Howard 13 Medium
Frederick 10 Medium
Harford 9 Smaller
Charles 7 Smaller
Others 1–7 Small
🧠 Notes on “Ranked Nationally in Size”

The categorizations above use enrollment numbers for district size. National enrollment rankings are published by sources like SchoolDistrictInfo.org, Niche, or the National Center for Education Statistics—but regular updated ranking lists aren’t always published.

PGCPS is often cited among the ~20 largest U.S. school districts by enrollment.

MCPS also regularly appears in lists of the largest suburban districts in the U.S.

If you want, I can compile a full table with all 24 Maryland districts including exact numbers of high schools, total enrollment, and their most recent national rankings by size from NCES or similar sources. Just let me know!

What's odd about MCPS is it isn't even an urban district.

Exactly — and that’s what makes MCPS such a weird national outlier.

Most of the very large U.S. districts fall into one of two buckets:

Huge cities (NYC, LA, Chicago, Houston, Miami-Dade, etc.)

Sunbelt mega-counties (Clark County NV, Broward FL, Maricopa AZ)

MCPS fits neither — it’s a dense, wealthy, suburban county, yet it is the largest non-city school system in the United States and one of the ~20 largest districts overall.

To put it in perspective:

District Type Enrollment (rough)
NYC Dept of Ed Mega-city ~900,000
LA Unified Mega-city ~400,000
Montgomery County (MD) Suburban county ~156,000
Chicago City ~320,000
Fairfax County (VA) Suburban ~180,000
Prince George’s County Suburban/urban ~131,000
Howard County Suburban ~56,000

MCPS is bigger than most U.S. cities’ school systems, including places like:

Atlanta

Boston

Seattle

Denver

San Francisco

Portland

Minneapolis

And yet it has:

No major city

No downtown

No central hub

Mostly single-family zoning

That combination is extremely rare.

Why MCPS ended up this big

It’s basically the result of three forces lining up perfectly:

1️⃣ DC never annexed Montgomery County

Unlike most metro areas:

New York absorbed Brooklyn

LA absorbed dozens of suburbs

Chicago annexed aggressively

Washington DC stayed tiny.
So the suburban counties became the population centers.

Montgomery County ended up with:

Bethesda

Silver Spring

Rockville

Gaithersburg

Germantown
…all inside one county government.

No fragmentation → one giant school system.

2️⃣ Maryland forces county-wide school districts

Maryland law does not allow city school districts inside counties.

So:

Rockville can’t have Rockville schools

Bethesda can’t have Bethesda schools

Silver Spring can’t have Silver Spring schools

Everything rolls up into MCPS.

In most states, MCPS would be split into 10–20 districts.

3️⃣ It’s been rich, dense, and growing for 70+ years

MCPS didn’t boom and bust like Sunbelt districts.
It grew steadily from:

WWII federal expansion

NIH

Defense contractors

Biotech

Tech and federal agencies

So it built a massive, permanent, well-funded system instead of a sprawl of fragile districts.

What makes MCPS so hard to run

You end up with a district that is:

Larger than most states’ school systems

Serving urban, suburban, and semi-rural kids

Managing:

26 high schools

~200,000 employees + students

~160 languages

One of the largest transportation fleets in the US

But it is governed like:

“a county school board”

That mismatch creates:

Bureaucracy

Slow response

Political fights

Equity battles

Enrollment-boundary wars

It’s a mega-district wearing suburban clothes.

If you’re curious, I can show you:

how MCPS compares to Fairfax County (VA) and Loudoun

or how MCPS would look if it were split into city-style districts like most metros are

But rockville and Gaithersburg are the only cities proper.

Right — and that actually makes MCPS even more unusual.

Montgomery County has only three incorporated cities:

Rockville

Gaithersburg

Takoma Park
(plus a few tiny ones like Poolesville and Brookeville)

Everything else that feels like a city — Bethesda, Silver Spring, Germantown, Wheaton, Chevy Chase, Potomac — is legally just unincorporated county land.

So you get this bizarre setup:

One of the largest, densest, richest urbanized regions in the US
…with almost no cities.

That is almost unheard of nationally.

