Anonymous wrote:Why is it ok to prep for AAP and SAT but not for TJ? Double standard?
IMO, the TJ and Blair tests are mostly IQ tests (in Blair's case, the Pearson company makes the test) whereas the SAT is mostly what you know (vocab, grammar, geometry) with a dash of IQ-related stuff. I say this as a NMSSF with a kid in a magnet.
I don't have a problem with kids learning *more* vocab and *more* geometry to do well on the SATs because, heck, now they'll have larger vocabularies for life. But TJ test prep means you're basically faking a higher IQ than you will ever have, because IQ tests do rely on a limited number of problems that can be taught.
Also, if your kid can get in the 80th-90th pctile on the SATs, s/he can probably compete well against most kids in her future college. But TJ and Blair take the top 1-2% by IQ, and that might put your kid at a huge disadvantage or even discourage some kids.