Claire

Emma and Claire are nice. The others are weird.

Emma - pretty but overdone
Claire - so ugly and stumpy (every girl named Claire gets called Claire Bear by their father)
Alice - just as ugly as Claire
Mackenzie - okay but a lil trashy
Cassidy - see Mackenzie

Alice was on my short list if my second was a girl. I think Emma and Claire are both nice enough but both ubiquitous. Cassidy is good and less common.

Mackenzie is bad.

1st 3 nice, classic

I like Alice.

Alice is wonderful. And she can vibe Ali if she wants to when she gets older. And then back to Alice again after that

No to Cassidy and McKenzie

Alice is my favorite, but I'm an old bore.

Wow, the first 3 on your list are a really different vibe from the last 2. Does one parent want more classic names and the other one more modern ones?

Cassidy is my favorite but I didn’t use it because I was afraid it wasn’t classic enough. Mackenzie is bad, the others are fine. Love Claire.

Alice

Claire and Alice are lovely.

The others are basic bi!ch.

Nice choices! Emma is probably the most common if that matters to you. Cassidy is my least favorite but can't really say why. Think of nns ..like are you ok with Kenzie or Emmy.

Thoughts on the following names? Having trouble deciding...
Emma
Claire
Alice
Mackenzie
Cassidy