Anonymous wrote:plus one on gruber

If you're trying to stay in a special education private school, pus two on Brian Gruber for helping figure out options and being realistic about outcomes when DC Public Schools fights parent placement. Even if you don't win, at least you know what you're up against with DCPS.

Bear in mind that the District is a small town when it comes to private schools. Special education is an even smaller circle. If you're trying to get into a different private school in the metro area, you might want to avoid lawyering up at this stage. Your current school might help get you into a different private school with a better "fit" for your child.

Hope things work out for your family.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:There are no special education rights in Private school, the laws only apply to public schools.

I think this answer is not quite right -- the federal IDEA law and it's idea of "free and appropriate public education" may not apply to private schools, but private schools still must comply with federal disability law like the Americans with Disabilities Act and probably Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act may apply as well if the private school receives federal funds directly or indirectly for any reason.

ADA does not apply to private religious schools, I believe.

No, 504s and IEPs need not be honoredby private schools.

And you could be asked to leave along the lines of "we don't have the resources necessary to support your child."

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:There are no special education rights in Private school, the laws only apply to public schools.

I think this answer is not quite right -- the federal IDEA law and it's idea of "free and appropriate public education" may not apply to private schools, but private schools still must comply with federal disability law like the Americans with Disabilities Act and probably Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act may apply as well if the private school receives federal funds directly or indirectly for any reason.

ADA does not apply to private religious schools, I believe.

No, 504s and IEPs need not be honoredby private schools.

Yes, you are correct that a private school does not have to create a 504 plan or an IEP, but that is not the same as saying that they are not subject to Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act or the ADA. For example, under the ADA, a private school would still have to make reasonable accommodations for ... a child in a wheelchair.... a child who needs to have time out of class to manage medications (like diabetes, e.g.)... has a concussion and needs time off school and a makeup work plan commensurate with medical advice. The way they do this doesn't have to be by the 504 or IEP process that we see public schools use, but it doesn't mean that they can refuse to accommodate entirely either just because they are "private". What exactly is "reasonable" is determined by statute and case law.

Saying private schools are "not subject to special education rights" is a bit simplistic and not quite right. "Special education rights" stem from 3 federal laws (plus any applicable state laws which may provide some enhanced rights) -- IDEA, Section 504 of the Rehab Act and the ADA. "Special education rights" stem from the notion that a person has a "disability," the definition of which varies somewhat under these 3 laws. Each different law provides different protections and processes, sometimes overlapping. If your child has a "disability" as defined under Section 504 or the ADA, a private school may still have to provide some kind of accommodation for the disability.

OP, please do see an attorney who can offer you better advice based on the individual facts of your child's needs and the exact type of private school you are in.

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:There are no special education rights in Private school, the laws only apply to public schools.

I think this answer is not quite right -- the federal IDEA law and it's idea of "free and appropriate public education" may not apply to private schools, but private schools still must comply with federal disability law like the Americans with Disabilities Act and probably Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act may apply as well if the private school receives federal funds directly or indirectly for any reason.

ADA does not apply to private religious schools, I believe.

No, 504s and IEPs need not be honoredby private schools.

Anonymous wrote:There are no special education rights in Private school, the laws only apply to public schools.

I think this answer is not quite right -- the federal IDEA law and it's idea of "free and appropriate public education" may not apply to private schools, but private schools still must comply with federal disability law like the Americans with Disabilities Act and probably Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act may apply as well if the private school receives federal funds directly or indirectly for any reason.

ADA does not apply to private religious schools, I believe.

plus one on gruber

We've had experience with Brian Gruber and Michael Eig. Both take DC and Montgomery co cases and some Va cases.
Loved Gruber!

Anonymous wrote:Michael Eig has an excellent reputation. I was going to use him but we live in VA. He's in DC.

I'm in VA too. Who did you end up using? Would you recommend him/her?

Anonymous wrote:Michael Eig has an excellent reputation. I was going to use him but we live in VA. He's in DC.

His office is in Friendship Heights, on the MD side, but the location doesn't determine where he operates, where he or his associates has a bar license does. He definitely takes cases in MD and DC, I'm not sure about VA, but would be surprised if he or someone in his firm doesn't take cases in VA.

Michael Eig has an excellent reputation. I was going to use him but we live in VA. He's in DC.

I'm guessing that OP meant that she wants an attorney adept in DC education law and private school placement.

OP - I just asked this question last month. search on MCPS Due Process.

Anonymous wrote:There are no special education rights in Private school, the laws only apply to public schools.

I agree. It's best to move on if it's not a good fit.

There are no special education rights in Private school, the laws only apply to public schools.

Try Michael Eig.

Do attorneys specialize in education? Special education rights? I need a recommendation for attorney to deal with a private elementary school in DC.
TIA