what about New Hope Academy? While they don't teach theology, they don't shy away from religion/prayer and they are very inclusive. We've had our kids here for 3y and have been extremely happy. It is a small school where we know all of the other parents, the teachers, and administration and they know my kids/us. We've found academics to be on par with their peers at both private and public schools and my kids standardized testing always comes back in the 90th+ percentile. I think it is worth checking out/taking a tour.