Anonymous wrote:My phone in my back pocket ripped up the drivers seat eventually so I was even more glad it was just the cover.
You...put your $1,000 phone in your back pocket and then sit on your phone, risking destruction of your pants, your phone, and your seat cover?

And this isn't a one-time mistake but a regular way of sitting? Cars these days have places to rest your phone.
Oh, and to OP, I vote leather. In addition to being easier to clean, the leather option in most cars also correlates with a higher-quality seat that is more comfortable on long drives. So the upcharge you're paying isn't usually just for the leather; it's for the leather and the higher quality cushioning materials and shape of the seat.
Note that many brands now offer synthetic/imitation leather instead of cloth. For instance, many Lexus vehicles offer NuLuxe seats and Toyota vehicles offer SofTex seats. Real leather seats are only on the top-tier trims of these brands' vehicles. These newer seat fabrics are easy to clean like real leather and are much more comfortable and attractive than the "pleather" of the 80s and 90s.