All serious independent historians acknowledge beef eating at the time of the earliest Veda. The fact that there has been a serious effort by Hindu nationalist historians to discredit this is interesting from the perspective of modern Indian politics, but it does not change the scholarly consensus.

Anonymous wrote:It can’t be Hinduism. Africa is the birthplace of civilization. India was not populated too much later.

Is religion a requirement for civilization?

Anonymous wrote:I am not sure it is a question that can be answered.

We have religions of the book, where we can give a reasonably clear idea of when they came about, like Christianity, Islam etc.

Hinduism is clearly very old. But it has also changed a lot. The earliest Vedic scrptures point to widespread eating of beef, for example.

Then we have hundreds of traditional religions in Africa, Australasia, Asia, and the Americas. How much continuity is there with their practices from 5,000 years ago? We really don’t know. All religions and belief systems evolve over time, particularly where there is no written tradition to maintain some degree of continuity. So the question is really unanswerable.

Two things

The articles about Veda and beef are not accurate. They are purposely wrongly transliterated Sanskrit from groups that benefit from invalidating cow reverence. These groups include from the earliest, British colonizers needing to civilize the heathens, modern day organized proselytizing religions, the Naxalite party, and the very lucrative meat industry.

The excavation site of Neolithic site, Mehrgarh, has found evidence of Shakti temple and worship nearly identical to current temple use of a Shakti symbols and worship.

Hinduism is Sanatana Dharma which literally means Eternal Path.

Yes, there could absolutely be possible that other ancient civilizations had rituals and beliefs. Most are Pagan based just like Hinduism. Unfortunately, most also have been wiped out by the major proselytizing religions. There is a very concerted global effort to do the same with Hinduism.

Anonymous wrote:Hinduism.

+1

Hinduism.

Anonymous wrote:It can’t be Hinduism. Africa is the birthplace of civilization. India was not populated too much later.

I can’t be Hinduism? So the scholars who say it is are wrong? Glad they have you. Phew.

Zoroastrianism May be older than Hinduism

It can’t be Hinduism. Africa is the birthplace of civilization. India was not populated too much later.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:https://www.aboriginal-art-australia.com/aboriginal-art-library/aboriginal-dreamtime/#:~:text=Dreamtime%20is%20the%20foundation%20of,world%20as%20they%20knew%20it.

No. It’s Hinduism.

OP, this isn’t something up for debate. There’s a scholarly consensus.

Weird that you provided a link that says "Many scholars" which would imply that it isn't consensus.

It is hard to compare a religion like Hinduism with a written tradition, with one without, but there are evidence that stories from Australia about the Dreamtime have been told over a longer period of time.

I am not sure it is a question that can be answered.

We have religions of the book, where we can give a reasonably clear idea of when they came about, like Christianity, Islam etc.

Hinduism is clearly very old. But it has also changed a lot. The earliest Vedic scrptures point to widespread eating of beef, for example.

Then we have hundreds of traditional religions in Africa, Australasia, Asia, and the Americas. How much continuity is there with their practices from 5,000 years ago? We really don’t know. All religions and belief systems evolve over time, particularly where there is no written tradition to maintain some degree of continuity. So the question is really unanswerable.

Anonymous wrote:https://www.aboriginal-art-australia.com/aboriginal-art-library/aboriginal-dreamtime/#:~:text=Dreamtime%20is%20the%20foundation%20of,world%20as%20they%20knew%20it.

No. It’s Hinduism.

OP, this isn’t something up for debate. There’s a scholarly consensus.

Anonymous wrote:Let’s Debate.

Who wants to debate something that can be answered by actually reading?

LMFGTFY: https://www.history.com/topics/religion/hinduism

Let’s Debate.