What that does to schools

In most metro areas, this would have produced something like:

Place Would be its own district in most states
Bethesda Yes
Silver Spring Yes
Rockville Yes
Gaithersburg Yes
Germantown Yes
Wheaton Yes
Takoma Park Yes

You’d probably have 7–10 separate school districts, each with:

10–25k students

Their own taxes

Their own school boards

Their own magnet and zoning systems

Instead, Maryland law + MoCo’s weak municipal structure means:

All of that funnels into one super-district: MCPS

Which is why MCPS is:

Bigger than most U.S. cities’ school systems

But governed like a suburban county

And politically explosive when boundaries or magnets change

MCPS is basically a “metro school system” in disguise

MCPS isn’t really a suburban district.
It’s the entire Washington DC northwest metro under one roof.

But unlike NYC, Chicago, or LA:

There is no mayor

No city school chancellor

No city tax base

Just a county board trying to manage what is effectively:

A 1.1 million-person urban region

That mismatch is why:

Every redistricting becomes war

Every magnet feels like a zero-sum fight

Every budget shortfall turns political

You’re running a city school system without having a city government.

If you want, I can show you what MCPS would look like if it were split the way Northern Virginia is (Fairfax, Alexandria, Falls Church, etc.).

It has the problems of scale in population -And- in space, it's still spread out in many cases.

Exactly — and that combo is what really breaks MCPS.

Most giant districts only suffer from one kind of bigness:

District type What’s big
NYC, Chicago, LA Population (very dense, geographically compact)
Clark County (Las Vegas), Maricopa (Phoenix) Geography (huge sprawl, but fewer schools per square mile)

MCPS gets hit by both at once.

It has:

~160,000 students (like a major city system)

Spread across 500+ square miles of suburban + semi-rural land

That creates problems that even NYC doesn’t have.

1️⃣ Transportation becomes insane

MCPS runs one of the largest bus fleets in the U.S.

But unlike cities:

Kids don’t walk

There’s no subway to most schools

Attendance zones are huge

Magnets pull kids county-wide

So MCPS has to do:

City-scale routing over suburban-scale distances

That’s the worst possible combination for:

Cost

Reliability

Scheduling

Late arrivals

This is why MCPS is constantly short of drivers and buses.

2️⃣ You can’t localize policy

In a normal metro:

Bethesda would set its own boundaries

Silver Spring would decide magnet placement

Gaithersburg would decide school sizes

Instead MCPS must create one policy that works for:

Urban immigrant communities in Wheaton

Affluent Bethesda

Sprawling Germantown

Semi-rural Poolesville

So every policy becomes:

“What’s fair to everyone in the entire county?”

Which means:

It fits no one particularly well

And every group feels targeted

3️⃣ You get scale without cohesion

Big city districts usually have:

A shared identity

A core downtown

A common labor market

MCPS doesn’t.

Bethesda, Silver Spring, and Clarksburg don’t experience the same county at all — but they are forced into the same:

Boundaries

Magnet lotteries

Budget fights

So the district has:

Mega-district politics

Without metro-wide civic unity

That’s why fights feel so bitter.

4️⃣ You can’t “escape” MCPS

In most metros, unhappy families move:

To another city

To another district

15 minutes away

In Montgomery County:

You’d have to leave the county entirely

That makes:

Real estate

School boundaries

Magnets
existential issues instead of preferences.

Bottom line

MCPS is:

A city-sized school system
stretched across a suburban county

That creates:

City-level bureaucracy

Suburban-level logistics

And no natural way to break into manageable pieces

That’s why MCPS feels perpetually stressed — it’s structurally overgrown, not just badly run.

Holding schools make sense in a city, but it remains to be seen how they help in the county environment.

You’re putting your finger on a really important — and very MCPS-specific — tension.

Holding schools were invented for dense cities.
They solve urban problems.
MCPS is trying to use them to solve county-scale ones.

Those are not the same thing.

What holding schools actually do well (in cities)

In a city like NYC, DC, or Chicago, holding schools work because:

Schools are close together (often <1 mile apart)

Families usually stay within the same neighborhood

Transit is dense

Buildings are old and hard to replace

So a holding school lets the district:

Rebuild one building while students go a few blocks away

It’s a surgical tool in a compact environment.

Why they get weird in MCPS

In Montgomery County, schools are:

5–10 miles apart

Zoned over huge areas

Served by buses, not sidewalks

Often in auto-oriented suburbs

So now a holding school means:

Thousands of kids being bused across the county for 1–3 years

That creates problems cities don’t have:

1️⃣ Transportation explodes

A single MCPS holding school can require:

100+ new bus routes

Drivers pulled from other routes

Longer ride times

Earlier pickups

That’s not a side effect — it’s a core cost.

