Anonymous
09/16/2025 10:01
Subject: Re:NMSFs in DC 2026
Well - they did “drop” if walls kids stayed the same but other kids on average now score higher. Apparently in past DC cut score roughly results in top 1 percent in DC getting NMSF. Wondering if that also happened this year - higher cut score - but even so 1 percent achieved it.
Anonymous
09/16/2025 09:30
Subject: Re:NMSFs in DC 2026
Anonymous wrote:6 down to 3 is 50% decrease at Walls. That is huge
The actual PSAT scores didn’t drop. The cut score rose. And the cut score has nothing to do with DC.
What’s “really really depressing” is the number of people who claim to care about education but seem to be incapable of analysis or critical thought.
Anonymous
09/16/2025 09:08
Subject: Re:NMSFs in DC 2026
6 down to 3 is 50% decrease at Walls. That is huge
Anonymous
09/16/2025 09:05
Subject: NMSFs in DC 2026
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Only 3 NMSF at walls this year (compared with 6 last year)
How do you know this?
Walls sent an email out to school with the three names
That is really really depressing. This is exactly what I thought would happen when they made it easier to get in.
Really really depressing? You don’t know anything about the school. Congrats to those three kids and send your kids elsewhere if this school makes you feel so depressed.
NP, no dog in the fight and no kids in high school.
But it is blatantly obvious that some top kids are not getting into Walls and some kids who would not get in previously are getting in. Data doesn’t lie not matter how much in denial you are.
Anonymous
09/16/2025 08:56
Subject: Re:NMSFs in DC 2026
Cut score went up everywhere because test has gotten easier in particular math where you can use built in Desmos calculator to do the problems for you.
Anonymous
09/16/2025 08:19
Subject: Re:NMSFs in DC 2026
Anonymous wrote:Walls PARCC/CAPE scores:
2018-19 /exam/84.1% (4+ math)/93.4% (4+ ELA)
2023-24/no exam/67.8% (4+ math)/97% (4+ ELA)
ELA seems about the same but math is definitely lower.
There are no decent public options to Walls in DC (other than BASIS DC, which you can't get into after 5th grade) and it only cherry picks A students, so the fact that Walls has some NMS/top students doesn't necessarily mean that the overall school quality hasn't decreased.
Well obviously the overall quality has decreased, they rejected my kid! /s.
But the NMSF numbers, which never covered any significant portion of the student body, are fluctuating because of the changing cut score, not the presence or absence of an entrance exam. And the cut score went up because of whatever’s happening in New Jersey and Massachusetts, which really has nothing to do with DC at all.
Anonymous
09/16/2025 08:08
Subject: Re:NMSFs in DC 2026
Walls PARCC/CAPE scores:
2018-19 /exam/84.1% (4+ math)/93.4% (4+ ELA)
2023-24/no exam/67.8% (4+ math)/97% (4+ ELA)
ELA seems about the same but math is definitely lower.
There are no decent public options to Walls in DC (other than BASIS DC, which you can't get into after 5th grade) and it only cherry picks A students, so the fact that Walls has some NMS/top students doesn't necessarily mean that the overall school quality hasn't decreased.
2018-19 /exam/84.1% (4+ math)/93.4% (4+ ELA)
2023-24/no exam/67.8% (4+ math)/97% (4+ ELA)
ELA seems about the same but math is definitely lower.
There are no decent public options to Walls in DC (other than BASIS DC, which you can't get into after 5th grade) and it only cherry picks A students, so the fact that Walls has some NMS/top students doesn't necessarily mean that the overall school quality hasn't decreased.
Anonymous
09/16/2025 07:46
Subject: NMSFs in DC 2026
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:POST THE LIST!!’
Where can one find the list?
Who are the local education reporters in DC?
This is honestly so depressing. Lauren Lumpkin is supposed to cover education for the Post but she clearly doesn't really want to, and most of her articles more nationally hooked.
I can't find any other dedicated dc education reporters at any publication.
We are so screwed. Not bc of this particular small topic, but it's a canary in a coal mine -- there is NO media paying any attention to what's going on in DC schools. So all changing curriculum etc, will happen with no scrutiny.
