Anonymous wrote:Sorry but this is simply not quite right. Yes pregnancy does contribute but it’s not correct to say that the majority of causes is pregnancy. Pelvic floor disorders are extremely common. They are more common in women who have had vaginal births than Caesareans. They are more common in women who have had children than who have not. Mode of delivery has an impact. For example, forceps deliveries result in a 2 to 5 times increase in developing a pelvic floor disorder.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:
NP. If you're going to ask other posters to provide cites for their statements, you should do the same for yours. Obviously this is anecdotal, but I have 19 friends who had babies in the past two years, and zero of them had PTSD or any ongoing physical issues (probably around 2/3 were vaginal and 1/3 c-section). All were in their 30s. I find your 25% figure difficult to believe. And pointing out that someone's experience was not the norm does not invalidate it in any way.
Np...19 and not ONE with significant issues with birth/recovery?? I find that incredulous based on my group of friends, all mid thirties, healthy. Of about 10 in my circle in the past few years, 4-5 experienced lasting difficulties: one had extreme ppd (suicidal thoughts), 2 describe feeling ptsd from traumatic (48 hr+) births with midwives, one of those has ongoing physical recovery issues; another had an emergency premature c which left her with ptsd/nightmares. One experienced late onset ppd that contributed to a divorce. They all worked through it and are amazing moms, though. Fwiw c-sec vs vag didn't seem to matter, but the worst seemed the ones with the longest labors, who I suspect would have been better off with switching to a c after 24 hrs max. I personally only pushed for a few hours but it took me a month to fully recover muscle control enough to stop my pee mid- stream. Luckily that was my only lasting issue (which really freaked me out.)
Look, there's a lot that's not in our control with childbirth and it's a major medical event full of hormonal fluctuations. The best you can hope for is a reasonable, attentive ob and nurses. Openness to adjusting our best laid birthplans as things progress & seeking out help when we need it are the best tips I can offer, from what I've seen in my group.
Plenty of them had issues with the delivery - tearing, epidurals not working correctly, weird reaction to the epidural, blood pressure or heart rate spiking, significant blood loss, pre-eclampsia manifesting right after birth, temporary postpartum anxiety, etc. But none of them had any ongoing mental or physical issues that didn't clear up within a month or two. I agree with your overall assessment though. It's important to be flexible and to have attentive, observant medical practitioners around you.
I'm not doubting you, but as someone with lots of postpartum issues I don't go around advertising them to my 20 closest girlfriends. And at least 4 of my friends in their early to mid thirties all leak now when they cough or sneeze, several have back issues, and a few have confessed that their vaginas and sex lives are not the same. Just because no one has told you what they are dealing with doesn't mean everything is peachy keen. There is a lot of shame and stigma with pelvic floor disorders and most people just don't talk about them.
The vast (vast) majority of pelvic floor dysfunction is because of pregnancy itself, not method of delivery. It is also generally treatable! Consult a specialist physical therapist, you don't have to live like that
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:
NP. If you're going to ask other posters to provide cites for their statements, you should do the same for yours. Obviously this is anecdotal, but I have 19 friends who had babies in the past two years, and zero of them had PTSD or any ongoing physical issues (probably around 2/3 were vaginal and 1/3 c-section). All were in their 30s. I find your 25% figure difficult to believe. And pointing out that someone's experience was not the norm does not invalidate it in any way.
Np...19 and not ONE with significant issues with birth/recovery?? I find that incredulous based on my group of friends, all mid thirties, healthy. Of about 10 in my circle in the past few years, 4-5 experienced lasting difficulties: one had extreme ppd (suicidal thoughts), 2 describe feeling ptsd from traumatic (48 hr+) births with midwives, one of those has ongoing physical recovery issues; another had an emergency premature c which left her with ptsd/nightmares. One experienced late onset ppd that contributed to a divorce. They all worked through it and are amazing moms, though. Fwiw c-sec vs vag didn't seem to matter, but the worst seemed the ones with the longest labors, who I suspect would have been better off with switching to a c after 24 hrs max. I personally only pushed for a few hours but it took me a month to fully recover muscle control enough to stop my pee mid- stream. Luckily that was my only lasting issue (which really freaked me out.)
Look, there's a lot that's not in our control with childbirth and it's a major medical event full of hormonal fluctuations. The best you can hope for is a reasonable, attentive ob and nurses. Openness to adjusting our best laid birthplans as things progress & seeking out help when we need it are the best tips I can offer, from what I've seen in my group.
