Anonymous
Post 02/08/2026 16:59     Subject: Pencil skirt
I still have my 20 year old JCrew lined pencil skirts.
Anonymous
Post 02/08/2026 11:12     Subject: Pencil skirt
Anonymous wrote:J Jill is a good source for knit skirts that wash well without losing color and shape. And with flattering seams.

Try there if the 9 West one doesn't work out.


Thanks!
Anonymous
Post 02/08/2026 09:22     Subject: Pencil skirt
Anonymous wrote:You'll attract a lot of attention from black men. If that's the goal, go for it.


🙄
Anonymous
Post 02/07/2026 23:20     Subject: Pencil skirt
Is it lined? I'll only wear pencil skirts if they're lined. Nordstrom Halogen used to have the best lined pencil skirts, but then they removed the lining and they're the worst.
Anonymous
Post 02/07/2026 22:46     Subject: Pencil skirt
J Jill is a good source for knit skirts that wash well without losing color and shape. And with flattering seams.

Try there if the 9 West one doesn't work out.
Anonymous
Post 02/07/2026 22:23     Subject: Pencil skirt
I love the style but I don't know about the stretchy material in the pic. I liked them fitted but in a more classic fabric.
Anonymous
Post 02/07/2026 21:50     Subject: Pencil skirt
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:This is fine, but I will tell you there is nothing like pencil skirts they used to have at J.Crew (second choice Banana Republic.) So flattering, comfortable, and last for years - still have mine. Pay a bit more and dry clean but I'd get them on sale and last forever.


Thanks. Though I am tempted to buy this one given the price.


Yes, but the JCrew ones are all over Poshmark for very cheap also! I bought a burgundy one last year for 20 bucks
Anonymous
Post 02/07/2026 21:24     Subject: Pencil skirt
Anonymous wrote:This is fine, but I will tell you there is nothing like pencil skirts they used to have at J.Crew (second choice Banana Republic.) So flattering, comfortable, and last for years - still have mine. Pay a bit more and dry clean but I'd get them on sale and last forever.


Thanks. Though I am tempted to buy this one given the price.
Anonymous
Post 02/07/2026 21:22     Subject: Pencil skirt
You'll attract a lot of attention from black men. If that's the goal, go for it.
Anonymous
Post 02/07/2026 21:21     Subject: Pencil skirt
This is fine, but I will tell you there is nothing like pencil skirts they used to have at J.Crew (second choice Banana Republic.) So flattering, comfortable, and last for years - still have mine. Pay a bit more and dry clean but I'd get them on sale and last forever.
Anonymous
Post 02/07/2026 21:18     Subject: Pencil skirt
Very boring.
Anonymous
Post 02/07/2026 21:18     Subject: Pencil skirt
Anonymous wrote:Please tell me they’re coming back in style! Are they? I love mine

I love them too.
Anonymous
Post 02/07/2026 21:16     Subject: Pencil skirt
Please tell me they’re coming back in style! Are they? I love mine
Anonymous
Post 02/07/2026 21:15     Subject: Pencil skirt
https://www.kohls.com/product/prd-5069717/womens-nine-west-pull-on-ponte-pencil-skirt.jsp

What do you think of this pencil skirt? I'm in my mid 30s, 5'5", 165, bottom heavy.