Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I don’t understand why there is a presumption of parental contribution from the stepdad. He is not the student’s father and since he did not adopt her he is not her father. The college’s presumption that an adult without any type of legal parental relationship needs to contribute is outrageous.
The stepfather contributes to the HHI, that's why. Mom lived with the kid as a single parent and now she has another adult to help pay the bills. She should have some savings because of it.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Why should stepdad pay for it when mom has a high income? Thats a bizzare expctation.
Where did you read that mom has a high in income?
This is OP. Neither of the parents makes a high income, especially for this area.
Then why are you assuming she can’t get aid? What is their yearly HHI? Assets?
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:I don’t understand why there is a presumption of parental contribution from the stepdad. He is not the student’s father and since he did not adopt her he is not her father. The college’s presumption that an adult without any type of legal parental relationship needs to contribute is outrageous.
Well, write your congressman and tell them to change the FAFSA rules
Anonymous wrote:I don’t understand why there is a presumption of parental contribution from the stepdad. He is not the student’s father and since he did not adopt her he is not her father. The college’s presumption that an adult without any type of legal parental relationship needs to contribute is outrageous.
Anonymous wrote:I don’t understand why there is a presumption of parental contribution from the stepdad. He is not the student’s father and since he did not adopt her he is not her father. The college’s presumption that an adult without any type of legal parental relationship needs to contribute is outrageous.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Take a gap year or two, work, become independent, then apply & seek need-based financial aid.
Or attend local community college for two years.
One reason I want to help this teen is that I don’t think she feels fully safe and secure in the home with her mom and stepdad. It would be best if she could get away from that.
Can they afford two years of community college then guaranteed transfer to UMD or whatever the state college is? If she works part-time, she could pull it off with a little help from her mother.
And about feeling safe... come on. Is this going to turn into an anti-immigrant screed, OP? Are you saying he's a pedo? A violent drunk? If she really wants to make this work, she needs to save money and live at home while going to college.
This has nothing to do with their national origin. If you can’t imagine a scenario where a teen would feel less than secure and happy in a home where she is, at minimum, treated like an unwanted extra by the stepdad, then you must live a pretty charmed life.
Why should the stepdad take on this financial burden? He may have spousal support to a prior wife or kids of his own (and those college obligations by court order).
She's not asking him to pay. But his income will count against her when she applies for financial aid. Period. Imagine if it didn't count just because he didn't want to pay? Everyone would claim they refuse to pay so the kids can get more aid. What makes him special that his refusal should have no consequences?
Also, if he has spousal support and court ordered college obligations, that goes in the aid application and will be used to lower the "parents' expected contribution." Note: expected, not required.
Anonymous wrote:I went through a similar situation. My widowed mom remarried when I was in 5th grade. It shocked me then and now that colleges counted his higher income in the expected family contribution eve though he was not my biological father and he did not adopt me as his daughter and thus had no legal obligation to provide for me. He was just my mom’s husband. No legal or biological relationship existed beyond that between him and me.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Why should stepdad pay for it when mom has a high income? Thats a bizzare expctation.
Where did you read that mom has a high in income?
This is OP. Neither of the parents makes a high income, especially for this area.
Anonymous wrote:My understanding is that all the parents' income and assets will be considered for aid at private universities. That includes stepdad and dad.
Anonymous wrote:We know a teen whose mom and stepdad seem to have an agreement that the stepdad is not responsible for paying for any of the teen’s college. So it is up to the mom, I don’t think she makes tons of money, but they won’t get as much aid if they have to include the stepdad’s salary.
Is there any way around this? I feel so sorry for this teen. She deserves to go to college.
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:What does she want to be?? Due to AI many current majors will be useless. The military would be a great choice to get the GI bill!
Have you been enlisted military? Not a great choice. Hard life.