Randolphs in Arlington. It's expensive, but it's delicious!! I had one for my kids 1st communion and everyone raved about how good the cake was. some people had seconds which I don't see very often.

Harris Teeter of those three.

Giant has the worst cakes....don't do it

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Wegmans. Ask for the whipped cream topping. It's light and not too sweet.

Oh I think the whipped topping is so nasty! it's by far my least favorite of the store cakes.

bleck. That whipped "cream" topping is the worst.

Giant. I've gotten a Giant cake for every one of DD's 9 birthday parties, and everyone loves it. Everybody gobbled up the last one before I even got a piece. Clean plates at the end!

Anonymous wrote:OP here. Thanks, PPs! I assume the Wegmans needs to be kept in fridge?

You can keep it in the fridge, but take it out a couple of hours before you serve it to allow it to come to room temp.

Haven't tried the Wegman's. Like Costco better than G, S, or HT.

Safeway (vanilla/vanilla or chocolate fudge.)

Anonymous wrote:Wegmans. Ask for the whipped cream topping. It's light and not too sweet.

Oh I think the whipped topping is so nasty! it's by far my least favorite of the store cakes.

Wegmann's!

Giant. It was delicious.

OP here. Thanks, PPs! I assume the Wegmans needs to be kept in fridge?

Wegmans. Ask for the whipped cream topping. It's light and not too sweet.

costco

Who makes the best sheet cake - Safeway, Giant or Harris Teeter?