Experiences. Do you go to the theater? Take them. Skiing, hiking, museums, whatever you like Explore their interests and yours together as they get older.
when i was the single aunt to brothers young kids, i always took them out, even just outside to kick a ball around. Swimming, shopping, coffee shops, zoo, etc. Then i would bring them home for dinner, bathe them and leave them tired out and happy. Sil was happy to have some time alone, knowing her kids were entertained and happy. i loved being with them and we still have a strong relatio ship, they are in college now and two of my favorite people on the planet. Got mothers day wishes from them both.
my sil does nice things for my 3 daughters. She insists on taking them each to nordstroms for theur first real bra fitting.