Anonymous wrote:The boundary study report has been posted to the website. (Not a recommendation yet, just a summary.)

https://www.montgomeryschoolsmd.org/departments/planning/UpcountyHSBoundaryStudy.aspx

Anonymous wrote:Was anyone able to attend or watch the boundary meetings over the past few days at SVHS and NWHS? Any more news on progress with the study?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Well, yeah. But at least 2 ESs, Gibbs and Clarksburg, currently serve both Germantown and Clarksburg addresses, and no one's ES is changing....

Clarksburg ES doesn't serve anyone with a Germantown address.

http://gis.mcpsmd.org/ServiceAreaMaps/ClarksburgES.pdf

Anonymous wrote:

Fine, then elementary schools that have a Germantown address should go to a MS, and a HS that are in Germantown. Elementary schools with a Clarksburg address should go to Middle Schools and the high school that have a Clarksburg address.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:As we eagerly await the proposed boundaries for the three schools, I am interested in what you all 'hope' to see, boundary-wise.

What do you hope the new boundaries will look like? What about the student bodies at all 3 schools?

What I hope isn't the same as what will happen of course. But in my opinion, Clarksburg kids should go to Clarksburg High. Germantown kids should go to Seneca Valley and Northwest. Those 2 schools serve Germantown. When Clarksburg was built, years ago, they decided to take some of the neighborhoods previously zoned for SVHS to Clarksburg to address overcrowding. Now that SVHS is renovating and can handle more students, it only makes sense that Germantown kids are zoned back to SVHS. SVHS from what MCPS is telling us is going to be a really nice school when it's done so based on that, we should assume that it would serve the community well.

But how are you defining "Clarksburg kid" vs. "Germantown kid"? MCPS has already said that the building blocks for the new boundaries will be the current elementary school zones, and those don't correspond to the boundaries of Clarksburg and Germantown.

Clarksburg kid is a kid who lives in Clarksburg. Germantown kid is a kid who lives in Germantown.

Well, yeah. But at least 2 ESs, Gibbs and Clarksburg, currently serve both Germantown and Clarksburg addresses, and no one's ES is changing....

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:As we eagerly await the proposed boundaries for the three schools, I am interested in what you all 'hope' to see, boundary-wise.

What do you hope the new boundaries will look like? What about the student bodies at all 3 schools?

What I hope isn't the same as what will happen of course. But in my opinion, Clarksburg kids should go to Clarksburg High. Germantown kids should go to Seneca Valley and Northwest. Those 2 schools serve Germantown. When Clarksburg was built, years ago, they decided to take some of the neighborhoods previously zoned for SVHS to Clarksburg to address overcrowding. Now that SVHS is renovating and can handle more students, it only makes sense that Germantown kids are zoned back to SVHS. SVHS from what MCPS is telling us is going to be a really nice school when it's done so based on that, we should assume that it would serve the community well.

Anonymous wrote:

Well, yeah. But at least 2 ESs, Gibbs and Clarksburg, currently serve both Germantown and Clarksburg addresses, and no one's ES is changing....

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:As we eagerly await the proposed boundaries for the three schools, I am interested in what you all 'hope' to see, boundary-wise.

What do you hope the new boundaries will look like? What about the student bodies at all 3 schools?

What I hope isn't the same as what will happen of course. But in my opinion, Clarksburg kids should go to Clarksburg High. Germantown kids should go to Seneca Valley and Northwest. Those 2 schools serve Germantown. When Clarksburg was built, years ago, they decided to take some of the neighborhoods previously zoned for SVHS to Clarksburg to address overcrowding. Now that SVHS is renovating and can handle more students, it only makes sense that Germantown kids are zoned back to SVHS. SVHS from what MCPS is telling us is going to be a really nice school when it's done so based on that, we should assume that it would serve the community well.

As you probably know, what "Germantown kids should go to Germantown high schools" means, historically, is, "We don't want those poor black and Latino kids from Germantown at our school in Clarksburg."

There may very well be poor black and Latino kids from Germantown just as there are other ethnic groups from various SES there. It's not like Germantown is all poor. Note Clarksburg is already pretty diverse. It really doesn't need Germantown to up it's diversity so I don't buy it. BOttom line, Clarksburg HS was meant to serve the Clarksburg community. Seneca Valley was meant to serve the Germantown community. Let's focus on making Seneca Valley a great school, so that people in Germantown would WANT to go to Seneca Valley.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:As we eagerly await the proposed boundaries for the three schools, I am interested in what you all 'hope' to see, boundary-wise.

