I got my Fenugreek at CVS. Other things I tried (not sure what worked or if it was a certain combination of things or if it just took time but BF eventually did work for me when it didnt look like it was going to in the beginning): oatmeal (yes, you can try the cookies or other recipes that use oatmeal if you don't like to eat it in mush form), mother's milk tea (bought at Safeway in the natural foods section), heating pads, dark beer. But, also consider this:
http://kellymom.com/bf/can-i-breastfeed/herbs/herbal_galactagogue/ (info recommending against worrying about taking galactagogues). Anyway, that's what I did. and i took 9 capsules of fenugreek a day.