Neither

I require a bag to close securely with a zipper.

Anonymous wrote:I've been looking for a new bag but I hate all three.

+1. Too big and bulky

The first one looks so awkward when worn cross body.

I like the first bag, as carried by the model in the white dress. I am guessing she is taller than the person with the yellow and blue outfit.

Proportion between the bag and the person wearing it is very important. If this bag came in two sizes, I would get the smaller one.

I also don't like it as a crossbody. I am not sure if it could be worn as a shoulder bag due to the petals.

Yuck to all three

I really like the first bag.

Do you want something you can wear crossbody? The first seems too big. Maybe a Fleuron Swann.

https://us.fleuron.paris/products/sac-a-main-swann-espresso?pr_prod_strat=jac&pr_rec_id=edc16d6e7&pr_rec_pid=10088249524557&pr_ref_pid=4652862013491&pr_seq=uniform

Or if you want a tote, look at the Coach Gramercy or Brooklyn, or a DeMillier New York tote.

The tote isxreeally big unless you want a tote not a purse.
I do not like the bucket bag.
The first one is a bit big too. It will be heavy.

Definitely the first one. It's like a tulip! But I wouldn't wear it crossbody - I would carry it on my wrist.

I love the flower bag (first one), and definitely don't read it in the same way as a PP

Start all over these are all horrible

There is something a bit vaginal about the top one. I wouldn’t get it and I don’t like the others.

I've been looking for a new bag but I hate all three.

Melie Bianco

I prefer the color above but here’s the model shots:





Longchamp Bucket:



Or ..

Go for a big tote: