I'm the OP of the 3-4 nights thread. DH wants to Caribbean but with a non-chaotic airport. I've heard St. Croix is good. St. Martin and Turks were just ok. We are okay with 1 connection - probably Charlotte or Atlanta because we are actually flying out of Richmond, where the grandparents/babysitters are.
How about Grand Cayman or St. Thomas (to get us to St. John.)? Any others?