For me, well loved means a few different things rolled into one. It means that you won't go in and find builder white walls, standard fixtures and builder grade everything. It means that they spent time in the property, made changes, and used the place. As a consequence, the property is likely to be slightly more worn and any updates you should be careful to have reviewed and inspected because many times those updates were DIY projects by the homeowners and may or may not be done well. Also most items in the house are likely to be older and not updated as recently. Changed, yes. Recently, no (or the realtor would have listed things like "new flooring", "updated kitchen", etc). Good and bad to it. Some of the things that I've seen in properties that are "well loved" include built-ins, custom designed spaces (especially for awkward areas), DIY'ed bathroom repairs, rooms that are functionally used for something other than what they were originally designed for, unusual wall color choices and unusual storage spaces.