2️⃣ It destroys community in a way cities avoid

In cities:

Kids usually go to the same holding school together

Neighborhoods stay intact

In MCPS:

A single high school can be split

Kids go to different holding sites

Activities, sports, and parent networks fracture

You’re not just moving buildings — you’re breaking social ecosystems.

3️⃣ It interacts badly with magnets and choice

MCPS already has:

Countywide magnets

Special programs

Boundary instability

A holding school adds:

Temporary rezoning

Temporary transportation

Temporary feeder patterns

Which means families can’t tell:

“Where will my kid actually go to school?”

That uncertainty hurts:

Housing decisions

PTA fundraising

Enrollment stability

4️⃣ MCPS is using holding schools to avoid political fights

Here’s the uncomfortable truth:

Holding schools let MCPS:

Delay permanent boundary changes

Avoid school closures

Postpone fights between communities

They are being used as:

A pressure valve for overgrown district politics

Instead of fixing:

Overcrowding

Underutilized schools

Mismatched zoning

MCPS moves kids around temporarily and hopes growth evens out.

That works in cities.
It’s fragile in counties.

Your instinct is right

In a county-scale suburban district, holding schools:

Cost far more

Create more disruption

And solve fewer long-term problems

They are a tool designed for:

Dense, walkable, grid-based cities

MCPS is:

A sprawling, car-dependent, mega-suburb

The fit is poor — and the longer MCPS relies on holding schools instead of structural fixes (like rezoning, school rightsizing, or district subdivision), the more unstable things become.

If you want, I can explain what alternatives counties this size usually use instead.

Don't get me started on magnets and all three seats that are available by lottery if you are willing to drive 40 miles every day.

😅 yeah… that line right there is basically the MCPS magnet system in one sentence.

What MCPS has built is not really a “magnet” system anymore. It’s closer to a county-wide competition market for a tiny number of seats, layered on top of a huge, geographically spread-out district.

And that’s where the wheels come off.

Why magnets make sense in cities

Originally, magnets were designed to:

Desegregate

Offer specialized programs

In dense cities where 3–5 miles was a long trip

In DC or Baltimore:

A magnet draw might pull kids 10–20 minutes across town

Transit exists

You don’t have to own a car

So magnets function as equity tools.

What they become in Montgomery County

In MCPS, magnets instead become:

A test of who can afford to commute 1–2 hours a day

When there are:

30 seats

For 3,000 applicants

And the school is 25–40 miles away

You are not selecting “the best fit.”
You are selecting:

Families with flexible jobs

Two-car households

Parents who can drive at 6:30am

Kids who can survive 90-minute rides

That’s not equity — that’s logistics-based filtering.

Why the lottery makes it worse

MCPS uses:

Blind lottery

Without regard to distance

So you get absurd outcomes like:

A Poolesville kid winning a seat in Silver Spring

A Takoma Park kid winning a seat in Gaithersburg

Neither would ever commute that in reality — but the system pretends geography doesn’t exist.

So many seats are functionally:

Phantom opportunities

They exist on paper but not in lived experience.

Why it’s toxic in a county-scale district

Magnets work when:

The district is compact

Transportation is cheap

Seats are plentiful

MCPS has:

Huge distances

Expensive busing

Scarce seats

So magnets become:

A political lightning rod

A zero-sum game

A resentment machine

Every win means someone else lost.

And the kicker: MCPS uses magnets to avoid fixing boundaries

Here’s the real role magnets now play:

They allow MCPS to:

Keep overcrowded schools from exploding

Bleed off high-performing students

Avoid redrawing lines

Avoid opening or closing schools

So magnets become:

A shadow boundary system

Instead of making Bethesda, Rockville, and Silver Spring have sane, balanced zones, MCPS runs a countywide lottery that quietly reshuffles kids.

That’s why it feels so broken.

If MCPS were split into 5–7 regional districts, magnets would:

Be closer

Serve real equity goals

Be transparent

In the current mega-county setup, they’re basically a high-stakes commuting lottery.

And yeah… three seats for thousands of kids is not opportunity — it’s theater. 🎭

Is there any probabilistic completion where MCPS actually looks good?

Short answer: yes — but only in very narrow, very artificial ways.