What do you hope the new boundaries will look like? What about the student bodies at all 3 schools?

What I hope isn't the same as what will happen of course. But in my opinion, Clarksburg kids should go to Clarksburg High. Germantown kids should go to Seneca Valley and Northwest. Those 2 schools serve Germantown. When Clarksburg was built, years ago, they decided to take some of the neighborhoods previously zoned for SVHS to Clarksburg to address overcrowding. Now that SVHS is renovating and can handle more students, it only makes sense that Germantown kids are zoned back to SVHS. SVHS from what MCPS is telling us is going to be a really nice school when it's done so based on that, we should assume that it would serve the community well.

But how are you defining "Clarksburg kid" vs. "Germantown kid"? MCPS has already said that the building blocks for the new boundaries will be the current elementary school zones, and those don't correspond to the boundaries of Clarksburg and Germantown.

Clarksburg kid is a kid who lives in Clarksburg. Germantown kid is a kid who lives in Germantown.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:As we eagerly await the proposed boundaries for the three schools, I am interested in what you all 'hope' to see, boundary-wise.

What do you hope the new boundaries will look like? What about the student bodies at all 3 schools?

What I hope isn't the same as what will happen of course. But in my opinion, Clarksburg kids should go to Clarksburg High. Germantown kids should go to Seneca Valley and Northwest. Those 2 schools serve Germantown. When Clarksburg was built, years ago, they decided to take some of the neighborhoods previously zoned for SVHS to Clarksburg to address overcrowding. Now that SVHS is renovating and can handle more students, it only makes sense that Germantown kids are zoned back to SVHS. SVHS from what MCPS is telling us is going to be a really nice school when it's done so based on that, we should assume that it would serve the community well.

But how are you defining "Clarksburg kid" vs. "Germantown kid"? MCPS has already said that the building blocks for the new boundaries will be the current elementary school zones, and those don't correspond to the boundaries of Clarksburg and Germantown.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:As we eagerly await the proposed boundaries for the three schools, I am interested in what you all 'hope' to see, boundary-wise.

What do you hope the new boundaries will look like? What about the student bodies at all 3 schools?

What I hope isn't the same as what will happen of course. But in my opinion, Clarksburg kids should go to Clarksburg High. Germantown kids should go to Seneca Valley and Northwest. Those 2 schools serve Germantown. When Clarksburg was built, years ago, they decided to take some of the neighborhoods previously zoned for SVHS to Clarksburg to address overcrowding. Now that SVHS is renovating and can handle more students, it only makes sense that Germantown kids are zoned back to SVHS. SVHS from what MCPS is telling us is going to be a really nice school when it's done so based on that, we should assume that it would serve the community well.

As you probably know, what "Germantown kids should go to Germantown high schools" means, historically, is, "We don't want those poor black and Latino kids from Germantown at our school in Clarksburg."

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:As we eagerly await the proposed boundaries for the three schools, I am interested in what you all 'hope' to see, boundary-wise.

What do you hope the new boundaries will look like? What about the student bodies at all 3 schools?

What I hope isn't the same as what will happen of course. But in my opinion, Clarksburg kids should go to Clarksburg High. Germantown kids should go to Seneca Valley and Northwest. Those 2 schools serve Germantown. When Clarksburg was built, years ago, they decided to take some of the neighborhoods previously zoned for SVHS to Clarksburg to address overcrowding. Now that SVHS is renovating and can handle more students, it only makes sense that Germantown kids are zoned back to SVHS. SVHS from what MCPS is telling us is going to be a really nice school when it's done so based on that, we should assume that it would serve the community well.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:As we eagerly await the proposed boundaries for the three schools, I am interested in what you all 'hope' to see, boundary-wise.

What do you hope the new boundaries will look like? What about the student bodies at all 3 schools?

What I hope isn't the same as what will happen of course. But in my opinion, Clarksburg kids should go to Clarksburg High. Germantown kids should go to Seneca Valley and Northwest. Those 2 schools serve Germantown. When Clarksburg was built, years ago, they decided to take some of the neighborhoods previously zoned for SVHS to Clarksburg to address overcrowding. Now that SVHS is renovating and can handle more students, it only makes sense that Germantown kids are zoned back to SVHS. SVHS from what MCPS is telling us is going to be a really nice school when it's done so based on that, we should assume that it would serve the community well.