Anonymous wrote:Have a 900K house in a hot neighborhood with a old basement 3/4 bath - would not redo it for resale. Maybe some fresh paint and caulking.

This - plus a new pretty shower curtain & liner, and new knobs on the vanity door. Draw attention away from the age of the shower stall itself.

Have a 900K house in a hot neighborhood with a old basement 3/4 bath - would not redo it for resale. Maybe some fresh paint and caulking.

Anonymous wrote:No way would I spend money upgrading it as long as it's clean and in good condition. As a buyer, I was not particular about basement bathrooms.

+1

I would only redo it if for some reason it would cause someone to walk into your house and turn away and walk right out. Which doesn't sound like the case since you have two other functioning bathrooms, and presumably that gets little use anyway

The main selling point is plumbed for basement bathroom , even better if something is there already

No way would I spend money upgrading it as long as it's clean and in good condition. As a buyer, I was not particular about basement bathrooms.

I guarantee that there will be more work after you take it down.

We bought a house with that exact type of shower and were thrilled to redo it year down the road.

What's funny is that acrylic shower is builders grade in most areas but in dc we think home depot is.

... And the main floors of the house -- including kitchen and two upper level bathrooms -- are in top notch conditions, fwiw.

Thanks. The shower stall is relatively clean and there isn't anything wrong with it. But it's one of those utilitarian very basic stalls that you would use temporarily while your bathroom is being renovated. It looks something like the picture below, but it looks old now.

I would and I'd search myself for the most appealing "builders grade" tile so it looked above grade. Pretty amazing what's out there now a days.

But that's only if no more glaring defect is present warranting attention.

Is it old-fashioned or does it actually have holes/significant rust/ mold etc? If it has really gross problems, replace it. I see something like that in a house, I assume the rest of the house is gross and not kept up. I will either walk or plan to seriously underbid because I figure there are a ton of things wrong with the house I have to budget fixes for.

If its okay, at least re-caulk.

Anonymous wrote:no

Thanks. Anyone else?

OP here. The house would probably sell for $875k+ .

no

If a very good looking house in a relatively hot market has two baths in great condition and a basement bath in meh condition, mainly because of a very ugly shower stall, would you spend $2k to demo and redo the basement shower, mainly for resale (as it's not used much) -- new one would look much better but would still look "builder grade."