Anonymous
Post 03/16/2026 05:58     Subject: Re:Best K-8 Schools?

A consultant told us she's never had a full pay family rejected from Speyer. They do this 2hr evaluation, but it's mainly for show.
Anonymous
Post 03/16/2026 00:25     Subject: Best K-8 Schools?

They go from 30 to 45 in 6th.

Gifted identification is a scam, and I say this as the parent of two kids frequently flagged as “gifted.”
Anonymous
Post 03/15/2026 23:16     Subject: Re:Best K-8 Schools?

1/3 of the class doesn't join in 6th. They take approx 30 in K. A few leave for Hunter after 6 and a few add. The amount of people who are so uncomfortable with a school for gifted kids is just funny. Gifted kids brains work differently. Not 2E. Giftedness on its own is a neurodiversity. They do a 2 hour assessment that's their own modified testing (that pulls from WPPSI, SB etc. From what I gather). Why are they great? They have a 6:1 student/teacher ratio. The kids take chess, debate, Spanish, dance, maker lab, and art in addition to the regular stuff as core classes. They have 0 ceiling to their differentiation so wherever kids go to they can accommodate. I hear some years they have 8th graders taking Calc. Their 7th graders trade real stocks. I know Kindergarten tackles the Odyssey....
They do a ton of SEL and Executive functioning stuff because the gifted kids need it. Highly recommend. Their exmissions are awesome because they are a good school.
Anonymous
Post 03/15/2026 22:41     Subject: Best K-8 Schools?

Anonymous wrote:Speyer has extremely impressive exmissions.


Yes but it’s a TON of testing schools; also like 1/3 of the class joins in 6th. So even by the standards of K-8 schools it’s highly debatable whether Speyer is actually doing anything for your kid or simply has a good admissions pool because people love to be told their kid is “gifted.”
Anonymous
Post 03/15/2026 20:02     Subject: Best K-8 Schools?

Speyer has extremely impressive exmissions.
Anonymous
Post 03/13/2026 23:58     Subject: Best K-8 Schools?

International School of Brooklyn in Carroll Gardens (although it’s a mess).
Anonymous
Post 03/13/2026 15:23     Subject: Best K-8 Schools?

Rodeph Sholom
Anonymous
Post 03/13/2026 14:17     Subject: Best K-8 Schools?

Should've also included the Epiphany School.
Anonymous
Post 03/13/2026 14:10     Subject: Best K-8 Schools?

Caedmon is K-5, Ecole has a HS program with Leman. Also, there is St. Ignatius Loyola School which is co-ed.
Anonymous
Post 03/13/2026 13:48     Subject: Re:Best K-8 Schools?

Pine Street School
Anonymous
Post 03/13/2026 13:46     Subject: Best K-8 Schools?

Cathedral and School at Columbia
Anonymous
Post 03/13/2026 11:47     Subject: Best K-8 Schools?

Anonymous wrote:Other options besides what PP provided are:
Brooklyn Heights Montessori
City & Country
Village Community School


Also Bank Street
Anonymous
Post 03/13/2026 11:47     Subject: Best K-8 Schools?

Other options besides what PP provided are:
Brooklyn Heights Montessori
City & Country
Village Community School
Anonymous
Post 03/13/2026 09:57     Subject: Best K-8 Schools?

Anonymous wrote:For a variety of reasons, I'm interested in having my child apply to K-8 private schools next year. Looking for a place that's nurturing while still remaining rigorous. Open to single sex girls school recommendations as well.


I do not believe there are any single sex girls schools that only go until 8th grade (someone can correct me if I am wrong). Many of the schools that are k-8 are single sex boys schools.

For co-ed there is:

Town
Caedmon
St. Hilda's & St. Hugh's
St. Lukes
Speyer
Ecole
The Studio School

I believe there may be more but that's off the top of my head.
Anonymous
Post 03/13/2026 08:09     Subject: Best K-8 Schools?

For a variety of reasons, I'm interested in having my child apply to K-8 private schools next year. Looking for a place that's nurturing while still remaining rigorous. Open to single sex girls school recommendations as well.