I like the second in the mocha stain. But I agree that both are a bit trendy.

First

Neither.

They both will look incredibly dated in just a few years.

First one is gorgeous.

First one looks very Ikea at an Ethan Allen price.

The second one. I don't care for the first one.

First one

Anonymous wrote:We have the first one - it does hold a lot. The dark drawer pulls will look nice with the bed.

PP, did you get the nightstand as well? We don't have nightstands and really need them - our bed from floor to top of mattress is 29" so the nightstands from the berkeley line are much shorter…

Also, if you got the nightstands did you get two matching ones? Didn't it get to match match?

We have the first one - it does hold a lot. The dark drawer pulls will look nice with the bed.

Both are beautiful but the first one is pretty special and my favorite. Of course, I'd have trouble digesting the price of either one but I can dream.

First one. My sister has the second one and in person it is nice too

Neither. I think all of them are unattractive, and I prefer the first dresser looks wise. But I think the second one matches the bed better.

I like the first one!

The first one looks like it holds more but I like the looks of the second one better.

http://www.roomandboard.com/catalog/bedroom/dressers/berkeley-dressers

http://www.roomandboard.com/catalog/bedroom/dressers/bennett-dressers

To go with a bed similar to this one: http://www.roomandboard.com/catalog/bedroom/beds/mackintosh-high-footboard-beds