Plenty of them had issues with the delivery - tearing, epidurals not working correctly, weird reaction to the epidural, blood pressure or heart rate spiking, significant blood loss, pre-eclampsia manifesting right after birth, temporary postpartum anxiety, etc. But none of them had any ongoing mental or physical issues that didn't clear up within a month or two. I agree with your overall assessment though. It's important to be flexible and to have attentive, observant medical practitioners around you.
I'm not doubting you, but as someone with lots of postpartum issues I don't go around advertising them to my 20 closest girlfriends. And at least 4 of my friends in their early to mid thirties all leak now when they cough or sneeze, several have back issues, and a few have confessed that their vaginas and sex lives are not the same. Just because no one has told you what they are dealing with doesn't mean everything is peachy keen. There is a lot of shame and stigma with pelvic floor disorders and most people just don't talk about them.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:
NP. If you're going to ask other posters to provide cites for their statements, you should do the same for yours. Obviously this is anecdotal, but I have 19 friends who had babies in the past two years, and zero of them had PTSD or any ongoing physical issues (probably around 2/3 were vaginal and 1/3 c-section). All were in their 30s. I find your 25% figure difficult to believe. And pointing out that someone's experience was not the norm does not invalidate it in any way.
Np...19 and not ONE with significant issues with birth/recovery?? I find that incredulous based on my group of friends, all mid thirties, healthy. Of about 10 in my circle in the past few years, 4-5 experienced lasting difficulties: one had extreme ppd (suicidal thoughts), 2 describe feeling ptsd from traumatic (48 hr+) births with midwives, one of those has ongoing physical recovery issues; another had an emergency premature c which left her with ptsd/nightmares. One experienced late onset ppd that contributed to a divorce. They all worked through it and are amazing moms, though. Fwiw c-sec vs vag didn't seem to matter, but the worst seemed the ones with the longest labors, who I suspect would have been better off with switching to a c after 24 hrs max. I personally only pushed for a few hours but it took me a month to fully recover muscle control enough to stop my pee mid- stream. Luckily that was my only lasting issue (which really freaked me out.)
Look, there's a lot that's not in our control with childbirth and it's a major medical event full of hormonal fluctuations. The best you can hope for is a reasonable, attentive ob and nurses. Openness to adjusting our best laid birthplans as things progress & seeking out help when we need it are the best tips I can offer, from what I've seen in my group.
Plenty of them had issues with the delivery - tearing, epidurals not working correctly, weird reaction to the epidural, blood pressure or heart rate spiking, significant blood loss, pre-eclampsia manifesting right after birth, temporary postpartum anxiety, etc. But none of them had any ongoing mental or physical issues that didn't clear up within a month or two. I agree with your overall assessment though. It's important to be flexible and to have attentive, observant medical practitioners around you.
Anonymous wrote:For the PPs who found your Cesarean's traumatic, can you comment specifically about what aspects were traumatizing for you? I am just curious as I may need elective Cesarean section and many doctors are pushing me hard to get it because I had PTSD from my vaginal birth.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:[...]
I note that in the posts above there are many examples of trauma. There is a link to a book on traumatic birth. There are many support groups on line with thousands of women who have experienced traumatic births. Please understand that we who have experienced them are trying to warn women that they are more common than we would all like to think so that they can make informed birth choices, and do thigns to prepare, like see a pelvic floor PT and have frank talks with doctors, get a late-term u/s, etc.
Misplaced anger on the part of the PP? I would not say so. Again, people with injuries in this string have made it very clear how this has affected them. It's hard. You need to respect that. It sounds as if you did for your friend.
[...] And would like to see a little more sisterhood, frankly. Because this is something that affects many more people than any of us would like to think.
[...]
Why should we? I have posted in other threads and I think this that I found my fairly straightforward c-section traumatic and that I found the experience of being cut open while awake so traumatizing that I would never again choose that. You don't seem to think my opinion or experience matters, just yours.
I'm sorry for your experience, PP. I also found my c-section extraordinarily traumatic, and have found no one wants to hear about it. Instead, I am constantly told it is a simple surgery and no big deal. I am sorry for your pain.
+1 my c section scarred me emotionally (...literally too!) for life. An awful awful experience; some days I cannot get those sensations out of my mind
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:
NP. If you're going to ask other posters to provide cites for their statements, you should do the same for yours. Obviously this is anecdotal, but I have 19 friends who had babies in the past two years, and zero of them had PTSD or any ongoing physical issues (probably around 2/3 were vaginal and 1/3 c-section). All were in their 30s. I find your 25% figure difficult to believe. And pointing out that someone's experience was not the norm does not invalidate it in any way.
