If you're talking about for work, maybe something like these with slacks? Clarks are supposed to be pretty comfortable.
http://www.clarksusa.com/eng/product/decade_capri/62267

Or even these if you can handle the heel (I couldn't):
http://www.clarksusa.com/eng/product/heath_merlin/63092

I wear these with jeans constantly and get tons of compliments on them, but they seem to be out of stock in most sizes.
http://www.shoestation.com/big-buddha-willo-brown/pampiakmmdlfdikn/product

For comfort, some brands to focus on would be Aerosoles, Clarks, and Easy Spirit. But they've got some duds too, so report back before you buy!

These are what we used to call "birth control shoes" in college. E.g. shoes that would guarantee that a guy wouldn't come near enough to the girl to get her pregnant.

Anonymous wrote:They're both ugly. The second ones look like something the vicar would be wearing in some stuffy Masterpiece Theatre story set in the 1840s.

HAHA OP here, that's definitely not the look I'm going for. i'm actually fairly conservative when it comes to clothes (mostly because i suck at putting stuff together so I stick to the essentials).

They're both ugly. The second ones look like something the vicar would be wearing in some stuffy Masterpiece Theatre story set in the 1840s.

Anonymous wrote:I think these aren't the most attractive, but tell us what you'd be wearing them with, and I'll do some shopping. (Nothing to do at work today. )

What would YOU wear with them? I have no idea where to even begin.

Thanks all. That's why I asked so I don't mind the honest opinion. I'm not the most fashionable by any means so I need help. I have no idea what I would be wearing with them. My preference would be slacks. Another problem is that I have really short hair so if I wear these shoes and slacks with a button up shirt I might end up looking very non-feminine. HELP!!!!

I think these aren't the most attractive, but tell us what you'd be wearing them with, and I'll do some shopping. (Nothing to do at work today. )

I'm so sorry, but I do not care for either one.

Yikes!

You asked, so I'll be honest. UGLY

UGG- LY

Sorry, but that's my opinion anyway.

Sorry, they are both ugly.

The second ones look interesting/funky. I think the naots are ugly, personally.

http://www.zappos.com/naot-footwear-pleasure-black-midnight-leather?channel=135&mr:referralID=a432329e-5692-11e2-b779-001b2166c62d

http://www.zappos.com/think-89146-chianti-kombi?channel=135&mr:referralID=c2498648-5692-11e2-b779-001b2166c62d

I desperately need something comfortable (bad knees) but I don't want to look frumpy.