Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:so all of us assume illegal immigrants pay zero tax? Do we know how much they pay taxes? I know the small business owners and workers always have a way to reduce their taxes, but I also know some illegal immigrants pay taxes to avoid conflicts with IRS. They are more cautious than other groups. If they pay taxes, their kids should get free education.

Illegal immigrants get way more out of us than we get out of them. That’s the exact reason they’re here. If all they wanted was safety then they would have stopped in Mexico or any of the other countries they passed through instead of coming here.

And no, their kids should not get free education. It’s not “free” - we pay for it. And we pay even more for illegals since their kids have much greater needs that we need to address.

Send them all back and permanently end birthright citizenship to stop the future tide of them too. Even Democratic representatives and senators will vote to end birthright citizenship since they know that’s where the vast majority of the country stands on this.

I wouldn't represent the majority of the county until we see the data.

BTW, making the topic from tax raise to immigrants does not make any sense here. If we don't like tax raise, we need to protest against it, not picking up the wars between different groups. I believe all the posts here mentioned the immigrants are trying to change people's attention from the actual tax raise. They may be the bots hired by some county board.

Well we can’t just print money. So if you want to spend more money then you need to raise taxes to pay for it unless you’re willing to make big cuts somewhere else. How else do you think we should pay for these things?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:so all of us assume illegal immigrants pay zero tax? Do we know how much they pay taxes? I know the small business owners and workers always have a way to reduce their taxes, but I also know some illegal immigrants pay taxes to avoid conflicts with IRS. They are more cautious than other groups. If they pay taxes, their kids should get free education.

Illegal immigrants get way more out of us than we get out of them. That’s the exact reason they’re here. If all they wanted was safety then they would have stopped in Mexico or any of the other countries they passed through instead of coming here.

And no, their kids should not get free education. It’s not “free” - we pay for it. And we pay even more for illegals since their kids have much greater needs that we need to address.

Send them all back and permanently end birthright citizenship to stop the future tide of them too. Even Democratic representatives and senators will vote to end birthright citizenship since they know that’s where the vast majority of the country stands on this.

I wouldn't represent the majority of the county until we see the data.

BTW, making the topic from tax raise to immigrants does not make any sense here. If we don't like tax raise, we need to protest against it, not picking up the wars between different groups. I believe all the posts here mentioned the immigrants are trying to change people's attention from the actual tax raise. They may be the bots hired by some county board.

Well we can’t just print money. So if you want to spend more money then you need to raise taxes to pay for it unless you’re willing to make big cuts somewhere else. How else do you think we should pay for these things?

What about stopping the Covid Memorial shit? More incentives for companies to get back employees in the office? Reducing the ESL instead of canceling them? Fairfax county has a large population of immigrants. Most of them are highly educated and paying high taxes. We don’t want them to feel alienated.

The kids of those highly educated foreigners paying high taxes that you want to keep in your country don’t need ESL services in the schools.

- highly educated immigrants paying high taxes

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:so all of us assume illegal immigrants pay zero tax? Do we know how much they pay taxes? I know the small business owners and workers always have a way to reduce their taxes, but I also know some illegal immigrants pay taxes to avoid conflicts with IRS. They are more cautious than other groups. If they pay taxes, their kids should get free education.

Illegal immigrants get way more out of us than we get out of them. That’s the exact reason they’re here. If all they wanted was safety then they would have stopped in Mexico or any of the other countries they passed through instead of coming here.

And no, their kids should not get free education. It’s not “free” - we pay for it. And we pay even more for illegals since their kids have much greater needs that we need to address.

Send them all back and permanently end birthright citizenship to stop the future tide of them too. Even Democratic representatives and senators will vote to end birthright citizenship since they know that’s where the vast majority of the country stands on this.

I wouldn't represent the majority of the county until we see the data.

BTW, making the topic from tax raise to immigrants does not make any sense here. If we don't like tax raise, we need to protest against it, not picking up the wars between different groups. I believe all the posts here mentioned the immigrants are trying to change people's attention from the actual tax raise. They may be the bots hired by some county board.