Np...19 and not ONE with significant issues with birth/recovery?? I find that incredulous based on my group of friends, all mid thirties, healthy. Of about 10 in my circle in the past few years, 4-5 experienced lasting difficulties: one had extreme ppd (suicidal thoughts), 2 describe feeling ptsd from traumatic (48 hr+) births with midwives, one of those has ongoing physical recovery issues; another had an emergency premature c which left her with ptsd/nightmares. One experienced late onset ppd that contributed to a divorce. They all worked through it and are amazing moms, though. Fwiw c-sec vs vag didn't seem to matter, but the worst seemed the ones with the longest labors, who I suspect would have been better off with switching to a c after 24 hrs max. I personally only pushed for a few hours but it took me a month to fully recover muscle control enough to stop my pee mid- stream. Luckily that was my only lasting issue (which really freaked me out.)
Look, there's a lot that's not in our control with childbirth and it's a major medical event full of hormonal fluctuations. The best you can hope for is a reasonable, attentive ob and nurses. Openness to adjusting our best laid birthplans as things progress & seeking out help when we need it are the best tips I can offer, from what I've seen in my group.
Anonymous wrote:For the PPs who found your Cesarean's traumatic, can you comment specifically about what aspects were traumatizing for you? I am just curious as I may need elective Cesarean section and many doctors are pushing me hard to get it because I had PTSD from my vaginal birth.
Anonymous wrote:
NP. If you're going to ask other posters to provide cites for their statements, you should do the same for yours. Obviously this is anecdotal, but I have 19 friends who had babies in the past two years, and zero of them had PTSD or any ongoing physical issues (probably around 2/3 were vaginal and 1/3 c-section). All were in their 30s. I find your 25% figure difficult to believe. And pointing out that someone's experience was not the norm does not invalidate it in any way.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:[...]
I note that in the posts above there are many examples of trauma. There is a link to a book on traumatic birth. There are many support groups on line with thousands of women who have experienced traumatic births. Please understand that we who have experienced them are trying to warn women that they are more common than we would all like to think so that they can make informed birth choices, and do thigns to prepare, like see a pelvic floor PT and have frank talks with doctors, get a late-term u/s, etc.
Misplaced anger on the part of the PP? I would not say so. Again, people with injuries in this string have made it very clear how this has affected them. It's hard. You need to respect that. It sounds as if you did for your friend.
[...] And would like to see a little more sisterhood, frankly. Because this is something that affects many more people than any of us would like to think.
[...]
Why should we? I have posted in other threads and I think this that I found my fairly straightforward c-section traumatic and that I found the experience of being cut open while awake so traumatizing that I would never again choose that. You don't seem to think my opinion or experience matters, just yours.
I'm sorry for your experience, PP. I also found my c-section extraordinarily traumatic, and have found no one wants to hear about it. Instead, I am constantly told it is a simple surgery and no big deal. I am sorry for your pain.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:This has been such an interesting discussion and I really feel like I learned a lot from reading the pps stories. I googled levator avulsion and that brought up a lot more information on the topic as well as pelvic exercises and other research.
I had an incredibly simple vaginal birth with epidural. But I was looking for info like that while pregnant so I knew what to ask for and what to try to avoid. I'm pregnant again. I don't know how you avoid long pushing? When I dialated 10cm they told me to push. What should you do if you've been pushing for an hour and you don't know how much longer it will take?
I've worked with older women and my grandmas and great aunts were very candid. They all have pelvic floor issues. Some gave birth with forceps and most had twilight sleep. They all had multiple births. I'm an only child and my mom had me via c section- she has pelvic issues now in her 60s.
This is interesting because my mother also had two children, both via c-section but now in her sixties has uterine prolapse and pretty significant incontinence issues. This is a big discussion amongst her friends of the same age, and their experiences run the gamut, with most having given birth vaginally, and about half with some mild incontinence issues and/or the need for pelvic OT. Interestingly, my mom's closest friend gave birth to six children naturally, and now has zero issues in her seventies. Most experiences are more middle of the road, but she does have a friend who never even experienced pregnancy but has significant incontinence issues in her sixties. I wish there were a better way to predict and protect women's health in this area, regardless of childbearing status or birthing history, and more attention and better treatments available as a whole.