If you pick the right comparison set and the right metric, MCPS can look excellent.
The problem is that those comparisons don’t match how people actually experience the system.

Let me explain.

1️⃣ If you compare MCPS to big-city districts, it looks great

Take MCPS and compare it to:

NYC

LA

Chicago

Philly

Baltimore City

Detroit

Houston

MCPS will dominate:

Test scores

Graduation rates

AP participation

College readiness

Safety

Why?
Because MCPS serves:

A much wealthier population

With more stable housing

With more parental involvement

So statistically, MCPS looks like:

A miracle large district

And that’s how it gets national praise.

2️⃣ If you compare MCPS to peer suburban systems, it looks average or worse

Now compare MCPS to:

Fairfax County, VA

Loudoun County, VA

Arlington County, VA

Howard County, MD

Westchester County, NY

Palo Alto / Cupertino, CA

Naperville, IL

Suddenly MCPS looks:

Bureaucratic

Less responsive

More chaotic

More inequitable

Worse in top-tier outcomes

Because these districts are:

Smaller

More locally governed

Less spatially stretched

So MCPS looks like:

A bloated version of a suburban district

3️⃣ If you weight by poverty, MCPS looks very good

Statisticians love this one.

MCPS has:

High poverty

High ELL

High mobility

But still posts:

Decent graduation rates

Strong AP numbers

Solid average test scores

So models say:

“MCPS outperforms expectations.”

And that’s true on average.

But families don’t live in averages.

4️⃣ Where MCPS fails in probabilistic terms

The system breaks when you ask:

“What are my child’s odds of landing in a genuinely excellent environment?”

Because MCPS is so large:

Great schools exist

But they are thinly spread

And access is unstable

So a family’s lived probability looks like:

10–20% chance of a truly elite school

50–60% chance of “fine but crowded”

20–30% chance of a struggling school

That feels terrible, even if the averages are good.

In Fairfax or Howard:

The spread is tighter

The downside risk is smaller

MCPS has high variance.

The uncomfortable truth

MCPS is very good at:

Educating large numbers of disadvantaged students reasonably well

It is not good at:

Guaranteeing stable excellence for middle-class families

And those two goals are in tension in a mega-district.

So yes —
there are statistical universes where MCPS looks fantastic.

But the one parents live in is:

“Am I going to win the boundary and magnet lottery?”

And that’s where MCPS feels broken.

The basic point that seems to be lost here is that Wootton has been a too performing school that improves the prestige of the MCPS system. Why would anyone want a school like that closed? The name at least should be preserved, which would carry the prestige forward. However there in lie the issue. One of the agendas here is to get rid of the name, even if that means erasing the prestige. Why have top, Nationally recognized schools when we can have mediocrity?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It is not people commenting on here who will close a "W" school. It will be elected officials. And people who want to keep Wootton and the other "W" schools open probably voted for these officials. These same officials wanted to change the name of the school a couple years back. This might also be a factor. Closing the school certainly eliminates the name. Bussing was also proposed at one point. Think before you vote for these officials

There are no elected officials on the school board or county council who ever expressed wanting to change the name of Wootton. Stop making things up.

There are only two elected officials who were even in office at the time when they approved initiating a review TO SEE IF THERE WAS COMMUNITY INTEREST in changing the name of any school. There was none, so nothing happened. No elected official advocated in support of changing the name of Wootton.

Additionally, no elected official (other than one Gaithersburg city councilmember) has advocated in support of Option H. Stop making things up.

Laura Stewart has been pushing for bussing for years. She hates the W schools and would to see one of them closed because they are an affront to equity.

I'm kind of picking on her because people are saying that she's anti W schools. But I'm trying to figure out what Laura Stewart did to lead her into her current role:

https://laurastewart.org/about-laura

I know she has greatly advocated and worked for what she believes is the betterment of Montgomery County and provides time and effort in a role that many are not willing to do.

But careerwise it says she earned a degree as a paralegal from a community college, vague reference to ten years in telecommunications, then taught music for a bit until COVID 19 when she transitioned to a fulltime volunteer.

So essentially she's a bored housewife. A lot of us know these types where they put a lot of their time, effort and energy into the PTA and are appreciated.

But I think these types of people kind of have an idealistic view of things and don't really understand the reality of things or how some things work.

