I think you have a good amount of low-income and immigrant residents there, mixed with a lot of orthodox kids who go to the Yeshivah there. If your child is ahead of the curve, I would opt for Catholic school if you aren't jewish. I'm sorry if that sounds harsh or mean or whatever - just being honest and saying what I would do for my child. Hell, I would try to get my kid into the Yeshivah if that meant what was best for my child's education.