DS got the toughest English teacher at his HS for freshmen English and got a C in an Honors class, and a C in one other class. He got all As and Bs as a sophomore and is on track to do the same as a junior, taking mostly Honors and AP classes.
Question - any idea whether most schools discount freshmen-year grades or simply look at the aggregate GPA? How much does trajectory and taking a progressively more challenging course load count?