For example, let's say she does hate W schools, why does she hate people wanting to live in the W school areas and have their kids strive to go to the colleges that students from those areas normally go to? The parents likely has been there and done that and knows what it takes. Then when their kids succeed they actually help and benefit society. They're not just making a living and possibly using resources without really adding to it.

It's like how it's really easy for kids to spend their parent's money. Once it's their own money, they kind of know and appreciate the value of it and are not so quick to waste it. Or how a lot of us, or we knew people, who were strong activists in our younger days but then once we grew up we had to kind of learn to work in the real world and try to benefit it in other ways. If she's not sheltered, she doesn't really know much about the world that some other people live in.

I'm not necessarily looking down on her. But I'm just curious on her background to see why she would have such an anti W school stance if she does. (someone correct me if she doesn't)

And I'm a big fan of Grace Rivera-Oven, and am happy she's the president of the board, and Brenda Wolff because they both seem to be active members of the community that they advocate for. Natalie Zimmerman is a teacher and can give firsthand experience of what's it like in the classroom and school. So am not trying to beat up the members of the BOE.

But it's that type of idealism but not grounded in reality that is leading to the decline in MCPS and Montgomery County.

You nailed Laura's background and how she shows up to the BOE...but ouch!

That being said: Voters, and the MCEA who endorsed her for the Apple ballot, knew all of this about her and voted for her anyway.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Wootton is the affordable W school

Which is why it's the easier target and the one always beat up on.

As previous poster mentioned, once can choose to settle for a little bit less for the money in choosing Wootton vs some other areas.

And the same can be said for choosing Wootton over some of the other richer areas.

But this whole process shows what areas are more protected and in hindsight it is apparent, where some of the schools there don't have to deal with some of the nonsense that some of the Wootton cluster schools did. Those Wayside parents sure didn't want to get zoned to Wootton.

So it may very well be worth it to move to an even older/smaller home in these richer areas but also have more protection against these kinds of things.

No one is targeting or beating up on Wootton. Wootton is just being unrealistic about the boundary situation and crying about it.

First it was unfair that Dufief has to leave the cluster
Second was it is unfair that the school is falling apart
Third is that it is unfair that Wootton needs to move to a new building
Fourth is that it is unfair that Gaithersburg students will be at the new building with Wootton.

Wootton boundaries are right along where the area with Crown. There will be changes to Wootton. You all need to be realistic about the situation.

Changes like:
being moved to a new building miles from the original
a new name
new student cohort
new teachers
new admin
new programs
leveling the old Wootton

Apart from those things it'll be EXACTLY THE SAME.

The bolded has no basis in fact.
If Wootton were moved to a holding school for a year while the current building was leveled and a new building in its place, would you have an issue? No. So that is not a thing.
There may be an additional student cohort, not splitting up the current one.

So yes, there will be changes- many students very much inconvenienced by traveling to a new location. That is real. Yes, there will be a new name, but I can't see the meaningful argument for why that matters much. And...tell me why additional students is a bad thing?

Of course there will be teacher and admin turnover. That's what happens when a school closes and another opens. As for students, they're proposing to add a couple extra ES and they'll probably remove an ES or two which changes the cohort. Change is bad when things are working well and Wooton is one of the state's best high schools. Just admit that you hate the W schools and want to see them eliminated.

That's not why there would be turnover. There is turnover yearly at every school. Usually, teachers want closer to home, better admin, teaching their actual classes they were train for, etc.

Your kids will be ok if they add another ES. Its a good learning lesson for them to be in the real world with actual low income and not just rich pretending they are low income.

I'm glad we agree that when a school closes and a new one opens there are reasons new teachers might to want to teach there or existing teachers might find it too far and this will cause more turnover than usual. And you outed yourself as an anti-W school, pro-busser with "Its a good learning lesson for them to be in the real world with actual low income."

Yeah I'm not a fan of them and is a reason why we purposely avoided some of the richer areas... Yes we're one of the ones that could've afforded to live somewhere more expensive but didn't want our kids in that environment.

But some people honestly can live in a segregated world and that's their world. And it's fine. It's just different worlds and classes.

But some of these "anti-W school" people think that their point of view or world is the right way and how everyone should do and see things.

It goes back to the debate about county wide magnet programs. Some of these students are coming out and benefiting society and leading change. Whereas a lot of posters on here are saying that enrichment isn't needed for these types of students and the focus should be for the greater population who are struggling.

