We've been really really happy there, with a younger child and a middle schooler. Like every school not everything is perfect, but neither are we!
Teacher, peers, arts/music/environment really are strong. I don't know how innovative the math/science is as I don't have a huge amount to compare. A dedicated lower school science teacher a few years back made a very positive difference. There's a few new hires for this year but they look to be really strong - and the couple of people hired in the last few years have turned out great.
There's always stuff, but the kids and the teachers really do make an effort for everyone to get along, which I didn't think was that unusual, but apparently it is, especially in this county. I think especially for middle school where most people are really unhappy with their choices, this is a good place.
For kids who need a huge amount of acceleration or a lot of remediation, it's probably not the best choice - you would probably not be satisfied. They can handle a little bit to either end, just not a huge amount. It is a wonderful community.
We're a very secular family and find quaker values very compatible with our values. I appreciate the emphasis on finding the common ground between people.