I have a very similar rug to the 2nd and love it. It is not too busy especially with a coffee table to break it up.
OP I got mine from rugsusa- much cheaper and virtually identical.
I've had many PB rugs and the quality is on-par IMO:

http://www.rugsusa.com/rugsusa/clearancerugs/rugs-usa-trellis-vs72/navy/200MTVS72A-508.html?product_open=true

I paid $199 for the 8x10 a few weeks ago and it is $159 today (price goes up and down also daily between to two).

The second one trips my hyperactivity, so even though I don't like the first one, if those were my only two choices on earth I'd pick the first.

Honestly, not a fan of either, but prefer the first one. If it were me, I'd want to interject more lively colors into the room.

I like the second one better. Just go for it!

I like the first one. The second is very busy and would look good with the colors you have going.

We've got beige walls and a beige couch, white curtains. It's for a family room. I have blue and white striped pillows but I can change those. Slightly worried the second one might show more dirt but kind of like it more (but not sure if it's too bold).

http://www.potterybarn.com/products/knot-tufted-rug-blue/?pkey=call-rugs&&call-rugs

http://www.potterybarn.com/products/scroll-tile-rug-indigo/?pkey=call-rugs&&call-rugs