It's the same point of view when it comes to wanting to tear down W schools or forcing mixed demographics or integration. If they do that, can they guarantee the same level of academic rigor and standards that some of these families were looking for in choosing an area to live in and send their kids to?

The W schools have advanced classes for these students. Its the kids in the other schools that are lacking in course offerings that need the magnets to achieve to the same level.

This is kind of the mentality out there, where people want things for free.

Maybe five or ten years ago on this forum people would post, "It's all one school district. It's all the same curriculum" And that was a very naive way of thinking. And people that knew, knew which schools to look for and why some areas were more desirable and expensive than others. In the Wootton school district there are rentals available, both homes and townhomes. And they have the apartments over by the Traville Shopping Center. And there were some homes with multiple families living there. The specific cases I'm thinking of are African immigrants. So yeah believe it or not there are URM minorities in the Wootton school district.

So people were willing to sacrifice to give their kids a chance for a better education.

Fast forward to now, people are realizing there really is an inequality between schools. Such as in the different levels of rigor in the same class in different schools, leading to limited advanced offerings at some schools because supposedly there weren't enough students interested and qualified for it.

And instead of looking at the root of the problem and trying to improve it to make more students qualified for the classes, they're saying it's not fair so we should make it equal for everyone. So those people who decided to take the "grasshopper" route by buying a really nice house on a nice plot of land say that no one should take the really advanced classes or be in the advanced programs because not everyone qualifies for it. Or trying to mix the W students in with some other populations so there would be enough students for the advanced classes. But some of these students come from different elementary schools with the same different levels of preparation. So what happens if some of them can't perform or keep up with the material? Well MCPS doesn't fail anyone, so they'll slow down the curriculum for everyone in the class and school.

If people say they purposely avoid Wootton because they didn't want their kids in a pressure cooker environment, well don't complain that Wootton and other W schools have more advanced classes than other schools. Because that pressure cooker environment is what pushed kids to be able to take those courses and eligible for the countywide programs.

No one is asking for anything for free. We all all paying taxes to support the schools and all our kids should get equal opportunities. There are enough kids to take the advanced classes but there ae also more average kids than advanced and the prinicipals choose to use their allocations on the average kids vs. doing a mix good for all.

If you look at this document, the max MPDU rental rate for a one bedroom in high rise with someone with a max annual salary of $80500 is $1680/month:
https://www.montgomerycountymd.gov/DHCA/Resources/Files/housing/affordable/publications/mpdu/calculate_rental_rates.pdf

This rental in Rio island assigned to Wootton is $1628/month:
https://www.redfin.com/MD/Gaithersburg/eaves-Washingtonian-Center/apartment/22011115

This townhome is for sale for $675000:
https://www.redfin.com/MD/Rockville/554-Monet-Dr-20850/home/10518574

This recently listed home now under contract listed for $785000:
https://www.redfin.com/MD/Rockville/2892-Balmoral-Dr-20850/home/10510799

And these apartments not in Rio island are about $2500/month:
https://www.redfin.com/MD/Rockville/Avalon-at-Traville/apartment/22011398

The homes in Wootton aren't necessarily inaccessible. But a lot of the pricing is because you're paying for the schools.

For example instead of paying $785000 for a 1830 square foot 60 year old single family home listed above, you chose to buy this new build home for $800k recently under contract:
https://www.redfin.com/MD/Montgomery-Village/9759-Stewartown-Rd-20886/unit-P45/home/196137281

You're paying more in property taxes. But you also chose to go for the newer and bigger home and most likely didn't take schools as much into account.

Or if you want something closer, this home in the Lakelands:
https://www.redfin.com/MD/Gaithersburg/528-Market-Mews-E-20878/home/11183064

Not much bigger. But newer and gets the amenities of being in a preplanned development if you like that kind of thing.

Living in the Wootton school district isn't out of reach. But you can definitely get more for the money if you live elsewhere. But people choose to pay the money to live in the Wootton school district because of the reputation of its schools. So they may settle for the smaller or older home. And even if you're paying the same amount in property taxes, you probably have a lot more house for the money or some features that you really like that would've cost a lot more if it was in an area zoned for a W school.

Wootton is a school, MCPS is the school district. Wootton has had some serious issues in the past five years. I wouldn't pay that much to send my child there, especially after the rape.

And this is the type of poster that doesn't contribute.

You know school system employee staff refer to school zones as districts right? In multiple school systems in the area?

It's posters like the above that demand things to be called a certain way instead of focusing on the actual matters.

