My short answer is that there's no need to buy multiple index funds, unless you want separate stock vs. bond funds, or REIT funds, or tax-managed funds. Index funds are, by definition, already spread out, so you'd likely be buying different buckets of the same things.
Anyway, your question is a good one, but it suggests that you would really benefit from taking a couple of days and, along with your spouse, if applicable, reading the entire J.L. Collins Stock Series. Read ALL of it. Then you'll better understand what to do:
http://jlcollinsnh.com/stock-series/