OP here. I purchased the designer living I. Seafoam and they are beautiful and comfy. Thanks for your help!

I like the Designer Living one the best and regarding a PP's suggestion, World Market chairs are not comfortable at all.

Would not do Home Depot. It's not just that it is gray like your couch perhaps spreading the gray too much, but the grays may not really go together when you put them side by side.

I like the Designer Living one best--not in love with the brown with gray combination you'd get with Overstock, which IMO is a bit drab.

Thanks everyone - very helpful!

OP have you looked at World Market? Tons of fun chairs! Some are neutrals, some are super fun colors. They're all around $100-250 so right in your price range.

I like the last one as a change to the gray sofa. Also prefer the two with arms as I think the armless one looks less comfortable (like an option you would choose when you really don't have the space).

I like the designer living chair

I want that designer living chair in red for my kid's bedroom. For a LR. I like the Home Depot one best.

I personally like the armless one best.

But a question - why not buy a chair that is a pop of color? In my house I have a dark chocolate leather couch and ottoman paired with a teal blue chair, and pillows/curtains that bring in patterns with variety of shades along with the blue that tie it all together including yellows, oranges, and greens. The walls are neutral. The chair is a nice centerpiece. Gray and gray might look too monochrome, don't you think?

I like designer living or home depot the most. The overstock chair is more of a chair for a small space since it has no arms. I really like the designer living color, would go well with gray.

Chairs will be paired with a light gray couch. Room color is neutral and will have pops of color with cushions, maps, etc.

http://www.overstock.com/Home-Garden/Armless-Tufted-Chair-Steel/4359787/product.html?searchidx=1

http://www.homedepot.com/p/Worldwide-Homefurnishings-Fabric-Arm-Chair-in-Grey-403-840/205674414?cm_mmc=Shopping%7cG%7cBase%7cPLA%7cD59%7cDecor&gclid=CMiJl_aXhsUCFUo7gQodmkcAQA&gclsrc=aw.ds

http://www.designerliving.com/Product/chairs/madison-park-oxford-chair/31141 (in seafoam color)

I'm leaning toward the overstock and the designer living one. The overstock chairs is a knock off of Room&Board Delia and the Designer living a knockoff of Room&Board Quinn. I really like the one from Home Depot (which is also available on Overstock) but worry it will be too much of the same shade of gray.

I'm terrible at making decisions.