Ok, i emailed the media contact for NMS and they responded really quickly! Hopefully they will offer something, and then maybe I'll send the list to.... Popville? the 51st?
Update, this is the response:
"It appears that the Catholic Standard, The Washington Times, and the Washington Post all received releases for your area. Those outlets may not yet have published the list, or may not publish unless someone first requests that they do so."
Isn't Lauren Lumpkin supposed to be covering local education issues for the Washington Post? You would think this at least warrants a small article (DMV semifinalists).
I just did a search on the WaPo app and the most recent list of semifinalists that I could find was published 11 years ago.
I don't think the Post is the right forum to publish it -- it just all made me realize that we have literally no local education reporting anywhere.
Anonymous
09/16/2025 06:55
Subject: NMSFs in DC 2026
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Only 3 NMSF at walls this year (compared with 6 last year)
How do you know this?
Walls sent an email out to school with the three names
That is really really depressing. This is exactly what I thought would happen when they made it easier to get in.
That is not what’s going on here. The reason Walls has fewer NMSFs this year is that the cut score rose.
Here is some historical data:
Class/admissions/cut score/NMSFs:
2026/no exam/225/3
2025/no exam/223/6
2024/exam/223/5
2023/exam/223/6
2022/exam/224/0
…
2018/exam/223/2
My high-scoring kid was excluded from Walls immediately after they dropped the exam, and I’m as bitter as anyone about it (why else do you think I was tracking this data?). But if you care about education you should care about facts and reason, and they show that raising the cut score has a much bigger effect on the number of NMSFs at Walls than whether or not Walls admits by exam.
Anonymous
09/16/2025 06:44
Subject: NMSFs in DC 2026
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Only 3 NMSF at walls this year (compared with 6 last year)
How do you know this?
Walls sent an email out to school with the three names
That is really really depressing. This is exactly what I thought would happen when they made it easier to get in.
Really really depressing? You don’t know anything about the school. Congrats to those three kids and send your kids elsewhere if this school makes you feel so depressed.
Anonymous
09/15/2025 23:44
Subject: NMSFs in DC 2026
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Only 3 NMSF at walls this year (compared with 6 last year)
How do you know this?
Walls sent an email out to school with the three names
That is really really depressing. This is exactly what I thought would happen when they made it easier to get in.
Anonymous
09/15/2025 23:40
Subject: NMSFs in DC 2026
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:POST THE LIST!!’
Where can one find the list?
Who are the local education reporters in DC?
This is honestly so depressing. Lauren Lumpkin is supposed to cover education for the Post but she clearly doesn't really want to, and most of her articles more nationally hooked.
I can't find any other dedicated dc education reporters at any publication.
We are so screwed. Not bc of this particular small topic, but it's a canary in a coal mine -- there is NO media paying any attention to what's going on in DC schools. So all changing curriculum etc, will happen with no scrutiny.
Ok, i emailed the media contact for NMS and they responded really quickly! Hopefully they will offer something, and then maybe I'll send the list to.... Popville? the 51st?
Update, this is the response:
"It appears that the Catholic Standard, The Washington Times, and the Washington Post all received releases for your area. Those outlets may not yet have published the list, or may not publish unless someone first requests that they do so."
Isn't Lauren Lumpkin supposed to be covering local education issues for the Washington Post? You would think this at least warrants a small article (DMV semifinalists).
I just did a search on the WaPo app and the most recent list of semifinalists that I could find was published 11 years ago.
Maybe the poster in contact with the national merit people can suggest they send the release to Jeff of DCUM, Prince of Petworth and the DC Patch. I'm not sure why the Catholic Standard gets the press release, when no one has ever heard of it.
Um, Catholics have heard of it.
It's not really the type of publication that covers local news for the general DC public. https://www.cathstan.org/
Wonderful--why don't you contact their education reporter then.
Anonymous
09/15/2025 23:37
Subject: NMSFs in DC 2026
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:POST THE LIST!!’
Where can one find the list?
Who are the local education reporters in DC?
