Anonymous wrote:OP here. Thanks for all the responses, especially 21:38, exactly the kind of snapshots I was looking for.
St. John's would be about the worst fit I can imagine. She is struggling through Macbeth right now. I'm not sure she could get into St. Mary's, but maybe.
Looks like Stevenson and McDaniel may be the best Maryland bets. I'll check out the other ones as well. There are a couple other schools I've heard are good for LDs in West Virginia, Marshall (but it's about 400 miles away) and Davis and Elkins (perhaps too small with just 700 students).
For LDs-aware colleges in WV, West Virginia Wesleyan College would be better than either Marshall or Davis and Elkins. They are known for their Center for Learning Disabilities, provide a lot of individual and group tutoring, accommodations to take tests with extended time, etc (I used to do both individual and group tutoring there). If LDs are your concern, WVWC would be a good choice.