Well we can’t just print money. So if you want to spend more money then you need to raise taxes to pay for it unless you’re willing to make big cuts somewhere else. How else do you think we should pay for these things?

What about stopping the Covid Memorial shit? More incentives for companies to get back employees in the office? Reducing the ESL instead of canceling them? Fairfax county has a large population of immigrants. Most of them are highly educated and paying high taxes. We don’t want them to feel alienated.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:so all of us assume illegal immigrants pay zero tax? Do we know how much they pay taxes? I know the small business owners and workers always have a way to reduce their taxes, but I also know some illegal immigrants pay taxes to avoid conflicts with IRS. They are more cautious than other groups. If they pay taxes, their kids should get free education.

Illegal immigrants get way more out of us than we get out of them. That’s the exact reason they’re here. If all they wanted was safety then they would have stopped in Mexico or any of the other countries they passed through instead of coming here.

And no, their kids should not get free education. It’s not “free” - we pay for it. And we pay even more for illegals since their kids have much greater needs that we need to address.

Send them all back and permanently end birthright citizenship to stop the future tide of them too. Even Democratic representatives and senators will vote to end birthright citizenship since they know that’s where the vast majority of the country stands on this.

I wouldn't represent the majority of the county until we see the data.

BTW, making the topic from tax raise to immigrants does not make any sense here. If we don't like tax raise, we need to protest against it, not picking up the wars between different groups. I believe all the posts here mentioned the immigrants are trying to change people's attention from the actual tax raise. They may be the bots hired by some county board.

Well we can’t just print money. So if you want to spend more money then you need to raise taxes to pay for it unless you’re willing to make big cuts somewhere else. How else do you think we should pay for these things?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The parents of the many kids showing up in the middle of the school year not speaking a word of english definitely have not paid into the system.

Even if you think that each one gets paid under the table (which not all do!), they still pay property taxes -- passed through to them by their landlords -- and sales taxes. So yes, they definitely do pay into the system.

The landlords would pay the property tax regardless of who is or isn't renting the property. So, no, they don't indirectly pay into the system.

Do you think property tax increases are absorbed by landlords out of the goodness of their hearts? No, they pass those costs on to renters.

The landlords pay the tax. Indirectly paying a tax doesn't convey any responsibility for paying the tax.

A completely meaningless distinction without a difference.

Then isn't the company employing the immigrants paying the property taxes? The renters are just a pass through.

No, because workers are paid a market-clearing wage in a competitive market. Workers are - roughly speaking - paid the marginal value they create. Workers don't command raises when property taxes increase - they can ask, but the answer will likely be no unless the labor market is very tight. Rent is sensitive to property taxes in a way that wages are not.

No sane person would argue that they don't pay sales taxes because they're not the ones cutting a check to the Department of Tax Administration, the store is. But, alas, perhaps I'm not talking to one of those people.

Sales tax is a line item on the receipt. The store holds the tax monies in escrow. Do landlords itemize the property taxes on the rent bill?

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The parents of the many kids showing up in the middle of the school year not speaking a word of english definitely have not paid into the system.

Even if you think that each one gets paid under the table (which not all do!), they still pay property taxes -- passed through to them by their landlords -- and sales taxes. So yes, they definitely do pay into the system.

The landlords would pay the property tax regardless of who is or isn't renting the property. So, no, they don't indirectly pay into the system.

Do you think property tax increases are absorbed by landlords out of the goodness of their hearts? No, they pass those costs on to renters.

The landlords pay the tax. Indirectly paying a tax doesn't convey any responsibility for paying the tax.

A completely meaningless distinction without a difference.

Then isn't the company employing the immigrants paying the property taxes? The renters are just a pass through.

No, because workers are paid a market-clearing wage in a competitive market. Workers are - roughly speaking - paid the marginal value they create. Workers don't command raises when property taxes increase - they can ask, but the answer will likely be no unless the labor market is very tight. Rent is sensitive to property taxes in a way that wages are not.

No sane person would argue that they don't pay sales taxes because they're not the ones cutting a check to the Department of Tax Administration, the store is. But, alas, perhaps I'm not talking to one of those people.