This is honestly so depressing. Lauren Lumpkin is supposed to cover education for the Post but she clearly doesn't really want to, and most of her articles more nationally hooked.
I can't find any other dedicated dc education reporters at any publication.
We are so screwed. Not bc of this particular small topic, but it's a canary in a coal mine -- there is NO media paying any attention to what's going on in DC schools. So all changing curriculum etc, will happen with no scrutiny.
Ok, i emailed the media contact for NMS and they responded really quickly! Hopefully they will offer something, and then maybe I'll send the list to.... Popville? the 51st?
Update, this is the response:
"It appears that the Catholic Standard, The Washington Times, and the Washington Post all received releases for your area. Those outlets may not yet have published the list, or may not publish unless someone first requests that they do so."
Isn't Lauren Lumpkin supposed to be covering local education issues for the Washington Post? You would think this at least warrants a small article (DMV semifinalists).
I just did a search on the WaPo app and the most recent list of semifinalists that I could find was published 11 years ago.
Maybe the poster in contact with the national merit people can suggest they send the release to Jeff of DCUM, Prince of Petworth and the DC Patch. I'm not sure why the Catholic Standard gets the press release, when no one has ever heard of it.
Um, Catholics have heard of it.
Wonderful--why don't you contact their education reporter then.
Anonymous
09/15/2025 23:35
Subject: NMSFs in DC 2026
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:POST THE LIST!!’
Where can one find the list?
Who are the local education reporters in DC?
This is honestly so depressing. Lauren Lumpkin is supposed to cover education for the Post but she clearly doesn't really want to, and most of her articles more nationally hooked.
I can't find any other dedicated dc education reporters at any publication.
We are so screwed. Not bc of this particular small topic, but it's a canary in a coal mine -- there is NO media paying any attention to what's going on in DC schools. So all changing curriculum etc, will happen with no scrutiny.
Ok, i emailed the media contact for NMS and they responded really quickly! Hopefully they will offer something, and then maybe I'll send the list to.... Popville? the 51st?
Update, this is the response:
"It appears that the Catholic Standard, The Washington Times, and the Washington Post all received releases for your area. Those outlets may not yet have published the list, or may not publish unless someone first requests that they do so."
Isn't Lauren Lumpkin supposed to be covering local education issues for the Washington Post? You would think this at least warrants a small article (DMV semifinalists).
I just did a search on the WaPo app and the most recent list of semifinalists that I could find was published 11 years ago.
Maybe the poster in contact with the national merit people can suggest they send the release to Jeff of DCUM, Prince of Petworth and the DC Patch. I'm not sure why the Catholic Standard gets the press release, when no one has ever heard of it.
Um, Catholics have heard of it.
Anonymous
09/15/2025 23:22
Subject: NMSFs in DC 2026
Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:Anonymous wrote:POST THE LIST!!’
Where can one find the list?
Who are the local education reporters in DC?
This is honestly so depressing. Lauren Lumpkin is supposed to cover education for the Post but she clearly doesn't really want to, and most of her articles more nationally hooked.
I can't find any other dedicated dc education reporters at any publication.
We are so screwed. Not bc of this particular small topic, but it's a canary in a coal mine -- there is NO media paying any attention to what's going on in DC schools. So all changing curriculum etc, will happen with no scrutiny.
Ok, i emailed the media contact for NMS and they responded really quickly! Hopefully they will offer something, and then maybe I'll send the list to.... Popville? the 51st?
Update, this is the response:
"It appears that the Catholic Standard, The Washington Times, and the Washington Post all received releases for your area. Those outlets may not yet have published the list, or may not publish unless someone first requests that they do so."
Isn't Lauren Lumpkin supposed to be covering local education issues for the Washington Post? You would think this at least warrants a small article (DMV semifinalists).
I just did a search on the WaPo app and the most recent list of semifinalists that I could find was published 11 years ago.
Maybe the poster in contact with the national merit people can suggest they send the release to Jeff of DCUM, Prince of Petworth and the DC Patch. I'm not sure why the Catholic Standard gets the press release, when no one has ever heard of it.