I have a 1 ct that I think looks really big on my hand. But I have the greedies sometimes and the bigger ones look so tempting.

But, what do you (or your GF?) like? Personal prefernce.

Yes. Aren’t diamonds on the way out now, with the man made ones becoming more popular? And with COVID hand washing. I see either no rings at all or just plain bands. I don’t think diamonds are coming back.
Like high heeled pumps.

FWIW I went with a smaller diamond with blue sapphires on each side and I get nothing but rave reviews.

I think it depends on the woman.

I wouldn't go any bigger. But some women have huge hands and need bigger rings to balance it. I have 1.5 and like it, but could do a 2ct (I mean, if you forced me )

Minimum

What about 1.5 carats?

way too big

totally depends on the hand size. I have slightly under 2 and it looks fine (albeit a bit on the bigger size, which I had to get used to), but when my sister tries it on it looks gauche and really not good. she's petite and I'm not

I think it is too big unless she is a large woman with large hands- then it would be a good size

For me it would be way too big but for a few people, the bigger the better.

Depends on a lot of factors. I would not like or regularly wear a ring that big, but plenty of women love them. It's also worth considering her hand size - if her ring is a size 5 or something it's going to look even bigger against her hand than if she wears an 8.

I think it's too big.

I think it’s personal preference and what you are happy wearing. I wouldn’t worry about all the judgment you will get on here.

As the title says. Is it too big or just the right size?