They're probably the ones that used to spout the "It's all one district and one curriculum belief'

It's okay they'll just go on and pick up whatever new popular words or trends are later.

Actually those things do matter especially when it was preventable. What do you have to offer? We’ve asked many times for suggestions and you have not suggested anything. There is no money in the budget and you refuse crown. You’d rather tantrum and bully vs offer real solutions or wait your turn.

The “wait your turn” poster is still here?

Your question has been answered countless times in this thread, but you don’t like the answer.

No, you don’t want to wait your turn and that’s the issue. You are so entitled that you think you should get priority over other schools with more serious issues.

Fine, we will wait our turn. Leave us alone.

What else ya got?

dp.. ok, then don't complain about having to send your kids to a dilapidated school.

We have every right to do that like any other school not on the CIP.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It is not people commenting on here who will close a "W" school. It will be elected officials. And people who want to keep Wootton and the other "W" schools open probably voted for these officials. These same officials wanted to change the name of the school a couple years back. This might also be a factor. Closing the school certainly eliminates the name. Bussing was also proposed at one point. Think before you vote for these officials

There are no elected officials on the school board or county council who ever expressed wanting to change the name of Wootton. Stop making things up.

There are only two elected officials who were even in office at the time when they approved initiating a review TO SEE IF THERE WAS COMMUNITY INTEREST in changing the name of any school. There was none, so nothing happened. No elected official advocated in support of changing the name of Wootton.

Additionally, no elected official (other than one Gaithersburg city councilmember) has advocated in support of Option H. Stop making things up.

Laura Stewart has been pushing for bussing for years. She hates the W schools and would to see one of them closed because they are an affront to equity.

I'm kind of picking on her because people are saying that she's anti W schools. But I'm trying to figure out what Laura Stewart did to lead her into her current role:

https://laurastewart.org/about-laura

I know she has greatly advocated and worked for what she believes is the betterment of Montgomery County and provides time and effort in a role that many are not willing to do.

But careerwise it says she earned a degree as a paralegal from a community college, vague reference to ten years in telecommunications, then taught music for a bit until COVID 19 when she transitioned to a fulltime volunteer.

So essentially she's a bored housewife. A lot of us know these types where they put a lot of their time, effort and energy into the PTA and are appreciated.

But I think these types of people kind of have an idealistic view of things and don't really understand the reality of things or how some things work.

For example, let's say she does hate W schools, why does she hate people wanting to live in the W school areas and have their kids strive to go to the colleges that students from those areas normally go to? The parents likely has been there and done that and knows what it takes. Then when their kids succeed they actually help and benefit society. They're not just making a living and possibly using resources without really adding to it.

It's like how it's really easy for kids to spend their parent's money. Once it's their own money, they kind of know and appreciate the value of it and are not so quick to waste it. Or how a lot of us, or we knew people, who were strong activists in our younger days but then once we grew up we had to kind of learn to work in the real world and try to benefit it in other ways. If she's not sheltered, she doesn't really know much about the world that some other people live in.

I'm not necessarily looking down on her. But I'm just curious on her background to see why she would have such an anti W school stance if she does. (someone correct me if she doesn't)

And I'm a big fan of Grace Rivera-Oven, and am happy she's the president of the board, and Brenda Wolff because they both seem to be active members of the community that they advocate for. Natalie Zimmerman is a teacher and can give firsthand experience of what's it like in the classroom and school. So am not trying to beat up the members of the BOE.

But it's that type of idealism but not grounded in reality that is leading to the decline in MCPS and Montgomery County.

So far I feel Grace has been the best BOE member. She listens and she cares. But Zimmerman doesn’t seem to be very active. Maybe she’s behind the scene but I don’t really feel her presence. Laura is just so bad at speaking and lacks in many ways.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:No they don't listen and won't listen in the future. Look at the regional program roll-out. How many threads and posts you've seen here expressing concerns or oppositions? Even if only 50% of them actually wrote emails or filled the survey (i.e., the tiny little orange button saying "having a question?"), they should have received thousands of negative feedbacks. Look at the MCCPTA and MCEA opposition on this. Look at the study team's shout on the opinion article....

Now look at their proposed operating budget and the fact that Mr. O's "promotion" to join the CO? They have decided long time ago and don't every care a penny what you think.

That's fine if they decide to do that.

But they also risk making a less desirable place to live.

