Lots of possibilities. I'd pick a country and vrbo. Don't forget that it's not just for islands-- we've rented in Mexico, Panama, and Costa Rica as well as USVI and French West Indies.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The viceroy anguilla has houses. We visited there and loved it. Anguilla is so much nicer than the other islands.

Friends of mine were robbed when staying at a private house in Anguilla. It was an inside job, and the police didn't care at all. They were in the house when my friend was sleeping. Very scary.

Viceroy is a hotel so partially mitigates some of the issue. Np here.

BVI

You might want to look at the Bahamas or Turks and Caicos. Those are relatively flat islands and you are more likely to find something right on the water. The islands that are more mountainous and hilly won't have many houses right on the water - they will be up the hill with great views but you will need a car or have a longish walk to the beaches.

Anonymous wrote:The viceroy anguilla has houses. We visited there and loved it. Anguilla is so much nicer than the other islands.

Friends of mine were robbed when staying at a private house in Anguilla. It was an inside job, and the police didn't care at all. They were in the house when my friend was sleeping. Very scary.

Mustique

The viceroy anguilla has houses. We visited there and loved it. Anguilla is so much nicer than the other islands.

Maybe try El Salvador

OP here. Open to any beautiful island.

At least 4 bedrooms. Directly on the beach and hopefully with a pool. Any ideas?