Not sure if I can compare/contrast. We do Ticonderoga at Christmas and Pumpkinville at Halloween. Pumpkinville has more animals, a zip line and camel rides which I don't think you can get hardly anywhere. Be prepared to have cash for camel ride and zip line. It seems like there is more to do at Pumpkinville, but you can compare the websites. I am sure they list all the stuff at each one.