Cute jewelry, maybe a festive earring and necklace set.

Yes to above, CD for Maroon 5 or Taylor Swift
A set of colored pencils
duck tape
Justice stuff

phone case. scarf.

Nail polish, make up bag filled with candy, cute hat or scarf( can get for $10 at forever 21 or Claire's, earrings, leg Warmers to wear w tall boots, Starbucks gift card , journal, funny joke book, calandar, fun tights

Go to Five Below and let your imagination go wild.

My sixth grade almost 12 yr old likes bath body works stuff, nail polish, Ariana grande, Japanese erasers, etc.

Do you know her, OP? Or is this a random person?

All good ideas. Depending on her personality, nail polish and smelly hand lotion. I loved all the stuff at Bath and Body Works when I was a kid and Target often has cheap nail polish.

Knetic Sand -

Nail kit with fun holiday colors

pretty journal & pen, cool pair of socks, ear buds, water bottle,

crazy aaron’s putty:
http://www.puttyworld.com

or other fidget

Must be $10 or under. Would prefer an item but will probably go with a $10 iTunes card if imagination fails. TIA.