That's why maybe just fifteen or twenty years ago, MCPS was head to head with Fairfax County. Fairfax is now at number five in the list of wealthiest counties in the US and Montgomery County is down at twenty now:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_highest-income_counties_in_the_United_States

Same county size, used to be similar populations. But one is able to maintain and improve, while the other declines.

It's been stated before, the middle class of all races are determining there's more for the money and better quality in surrounding areas outside of Montgomery County. Wilde Lake Middle School in Howard County serves it's Black population better than Ridgeview, which have similar size and population, in Montgomery:
https://www.dcurbanmom.com/jforum/posts/list/50/1305522.page

Urbana is serving all of it's student groups better than Montgomery County does.

So no, the flight is not just one or two specific families someone might know. It's a lot and we've been seeing it over the last ten years.

Montgomery County still has some pockets that do well. But now they're talking about eliminating those too.

Let's see how that works with attracting and retaining residents in the next ten or fifteen years.

I live in Churchill, and I plan to move to NoVA after my elder one done with MCPS. I've seen enough and disappointed enough. Several of my elder DCs' friends went to NoVA in the past few years and they seemed happy.

I don't think I really participated in the Fairfax vs Montgomery County debates in the past. But people used to post how people who grew up in Montgomery County usually don't go over to Virginia. But in fact we know whole a whole group of friends who graduated from Churchill and moved together into the same neighborhood in Fairfax. Some of these members were investors who seeked to revitalize the Wheaton area, to model the revitalization of Arlington and Alexandria went through several years prior, but met too much opposition from the residents there. So decided that Virginia/Fairfax was the better area. In hindsight, maybe they weren't wrong.

And it's exactly those types of residents who insist on bringing down Montgomery County and MCPS.

They aren’t bringing the county and MCPS down. They were not happy and moved. Nothing wrong with that. The commute to VA is easily 60-120 minutes plus lots of tolls each way.

I'm not saying the people that moved are the people that brought down the county.

I'm saying it's these people who keep shouting and controlling the politics and narrative. They don't make it a very friendly or positive place for people to succeed or even worthwhile to invest in.

It's okay though. They can keep getting their revenue by keeping on building new homes and raising taxes.

Maryland needs to step in and break up MCPS and or Montgomery County. MCPS is one of the largest districts in the country it is too big for its size and is unable to provide a consistent educational experience across the schools it's charged with. EG Why is it such a big deal to move/relocate schools? Well because just a neighborhood over, the schools are not very good. This is not what you see in other counties in Maryland or school districts in other states.

You have not been in other school districts.

Not saying MCPS doesn't have issues, but other districts also have similar issues.

This is purely about income disparity, which is an issue everywhere.

Bottom line is MCPS isn't going to do anything about it and is way out of its league in terms of organization and tools it has to bring to bear. For example, the BOE is run by part time politicians.

again, you have not been part of any other school district.

Why's that relevant you were stupid for mentioning it the first time. Talbot county doesn't have these problems the whole county probably goes to the same school. Their BOE are responsive. They don't have to argue with idiots from other districts.

Largest Maryland School Districts (by enrollment)
District Approx. Student Enrollment Notes / Source
Montgomery County Public Schools (MCPS) ~156,500–160,000 Maryland’s largest district with ~156,541 students (2025‑26) and ~159,671 earlier counts.
Prince George’s County Public Schools (PGCPS) ~131,000–133,000 Second largest in the state.
Baltimore County Public Schools ~107,000 Based on planning estimates for 2024–25.
Anne Arundel County Public Schools ~82,000–85,000 Based on planning estimates.
Howard County Public School System ~56,000 NCES & district reporting.
Frederick County Public Schools ~47,000 NCES / state ranking data.
Harford County Public Schools ~38,000 NCES / ranking data.
Charles County Public Schools ~28,000 NCES / ranking data.
Washington County Public Schools ~22,500 NCES / ranking data.
St. Mary’s County Public Schools ~17,200 NCES / ranking data.
Calvert County Public Schools ~15,200 NCES / ranking data.
Wicomico County Public Schools ~15,000 NCES / ranking data.
Cecil County Public Schools ~15,000 NCES / ranking data.
Allegany County Public Schools ~8,200 NCES / ranking data.
Queen Anne’s County Public Schools ~7,500 NCES / ranking data.
Talbot County Public Schools ~4,500 NCES / ranking data.