Anonymous wrote:My ILs do this type of thing, especially to cover up things they are insecure/embarrassed about, particularly with respect to my SIL. For example, SIL is almost 40 and not married. She has a great job, lots of friends, etc., but MIL/FIL gloss over that and talk about the fiancé she tragically lost to illness in her 20s. The "fiancé" was a guy she dated semi-seriously got 6-8 months before he got leukemia. It is possible he might've been "the one" but there was never any engagement to speak of. I feel so badly for SIL that they keep rehashing that old experience instead of focusing on her many accomplishments.
I have no real solutions. I have called out MIL when she's done similar things to DH and she just denies, denies, denies. I think she really believes the stories she has fabricated. She doesn't exactly ask us to collude with her, she just tells us we are wrong if we correct her. So I have stopped trying - it's not worth the argument. DH will still sometimes fight it. FIL is her co-conspirator by virtue of his silence.
Yes, my parents also seem to believe their lies. It's like they think I am trying to sabotage them by making up things. By the end of a conversation with them I start to question whether I have made up DD's learning disability and if maybe I somehow held back my son by not prepping him for gifted program tests. I made him average.
I have an unmarried brother-many girlfriends over the years and one actual engagement. He is an actual over-achiever (Harvard, Yale and Cornell degrees) and I think his perfectionism made him unable to settle down. He has been with his current girlfriend for 8 years. My parents brag about all his accomplishments and while behind the scenes they push him to settle down, in public they just say it's hard for him to find someone good enough for him.
I also have a sister who was academically average and low and behold she still went to college, got a job she loved and got married and had kids. The world didn't come crashing down, but my parents just didn't mention her when they bragged about us because she got labelled the average one. Pretty disgusting. My sister doesn't visit much, but when she does she just rolls her eyes and plays along.