Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I don't understand why people are so up in arms that someone allowed their child to invite just 5 people to her birthday party. Just because this other girl had a party that same weekend doesn't mean the OP had to change their plans. She had a 5 person party. What's the big deal? Are people not allowed to have small parties anymore? And if you opt for a small party, but someone else didn't, that means you can't go to that party? That doesn't make sense to me.

Please read the thread. This is NOT about small parties (I think small parties are great, personally). This is about defending your 7 year old DD's decision to exclude a girl from her birthday party, even as the DD attended other girl's birthday party that very same weekend.

I did read the thread. And it does seem like people are more concerned that the invitation wasn't reciprocated. That because she got to go to the other girl's party, that other girl should have been able to go to hers. I don't think that's necessarily true. People decide what size parties they want to have. She had her 5 person party. The other girl had a larger party. What in god's name is the problem? This is like saying, "You invited me to your wedding. I chose to attend that wedding. Now, even though I'm having a family-only wedding, I have to invite you to my wedding because I went to yours." No sense.

I think you're missing the point that the girl specifically wanted to exclude the other girl - and had no qualms about telling her that - while at the same time going to the other girl's party. I think it would have been a whole other issue if it really was limited to just 5 girls and the mother said, sorry, you only get 5 and the other girl didn't make the cut - which is similar to your wedding example. However, the mom (OP) specifically said that after they got the other girl's invite, she told her daughter they'd make room for the other girl. the dd said no because of XYZ. Then turns around and goes to her party. Does that now make sense?

Hold on there, buster. You just said dd "had no qualms about telling her that."

In fact, dd didn't say anything about it until she was *put on the spot* by the other child who demanded to know why she hadn't been invited. By all of YOUR reasoning, she's a rude little witch because she put dd on the spot.

And for that matter, the third party girl who marched up to the excuded girl and told her ALL about the second party is a bitch too. By your reasoning, that is.

My dd didn't say a THING until confronted. She should have said, "I'm so sorry, my guest list was small and set before I received your invitation" but she is 7 years old so she said what she really thought.

Think what you want, but please stop asigning malice here. You're awful. Beyond awful.

Anonymous wrote:15:34-
Are you the OP? "Uh, no." is childish. My point.

Anonymous wrote:everyone keeps losing sight of the real problem here, which is the the dad allowed 5-person-party-girl to be a total hypocrite. no one cares that she didn't invite the other girl to her party. the fact that she was rude when confronted sucks but it really isn't the main problem either.

the problem is that the PP said it was ok to not invite this little girl because, essentially, his daughter DIDN'T LIKE HER, but that it was then ok to still go to that girl's party anyway.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:My son is almost never invited to b-day parties. He has Asperger's and a hard time socially. Frankly, when I've seen other kids his age at birthday parties or when he does actually go to one or at his own (small) parties, he's no more or less offensive than the other kids. But I know he's hard to take (most kids don't want to discuss his obsessions of course). He loves being around other kids and I can't think it doesn't hurt his feelings to hear the other kids talk about parties. I understand why he's not at the top of the invitee list, but it sure is hard.

I'm the dad of the 5-girl party getting flamed left and right here.

Let me just say that my dd, who has been alternately deemed a mean girl, a bitch, and a whole hosts of other nasties by the superior mothers on this board, counts a boy with asperger's in her class as one of her closest friends. In fact, she talked about inviting him to her party but decided he wouldn't like getting manicures and pedicures with a bunch of girls. So, we took him out to dinner with us one night separately.

What a little cold bitch, eh?

I think you're ignoring that most people, myself included, think the fault here lies with YOU, not your daughter. I do agree that people calling her names are out of line - for cryin' out loud people, she's 7. But all the more reason for an adult to steer her in the right direction. And unfortunately, you failed her. But you seem incapable of any sort of mature self-reflection.

No, that's where you're wrong. You have no standing to assign "fault" because no wrong was done. Your perspective simply isn't valid. I didn't "fail" her. Where do you get that?

Please tell me what the lesson is in demanding a child invite someone to her party she doesn't want to have there?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:My son is almost never invited to b-day parties. He has Asperger's and a hard time socially. Frankly, when I've seen other kids his age at birthday parties or when he does actually go to one or at his own (small) parties, he's no more or less offensive than the other kids. But I know he's hard to take (most kids don't want to discuss his obsessions of course). He loves being around other kids and I can't think it doesn't hurt his feelings to hear the other kids talk about parties. I understand why he's not at the top of the invitee list, but it sure is hard.

I'm the dad of the 5-girl party getting flamed left and right here.

Let me just say that my dd, who has been alternately deemed a mean girl, a bitch, and a whole hosts of other nasties by the superior mothers on this board, counts a boy with asperger's in her class as one of her closest friends. In fact, she talked about inviting him to her party but decided he wouldn't like getting manicures and pedicures with a bunch of girls. So, we took him out to dinner with us one night separately.

What a little cold bitch, eh?

I think you're ignoring that most people, myself included, think the fault here lies with YOU, not your daughter. I do agree that people calling her names are out of line - for cryin' out loud people, she's 7. But all the more reason for an adult to steer her in the right direction. And unfortunately, you failed her. But you seem incapable of any sort of mature self-reflection.

No wrong was done???? In your very first post, you said "I bet those other parents despise us." OP, you KNOW your daughter did something that wasn't nice. Now, you just covering up.
No, that's where you're wrong. You have no standing to assign "fault" because no wrong was done. Your perspective simply isn't valid. I didn't "fail" her. Where do you get that?

Please tell me what the lesson is in demanding a child invite someone to her party she doesn't want to have there?

Anonymous wrote:OP and her husband made a parenting mistake. The problem at hand and the way they dealt with it was a mistake- they should have not let the daughter attend the other girls party and explained basic social etiquette (in 7 yo terms of course).
That being said, it was just that- a mistake. No one needs to be name calling. OP, you're rebuttals and remarks have been off-base and childish, and that's why people have been fueling the fire more than necessary.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:My son is almost never invited to b-day parties. He has Asperger's and a hard time socially. Frankly, when I've seen other kids his age at birthday parties or when he does actually go to one or at his own (small) parties, he's no more or less offensive than the other kids. But I know he's hard to take (most kids don't want to discuss his obsessions of course). He loves being around other kids and I can't think it doesn't hurt his feelings to hear the other kids talk about parties. I understand why he's not at the top of the invitee list, but it sure is hard.

I'm the dad of the 5-girl party getting flamed left and right here.

Let me just say that my dd, who has been alternately deemed a mean girl, a bitch, and a whole hosts of other nasties by the superior mothers on this board, counts a boy with asperger's in her class as one of her closest friends. In fact, she talked about inviting him to her party but decided he wouldn't like getting manicures and pedicures with a bunch of girls. So, we took him out to dinner with us one night separately.

What a little cold bitch, eh?

I think you're ignoring that most people, myself included, think the fault here lies with YOU, not your daughter. I do agree that people calling her names are out of line - for cryin' out loud people, she's 7. But all the more reason for an adult to steer her in the right direction. And unfortunately, you failed her. But you seem incapable of any sort of mature self-reflection.